As part of the seed saving circle I received some of both of these toms.
The Yellow Furry Hogs all seem to have the same 'pepper leaf' shaped leaf; whereas some of the Scotias have normal tomato type leave but some have the exact same leaf as the Yellow Furry Hogs.
Obviously, it's noticeable because of the leaf shape - but has anyone else sowed these from the circle last year? And are you getting the same leaf shapes?
I grew Scotia and Yellow Furry Hog last year, from memory Scotia is a bush variety with regular leaves. I know we had Silach as I remember bagging them up for Ruud, but I didn't think we had Scotia in the circle? Unless I slipped up big time and added some by mistake :o
YFH is a cordon with I think a regular leaf too,but I'll go and have a look at mine in the morning, although I think I used my seed and not from the circle, so may not be much help.
There seems to be confusion about the name either YFG or FYH, but IDIG forum information and Tatiana's tomato base information agree that this tomato is regular leafed, not potato leafed. Not quite sure what pepper leafed is, but guess round with a point and not very indented. Scotia was not in my circle bag either. Scotia is regular leafed also according to Tatiana's. Will check tomorrow when it is light what my Circle Hogs are looking like, but pretty sure they are regular leafed.
I cant speak for scotia as that wasn't in my bag, but re the YFH the plant I have growing looks like a potato leaf to me; actually, pepper leaf is a good description, given what it looked like at the weekend.
I would never rule out my own human error normally, as I sow into module trays which - personally speaking - I find a bit fiddly sometimes, but this plant seemed to fit the "late" description as it was one of the slower developers, so I obviously overlooked the leaves! :)
Cheers all - I'll take a photo in a bit of a line of the furry hogs and a line of the scotias....I definitely got some scotias in the circle as I had a bag of the circle ones in my box, and a bag of them in the schools box [as donated by the lovely Jayb].
I've got the flu at the mo so going out and lining up plants and taking photos is not number one on my list - perhaps by 11 I'll have summoned up enough energy.
I did look onlike at furry hogs and couldn't see a pic of the leaves so couldn't make the connection there....
Still only seed leaves here,I am guessing you have taken a peek at Dave's Garden-sorry links like most things are beyond me!
Although there are no pictures of leaves it does say " regular" but in a comment it also talks about it's crosses that include the potato leaf types -so could get interesting..............
Quote from: galina on April 05, 2011, 23:42:56
Will check tomorrow when it is light what my Circle Hogs are looking like, but pretty sure they are regular leafed.
Just as well to check rather than try and remember - mine are definitely potato leafed (pepper leafed) and not regular leafed. Nice strong plants.
Quote from: aj on April 06, 2011, 08:00:44I've got the flu at the mo so going out and lining up plants and taking photos is not number one on my list - perhaps by 11 I'll have summoned up enough energy.
Hope you feel better soon. x
Quote from: galina on April 06, 2011, 10:07:13
Quote from: aj on April 06, 2011, 08:00:44I've got the flu at the mo so going out and lining up plants and taking photos is not number one on my list - perhaps by 11 I'll have summoned up enough energy.
Hope you feel better soon. x
Thanks! Will be braving the greenhouse to take photos shortly.......
I've had to put the photos on my blog as I haven't taken the relevant 'how to' put a gallery up on here...it kept saying I had to pick a category from no options.....anyhoodles
http://linearlegume.blogspot.com/
My main concern is - has the furry hog cross-fertilised with the original scotias or just a few seeds got mixed up [which I can't see to be honest, as a seedsmith myself, it's quite hard to do unless you lose it for a while or the other half mixes drying trays up]....
And if it has cross-fertilised, do we need to be concerned about this happening with this year's furries?
Quote from: aj on April 06, 2011, 11:10:33
I've had to put the photos on my blog as I haven't taken the relevant 'how to' put a gallery up on here...it kept saying I had to pick a category from no options.....anyhoodles
http://linearlegume.blogspot.com/
My main concern is - has the furry hog cross-fertilised with the original scotias or just a few seeds got mixed up [which I can't see to be honest, as a seedsmith myself, it's quite hard to do unless you lose it for a while or the other half mixes drying trays up]....
And if it has cross-fertilised, do we need to be concerned about this happening with this year's furries?
I share your concern, but can't comment on the Scotia. If we have furry hogs with the wrong type of leaves, they may not be hogs at all. Simple mix-up that could have happened several years and several seed donors ago.
If they should be (as several websites say) regular leafed, there is some question mark if we all see potato leaves. PL is a recessive trait and in the first generation after a cross the dominant appearance will show (RL) and not the recessive (PL). If a cross had happened it would have been further back in time. Or the breeder bred both versions.
In both cases we need to wait and compare the end result. Human error does happen. It just means not passing on any seeds with that name until we are sure the variety is correct.
We could ask Wild Boar Farms what the hogs should be like. And our seed donor of course.
There is one other explanation - there are spontaneous mutations from RL to PL if tomatoes are grown under very different conditions. And who knows, this may indeed have happened to the hogs we have that originated from balmy California. They would be identical in any other way. This is pretty rare, but such mutations can happen. If all our fruit look identical and exactly like photos on the web, this could have happened.
