Allotments 4 All

Produce => Recipes => Topic started by: daisymay on November 29, 2006, 13:29:30

Title: not very tasty pumpkin
Post by: daisymay on November 29, 2006, 13:29:30
hi

cut into one of our jack o lantern pumpkins and the flesh is quite soft and it tastes earthy and fusty (if that is a word!) - really quite unplesant.

Do you think they have gone off a bit maybe? very firm on the outside still - seemed fine. They have been in the shed (with the sprouting carrots  :() so guess they could also be a bit warm???

Not much we can do short of keeping them in the fridge in the garage only place we have cooler than the shed!
Title: Re: not very tasty pumpkin
Post by: saddad on November 29, 2006, 18:21:52
We grew Fester which was watery and insipid... have they been tainted? Some things pick up flavours... shouldn't keep my quince and apples in the same place but don't have two stores.
???
Title: Re: not very tasty pumpkin
Post by: Mrs Ava on November 29, 2006, 22:16:59
Did it smell of mildew?  I had some that although they were still firm, they probably weren't properly seasoned and the flesh had started to go mouldy.  Couldn't see it, but could smell and taste it.  Also had a couple that were as bitter as hell and I put that down to cross pollination or something along those lines, similar to the problem with bitter cucumbers...... :-\  What a shame!
Title: Re: not very tasty pumpkin
Post by: jennym on November 29, 2006, 23:21:33
Think EJ is right, and it'd started to go off. Also word of caution for those like me who are storing their hoard on the stairs, do check them regularly for any signs of softness. Someone gave me a pumpkin to try, I put it with the others - 2 weeks later a foul mushy mess on the carpet one morning - yuk!
I find the best way to store squash is suspended in nets in the shed, but suppose I'm lucky as my shed is quite cool.
Title: Re: not very tasty pumpkin
Post by: supersprout on November 29, 2006, 23:33:56
yes I'd suspect EJ is right too. When a squash decides to go, it goes fast - jenny, if you ever come visiting, I can show you the very spot on the stairs where one of me pumpkins imploded last week yurrrrgh >:( :P
Title: Re: not very tasty pumpkin
Post by: jennym on November 29, 2006, 23:49:22
I'm still scrubbing at my stain too  ;D
Title: Re: not very tasty pumpkin
Post by: Curryandchips on November 30, 2006, 00:10:48
Just as an aside ... don't they pong when they implode ... mine have always been in the shed or greenhouse, so any smells have had a chance to waft away ...
Title: Re: not very tasty pumpkin
Post by: jennym on November 30, 2006, 00:18:14
By the time I noticed anything, it was too late!
Title: Re: not very tasty pumpkin
Post by: Curryandchips on November 30, 2006, 00:22:49
Well that may explain why businesses only concentrate on pumpkins for halloween, they may become a liability after that. I cannot see myself growing pumpkins again, now I am aware of the superior taste from winter squash, although the pumpkins did provide me with awesome quantities of curry sauce ...
Title: Re: not very tasty pumpkin
Post by: daisymay on November 30, 2006, 16:07:43
thanks for the replies.... yes - they do smelll damp and mildew like - got another one yesterday and it is the same too..... will def stick to squashes next year also! butter nuts in the shed are still looking great and made the nicest roast butternut and sweetcorn soup for lunch today  :)

I think I picked them too early, although they were on a sunny window ledge for about 3 -4 weeks (until they had gone completely orange and their skins seemed a bit tougher), but guess it was not long enough!
Title: Re: not very tasty pumpkin
Post by: Merry Tiller on December 01, 2006, 01:24:07
QuoteI cannot see myself growing pumpkins again, now I am aware of the superior taste from winter squash

Aren't pumpkins just another type of winter squash?
Title: Re: not very tasty pumpkin
Post by: supersprout on December 01, 2006, 08:27:25
I thought you'd never ask MT ;)

In a way, yes. Pumkin and squash belong to the genus cucurbitae, related to cucs, melons, gourds and luffas. Surprisingly, the fruit is strictly speaking a berry :o a simple fruit with pulpy flesh that doesn't split to reveal the seeds.

Depending which Booke you consult, there are between 20 and 27 different species.
The three main species of cucurbitae are:
C. maxima - large, corky or spongy stems which are roundy and larger at the base
C. moschata - stems angled and fleshy, rather than rounded and ropy, opening out towards the fruit, becoming star-shaped and knobby
C. pepo - stems ridged all around, widening slightly at the base.

