Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows talk here!

Started by Heldi, July 21, 2007, 00:31:51

Previous topic - Next topic

Heldi

SPOILER SPOILER SPOILER.

You know what I thought today...wouldn't it have been good to have had a conversation between Harry and Snape's portrait in the headmaster's office. Snape will have one now won't he!

Yes I would've liked a bit more closure on Lupin and Tonks.  I guess making Harry Godfather was a disaster waiting to happen lol.  Lupin was a great character and I think he deserved a good sent off !

There was a moment where I was wondering if Dumbledore was a dark wizard himself...wondered exactly what he had been up to with all the secrets he had kept from Harry.  I think I forgave Dumbledoreafter Harry realised he had had to come to the conclusions by himself and definately forgave his weaknesses after Harry had his conversation with him in the heavenly Kings Cross .

The nineteen years later..."Albus Severus"... thought that was poop tbh. That,s all we got to explain Harry's thoughts on Snape. Hope Albus Severus ends up in Slytherin haha!

My son and his friends call me Professor McGonagall.  :o  ;)  ;D



Heldi


kitten

* * SPOILER * * SPOILER * *

Yeah, we never got to find out what happened to McGonagall either (I wanted her to be the new headmistress  ;) ) nor Hagrid.

Agree re Dumbledore (think I mentioned it in an earlier post actually...) but I defo forgave him in the end - he did seem genuinely sorry for what he'd done

I was a bit disappointed in the final chapter the more I think about it actually.  What a shame - I'll still read it again in a couple of months and watch it in the cinema when it comes out  ;D  ;D
Don't cry because it's over, smile because it happened

cambourne7

HI Guys,

Found this link http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HfquI8uvPEg

JK reading the first chapter on the release night.

Dont the kids look young or is it just me?

Cambourne7

posie

Yep I thought the 19 years later bit was pants too. End of the book seemed a bit rushed to me, like she'd just got totally fed up with it.  Mind you leaves it wide open for Son/Daughter of Harry Potter I spose!
What I lack in ability and experience, I make up for in sheer enthusiasm!!!

scotch-mist

Yipeeeeeeeeee,
         Finally got my copy, Got my act together,
Tied the weans to their beds (only kidding) ;D ;D ;D
and I'm now at chapter 12 ;)

Got to go, I'm getting withdrawal symptions and need to read a bit more before bed ;D ;D ;D
UNDER PRESSURE (constantly)

kitten

Ooooh do hurry up and finish it so we can start gossiping about it with ya  ;D
Don't cry because it's over, smile because it happened

Heldi


kitten

hmmmmmm interesting indeed but i'd have preferred some of that info in the final chapter tbh, or is it me?   ;D  ;D
Don't cry because it's over, smile because it happened

Heldi

I reckon there must be quite a few of us feeling a bit bewildered  ??? by the last chapter if JK is having to answer those type of questions.

Feel a bit cynical about the encyclopedia really.

But I still think it's a cracking good story !  ;D

kitten

Agree with all of that heldi  ;D  I do love the story as a whole too, the movie will be good as well  ;)
Don't cry because it's over, smile because it happened

Powered by EzPortal