I hope my writing is making sense.
Well I do wish I'd taken in a bit more in those genetics lectures. This is fascinating stuff though, I was following- I sort of thought I was - till the bit about asking about the Hogs at Wild Boar Farm!!? :D :-[
Quote from: pumpkinlover on April 06, 2011, 13:13:48
Well I do wish I'd taken in a bit more in those genetics lectures. This is fascinating stuff though, I was following- I sort of thought I was - till the bit about asking about the Hogs at Wild Boar Farm!!? :D :-[
Yellow Furry Hog is a fairly modern tomato and was bred by the owner of Wild Boar Farms Brad Gates.
http://www.wildboarfarms.com/index.html
Unfortunately they are not on their seed list this year, this is why we would need to ask.
Cheers chuck - email duly sent...I'll copy in any response I get.
Anyone else sown these and have any true leaves yet? G'won - share your leaf shape with me - you know you wanna. :-*
Hope you feel better soon AJ, a bit harsh having flu again :(
Interestingly my little YFH is a potato leaf, I'm fairly sure it is from seed I saved in 2010 which originally came via a seed swap. A shame I can't remember the leaf type that grew last year. Also I've misplaced some growing notes from last year so no help there. I do remember it being tasty, yellow with faint stripes!
An intresting one Galina, I tend to think the name Yellow Furry Hog is most likely as both Tatiana and Baker Creek have it listed as such. From the little I know it is one of Brad Gates creations and Baker Creek sent it out as a freebie a couple of years ago, they also currently have it listed in their catalogue. I don't know for another source.
I've had a think and the seeds (from Ruud) sent out for the circle will all have a typed name within the little bag the seeds are in. Each variety was bagged separately and the table wiped down between varieties. I'm fairly certain the seed you received are the seeds I was sent. Perhaps, when you are feeling a little better, you could check the seeds from the circle bag to see if it has a typed or hand written label. I can't think how Scotia would have been added instead of Silach, I have some spare ones here if you would like me to send them on to you.
I saved the Scotia seeds last year which I sent you for the schools, the blossoms for these were not bagged. They were defo a bush variety, I'll have a look through my pictures and see if I have one of Scotia. Looking at your picture it looks most likely you have 2 types on the go so it would seem the naughty plants were crossed, I grew several potato leaf varieties. Gosh, wonder what will develop, ;D I'm going to have to sow some now just to see.
I think I still have a spare pack of YFH from the circle I'll set some to germinate and see if they are all potato leaf type, I'll do some of mine too, be nice to know.
I've just me bags out and can only find one Scotia.....but of course I do have seeds everywhere.
::)
I'm not worried about having more seeds [honest] - I'm more trying to work out whether the seeds would have got mixed up, which is sounds as if they definitely wouldn't have....or if anyone else has the same mix of scotias!
I agree, if it isn't a seed mix up as they are from completely different sources then hurrah!!! It's very obvious this year as the YFHs are growing vigorously, even more so that any others......and the 'pepper leaf scotias' are also growing at the same rate. I'm not calling it potato leaf as sorry, it's a pepper leaf!
We'll have to wait and see what occurs.
I'll sow a pot of Scotias and let you know how they pan out.
On the Furry Hog theme;
I made a mistake Baker Creek list their seeds as Furry Yellow Hog.
I'm also growing Red Furry Boar this year (although they don't seem very furry the momment) to see how they compare, leaves are regular type. This ones name again seems to interchange between Red Furry Boar and Furry Red Boar?!
Wild Boar Farms list some of their seeds through Local Harvest and have RFB and Yellow Furry Boar listed, I wonder if this is YFH. Hopefully AJ will get a reply to her email.
Quote from: Jayb on April 07, 2011, 10:38:50
Wild Boar Farms list some of their seeds through Local Harvest and have RFB and Yellow Furry Boar listed, I wonder if this is YFH. Hopefully AJ will get a reply to her email.
That is very interesting. The plot thickens :) - Local Harvest list Yellow Furry Boar and say that this variety is
potato leafed! Are we by any chance growing boars and not hogs?
Yes I too hope all will be made clear and aj will get a reply soon.
http://www.localharvest.org/rare-tomato-seeds-yellow-furry-boar-C7800
Bang.
That was my brain going.
I can't wait to get some flippin fruit from these!
Quote from: aj on April 07, 2011, 16:08:56
Bang.
That was my brain going.
I can't wait to get some flippin fruit from these!
And breathe AJ, breathe ;) ;D
I hope you like them ;D
And cos I'm a real tomato saddo, I've just ordered Furry Yellow Hog from Baker Creek. They are not the speediest on delivery, so possibly too late for them to grow into much this year, but I will sow a few just to see what leaf form :P
;)
Just the sort of saddo we love!!!
They will probably arrive before the email ::)
Still no email.
Just saying like. :(
The first set of true leaves are pepper pointy just like yours ..
