Allotments 4 All

Photo Gallery => The Gallery => Topic started by: Common_Clay on October 25, 2007, 17:56:14

Title: Tree ID - Is this a Stag's Horn Sumac?
Post by: Common_Clay on October 25, 2007, 17:56:14
Hi,
 
  Could anyone please confirm if this is a Stag's Horn Sumac (Rhus Typhina)? I found that variety in a book but the picture is small and looks slightly different from the ones in the links. Also, while I'm at it, can anyone recommend a good tree identification book, preferably small enough to go in a bag or pocket? Many thanks.

http://bp3.blogger.com/_rih0ykyhU0s/RyDIaXnkSAI/AAAAAAAAAAk/XpmWxLY_Sqo/s1600-h/October+2007+063+smaller.jpg

http://bp0.blogger.com/_rih0ykyhU0s/RyDIennkSBI/AAAAAAAAAAs/j-gon8SGjI4/s1600-h/October+2007+066+smaller.jpg
Title: Re: Tree ID - Is this a Stag's Horn Sumac?
Post by: Common_Clay on October 26, 2007, 07:29:33
I think it is, I did a google search and it looks very similar, although the photograph I took doesn't show much of a 'trunk', whereas pictures on line show it to look more like a tree.
Title: Re: Tree ID - Is this a Stag's Horn Sumac?
Post by: Obelixx on October 26, 2007, 08:43:42
Yes it is.  Some do grow like this - short and shrubby and suckering with gay abandon.   Some get taller and grow proper trunks but I suspect this happpens best when suckers are ruthlessy hacked.
Title: Re: Tree ID - Is this a Stag's Horn Sumac?
Post by: kenkew on October 26, 2007, 15:21:22
Also check out Chinese Ceder. Are the leaves toothed along the edge?
Title: Re: Tree ID - Is this a Stag's Horn Sumac?
Post by: star on October 26, 2007, 18:14:46
Stags horn are notorious for suckering, they will start off fine as a small tree, but any damage to roots will encourage this suckering habit.

Lilacs do the same......

It definatly looks like you have a stags horn sumach there ;)
Title: Re: Tree ID - Is this a Stag's Horn Sumac?
Post by: Common_Clay on October 26, 2007, 18:50:22
That's interesting about the way the trunk grows, thanks for the replies, I'm quite pleased that I actually managed to identify a tree correctly without too much trouble!  :)
Title: Re: Tree ID - Is this a Stag's Horn Sumac?
Post by: SueSteve on October 26, 2007, 19:00:50
They were making rosehip and sumac sorbet on Radio 4 earlier, I missed most of it though, as i was hopping in and out of the van making deliveries!
Title: Re: Tree ID - Is this a Stag's Horn Sumac?
Post by: Common_Clay on October 28, 2007, 13:42:00
Really? I wonder what part of the tree is edible. I don't suppose you remember the programme or what time roughly you heard it? I might be able to find it repeated on the BBC Radio 4 website. Thanks.  :)