Tree ID - Is this a Stag's Horn Sumac?

Started by Common_Clay, October 25, 2007, 17:56:14

Previous topic - Next topic

Common_Clay

Hi,
 
  Could anyone please confirm if this is a Stag's Horn Sumac (Rhus Typhina)? I found that variety in a book but the picture is small and looks slightly different from the ones in the links. Also, while I'm at it, can anyone recommend a good tree identification book, preferably small enough to go in a bag or pocket? Many thanks.

http://bp3.blogger.com/_rih0ykyhU0s/RyDIaXnkSAI/AAAAAAAAAAk/XpmWxLY_Sqo/s1600-h/October+2007+063+smaller.jpg

http://bp0.blogger.com/_rih0ykyhU0s/RyDIennkSBI/AAAAAAAAAAs/j-gon8SGjI4/s1600-h/October+2007+066+smaller.jpg

Common_Clay


Common_Clay

I think it is, I did a google search and it looks very similar, although the photograph I took doesn't show much of a 'trunk', whereas pictures on line show it to look more like a tree.

Obelixx

Yes it is.  Some do grow like this - short and shrubby and suckering with gay abandon.   Some get taller and grow proper trunks but I suspect this happpens best when suckers are ruthlessy hacked.
Obxx - Vendée France

kenkew

Also check out Chinese Ceder. Are the leaves toothed along the edge?

star

Stags horn are notorious for suckering, they will start off fine as a small tree, but any damage to roots will encourage this suckering habit.

Lilacs do the same......

It definatly looks like you have a stags horn sumach there ;)
I was born with nothing and have most of it left.

Common_Clay

That's interesting about the way the trunk grows, thanks for the replies, I'm quite pleased that I actually managed to identify a tree correctly without too much trouble!  :)

SueSteve

They were making rosehip and sumac sorbet on Radio 4 earlier, I missed most of it though, as i was hopping in and out of the van making deliveries!
Sue
Lottie at Upton St Leonards, Gloucester
Lottie owner since 11th April 2007.
Still in the plot   36 Leeks, 1x rows parsnips, 2x  rows chard, psb, broccoli, 5 rows garlic, 1 row swede, lots of onions - started in rows, but the birds had them and now they are random!!

Common_Clay

Really? I wonder what part of the tree is edible. I don't suppose you remember the programme or what time roughly you heard it? I might be able to find it repeated on the BBC Radio 4 website. Thanks.  :)

Powered by EzPortal