All pumpkins and squash fit into five horticultural groups which the seed catalogues use:

Summer squash (all C.pepo) - eaten when immature. Courgette/zucchini, crookneck, round courgette, and pattypans.
Autumn Squash (all pepo) - squash eaten when mature but not stored for more than two months. Acorn squash, spaghetti squash, marrow.
Winter squash (all maxima and moschata) - keeping qualities up to a year. Several groups e.g. butternuts, hubbards, kabocha, sweet potato squash etc. They have a strong, distinctive flavour that stands well on its own, unlike most pumpkins which are more watery and have a grainier or fibrous texture.
Pumpkins (mainly pepo but include a few maxima) - rounded shape and yellow to orange colour. Many have a yellow gene that ensures early yellowing.
Ornamental Gourds (all the inedible and some edible pepo, some maxima) - grown for decoration. Includes the smallest (edible) pumpkins e.g. Jack-be-little, and Turk's Turban.

For the curious:
Butternut, Black Futsu are moschata.
Delicata, Jaspee de Vendee are pepo.
Buttercup, Crown Prince, Hubbard, Queensland Blue, Kuri are maxima.
Atlantic Giant, Big Max, Rouge Vif d'Etampes pumkins are maxima.

So yes, some pumpkins are the same genus as some of the most delicious winter squash, but different ::)

The distinction is helpful in the kitchen too. Pumpkins are good for soups and pies, winter squash IMO stand alone for flavour and texture.

8)
Title: Re: not very tasty pumpkin
Post by: Curryandchips on December 01, 2006, 08:55:13
Quote from: supersprout on December 01, 2006, 08:27:25
The distinction is helpful in the kitchen too. Pumpkins are good for soups and pies, winter squash IMO stand alone for flavour and texture.

I agree entirely ...
Title: Re: not very tasty pumpkin
Post by: Andy H on December 01, 2006, 14:34:47
All my marrows have gone orange and hard???

What is that all about? Was it because the pumpkins were also in the garage with them?
Title: Re: not very tasty pumpkin
Post by: saddad on December 01, 2006, 18:48:40
Just ripening... Andy, the hard skin carries it through the winter and the sudden soggy collapse gives the new plant a drink to get started!
8)
Title: Re: not very tasty pumpkin
Post by: Andy H on December 01, 2006, 19:51:02
Do they always go orange or sometmes stay green and go mushy?
Title: Re: not very tasty pumpkin
Post by: mc55 on December 01, 2006, 21:03:08
I went to check my butternuts tonight and picked up a particularly nice looking one only to discover its gone mouldy at the back of the neck where its been hidden from view ... have chopped off offending mush and will roast rest of it tomorrow.  God I hope the rest are OK through the winter.

Title: Re: not very tasty pumpkin
Post by: Mrs Ava on December 01, 2006, 23:16:33
Some stay green Andy - mine have this time.  And yes, boy do they collapse when you least expect it.  The first I know about it is when the kids come tearing in from the conservatory screaming that the pumpkins have gone rotten and leaked all over the floor!
Title: Re: not very tasty pumpkin
Post by: Curryandchips on December 01, 2006, 23:32:18
Leaky pumpkins would not go down well here !!! Since my main use of pumpkins was curry sauce (12 gallons one year?) and this year I produced a superior sauce from green tomatoes, I think the tomatoes will win out (since the red ones are lovely too !). I will be growing the squashes of course (varieties as I can get hold of) and also considering any other exciting veg to trial ... I watch all these threads for interesting ideas !
Title: Re: not very tasty pumpkin
Post by: Andy H on December 01, 2006, 23:35:24
Yeah firm firm firm BANG gunge :-\
Title: Re: not very tasty pumpkin
Post by: artichoke on December 05, 2006, 13:16:40
Hello, Supersprout, thank you, a very useful list distinguishing various cucurbit species and cultivars. Just one thing:

The FAMILY is CUCURBITACEAE

The GENUS is Cucurbita

The SPECIES are all, as you say,  Cucurbita pepoC. moschata etc.

Sorry....as a botanical illustrator I have illustrated masses of different Cucurbitaceae species for Kew specialists and others, and I had to use these distinctions carefully.
Title: Re: not very tasty pumpkin
Post by: supersprout on December 05, 2006, 15:40:19
 :-[
Now I know better! :P ;)
I bet that was a wonderful job drawing all those cucurbitaceae (great word for scrabble) ;D ;D ;D
Title: Re: not very tasty pumpkin
Post by: Squashfan on December 07, 2006, 16:19:25
 I came back from hols recently to a pumpkin rotting on my counter. Yucky  :-X! I may take care of a few more this weekend as they are getting in the way now.
Title: Re: not very tasty pumpkin
Post by: supersprout on December 07, 2006, 17:24:11
When you say 'take care of' .... what lies in store for them squashmad?
(no pun intended) ;D ;D ;D