Allotments 4 All

Produce => Edible Plants => Topic started by: tonyveggie on November 03, 2006, 14:00:15

Title: Can I plant shallots now???
Post by: tonyveggie on November 03, 2006, 14:00:15
I've just recieved some shallot sets and two varieties of garlic (purple wight and elephant). I know I can plant the garlic about now but the instructions that came with them say to store in a cool light place and sow in March/April.

I've read some posts here which suggest that shallots planted now will grow as spring onions.

Is it worth planting them now? I've just taken on my plot and would love to be growing something over the winter other than green manure!
Title: Re: Can I plant shallots now???
Post by: supersprout on November 03, 2006, 14:24:22
our site rep says, plant shallots on the shortest day, harvest on the longest ::)
in my mum's Northumberland veg garden, they went out in March. Here in Peterborough I've just planted ten - they were in the garlic bag so I just kept going :P
Hope this isn't going to lead to  :'( ???
Title: Re: Can I plant shallots now???
Post by: flowerlady on November 03, 2006, 15:02:24
Quote from: supersprout on November 03, 2006, 14:24:22
... ...  plant shallots on the shortest day, harvest on the longest ::)
... ...

I go with that too  ;)
Title: Re: Can I plant shallots now???
Post by: cambourne7 on November 03, 2006, 15:15:40
Hi

I went up to the allotment on tuesday after having the flu jab and planted Garlic and Japanese onion seed.

feel very happy that i have done this now.

cambourne7
Title: Re: Can I plant shallots now???
Post by: Larkspur on November 03, 2006, 18:26:25
Hi, its a bit early yet. Mid to late winter is more usual. I normally put mine in during a mild spell in January.
Title: Re: Can I plant shallots now???
Post by: tim on November 03, 2006, 18:35:27
Surely a waste of good seed to grow shallots as Spring Onions?

And, for what its worth, I have never strayed from the 'book' teaching of February - April. There's no rush?
Title: Re: Can I plant shallots now???
Post by: supersprout on November 03, 2006, 18:38:46
oh dang :-\ :-[
well it's only ten ::)
Title: Re: Can I plant shallots now???
Post by: tonyveggie on November 03, 2006, 18:47:45
Cheers

I'll put the garlic in this weekend and try to resist the temptation to plan the shallots too. I like the idea of gardening according to wisdom handed down the generations so I'll try planting as near to the longest day and see what happens - lots of  :D and not any  :'(

Tim - no, no rush: just recieved my first sets in the post this morning and am keen to get planting! I agree with you about the planting shallots for spring onions, rather wait for the shallots.

supersprout - never mind, you don't know what'll grow, and if not, it's only 10 like you say

Title: Re: Can I plant shallots now???
Post by: tim on November 03, 2006, 19:02:49
In the end, everything is possible?
Title: Re: Can I plant shallots now???
Post by: cambourne7 on November 03, 2006, 19:23:35
Quote from: tim on November 03, 2006, 19:02:49
In the end, everything is possible?

and life will find a way.