Ooh - thanks for that!
Was thinking it was just me :D
Interesting development.....
I now have 3 Galina toms with the exact same pepper leaf. :-\
Hi aj,
Galina - the tomato, that is - is definitely potato-leaved; I double checked this with realseed when I grew them for the first time as they didn't mention it on their website, so I don't think it's contagious ! :)
Wrt the yellow furry hogs, everyone so far seems to have the same leaf type: does anyone else have anything to report?
Sue
These aren't potato leaved - they are pepper leaved....
I'm a bit slow with this but I've just sown some scotia just so I know, wouldn't want to pass anymore of these on it they are not what they should be :-[
Also sown some of Ruuds Yellow Furry Hogs, some of my saved YFH and today Furry Yellow Hogs from Baker Creek arrived so they have been sown too, will report on leaf shape in a wee while. Hopefully just enough time to get a few ripe fruit from one of each to compare.
I know the fruit is meant to be slightly fuzzy, I'm wondering if the leaves should be to? Mine weren't last year. Anyone got fuzzy/furry leafed hogs?
Quote from: Jayb on April 30, 2011, 17:07:07
I know the fruit is meant to be slightly fuzzy, I'm wondering if the leaves should be to? Mine weren't last year. Anyone got fuzzy/furry leafed hogs?
Didn't think the leaves should be, just the fruit. There are no fuzzy or furry leaves here. Will keep an eye on them and report if they turn furry when they are getting more mature plants. At the moment they are seedlings ready to be planted out in the greenhouse, but I am still hesitating to take the plunge. It is comforting to know that I could just hoik them off the bench and take them indoors if we get frosts.
aj, did you ever get a reply?
Nope.
Just keeping an eye on them all and will report back when I get fruit showing. It could be a genetic quirk or a simple seed mix-up. Nothing ventured nothing gained!!!
I think you are right no reports of furry leaves, I think it is me geting carried away with woolly/furry varieties, I think they are simply gorgeous ;D
[attachment=2]
Seeds sown =
10 Scotia seedlings all with regular leaves
10 Ruuds Y Furry Hogs all Potato leaf
10 saved (mine) YFH's from 2010 all potao leaf
8 Baker Creek Furry Yellow Hogs all regular leaf :o
I'll let you know how the fruits compare in a wee while.......
Now what to do, anyone want some seedlings?
Now what to do, anyone want some seedlings?.... ;D... ;)
Quote from: Jayb on May 14, 2011, 11:27:40
Seeds sown =
10 Scotia seedlings all with regular leaves
10 Ruuds Y Furry Hogs all Potato leaf
10 saved (mine) YFH's from 2010 all potao leaf
8 Baker Creek Furry Yellow Hogs all regular leaf :o
I'll let you know how the fruits compare in a wee while.......
OK, we have ripe outdoor fruit! They are nice tasting. Other websites have remarked on a citrussy flavour and that is definitely there. Others have remarked that this one is late. Not ours - vigorous and early.
But - furry they are not. I am growing Garden Peach this year too, which looks exactly like an apricot, and that one IS furry. Gently rubbing both against my lips, and a definitely NOT furry tomato variety for comparison, shows that it is not furry. It does have shiny skin - unlike garden peach which is matte.
How are the others out there doing?
Galina, you made me laugh. I have this picture in my head of you standing in your garden kissing tomatoes.
XX Jeannine
Quote from: Jeannine on August 18, 2011, 18:29:23
Galina, you made me laugh. I have this picture in my head of you standing in your garden kissing tomatoes.
XX Jeannine
Yep - that's just abouth how it was ;D
We definitely love our tomatoes ;D
http://www.flickr.com/photos/55414761@N05/6242871957/
I have Yellow Furry Hogs, from a plant that had Yellow furry Hogs on the label. ;D
aj,
your fruits look furry! By contrast, mine were bright yellow, rather than yellow with apricot hues and they were not furry. They were also larger and had a really strong citrussy 'bite' - very unexpected but quite delicious.
Thanks for showing us.
They are indeed peachy. :o
Will be saving seed, natch.
Lovely pictures, they look scrummy toms aj. Were they peachy tasting too?
The plant I grew out has produced slightly fuzzy yellow fruit, not peachy coloured at all. Flavour is good. I'm afraid the Furry yellow Hog from Bakers Creek got zapped by blight so not really able to do a comparason. I'll hopefully try again next year.
I've some saved seeds of these or a few spare from Baker Creek if either of you would like.
Edit to add; just took these pictures before they get roasted for pasata :)
i prefer the tomato Wapsipinicon Peach , do to the fact that tomato fruit is fuzzy like a peach.
Quote from: Jayb on October 14, 2011, 16:39:54
Lovely pictures, they look scrummy toms aj. Were they peachy tasting too?
Yours look lovely - mine haven't been eaten yet. I have to deseed them first, and I still have 3 lots drying out in trays so I'll do them tomorrow. They did look amazing sat there behind some pepper leaves, i was taken aback a bit when I saw them.