Allotments 4 All

Produce => Edible Plants => Topic started by: dingerbell on August 08, 2005, 20:55:54

Title: Tomato Disaster
Post by: dingerbell on August 08, 2005, 20:55:54
My outdoor tomatoes were looking fantastic but suddenly leaves are going brown and curling up and the fruit has gone from green to nasty brown :-[
What's going wrong??  Help please :'(
Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: Derekthefox on August 08, 2005, 21:03:51
My immediate reaction is that you have got the blight. If so, then that is the end of your plants I believe. Lets see if anyone else has other ideas.   :(
Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: plot51A on August 08, 2005, 22:20:17
Went down to my lottie this evening after being away for a few days. Have lost ALL my tomato plants to the dreaded blight - disaster is the only way to describe it! Had some slight signs 3/4 weeks ago. decided to spray but wasn't able to do so after the last rain we had last week. I didn't realise it could strike so quickly and so completely. Probably the reason why nobody on my lotties seems to grow them.
Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: Jill on August 08, 2005, 23:40:03
Have to say it does sound like the dreaded blight.  Commiserations, it got my toms that way last year.  Now grow in pots at home where so far toms and pots have been blight-free.
Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: Trenchboy on August 08, 2005, 23:52:22
It seems that once an allotment site is hit by blight or carrot fly or whatever, it stays infected.

Certainly our site doesn't support tomatoes, though so far mine at home are looking ok. It's a real sickener when something you've toiled over turns to mush. Memo to self - avoid children in the next life/incarnation.

Hope all your other stuff stays fit and well.

Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: tim on August 09, 2005, 06:13:02
There but for the grace of God...........................................
Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: beejay on August 09, 2005, 07:54:55
Lost most of our toms to blight 2 & 3 years ago, but then last year one of the best crops ever. So not total doom & gloom, depends on weather conditions I believe but the worry is always there.
Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: aquilegia on August 09, 2005, 09:22:59
Oh Dinger, my sympathy goes out to you. Mine had blight last year - it is nasty.
Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: quinny on August 09, 2005, 09:59:32
My toms have little black specks on them - gritty looking - do you guys think that's the dreaded lurgy also?
Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: dingerbell on August 09, 2005, 13:25:46
 :'( Months of hard slog down the Gurgler.
Do I have to destroy ALL my plants or is there any possibility that those not yet affected maight be spared....They're all loaded with fruit :'(  Maybe some Green Tomato Chutney before they succumb :-\
There are 3 different varieties and some look worse than others. Some are As yet, un affected. Am I grabbingg at straws?? :-\
Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: Jill on August 09, 2005, 19:33:48
DB it's awful, isn't it.  Afraid to say when I tried rescuing the few remaining healthy looking tomatoes from my blight infested plants, I found that within a day or so of picking they still started turning brown.  Mine were all the same variety though.
Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: the_snail on August 10, 2005, 05:39:17
There is NO reason why you should not grow outdoor tommies on your allotment. There are allot of varaities that are resistant to many diseases like blight! If they can cultivate a blite resistant potatoe then a tomatoe is simple, they both belong to the same family! The potatoe is solaneace tuberosus and the tomatoe was once known as Solanum lycopersicon but now is more commonly known as Lycopersicon esculentum which is the common generic variety.

If you would like to try tomatoes then please try a variety that is not prone to blight, or try some in grow bags planted in a shielded area like between some runner beans or your peas.

Hope that helps:)

The_Sexy_Snail (aka The_Snail)
Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: plot51A on August 10, 2005, 07:45:07
Can you give us a bit more info Snail - like which varieties? I was growing 8 different varieties including Gardeners Delight, Ailsa Craig, Sunburst - all recommended for outdoors. Would love to try blight resistant varieties after this years experience.
Thanks very much.
Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: the_snail on August 10, 2005, 08:14:24
I have never realy grown a outdoor tomatoe. My advice would be to snuggle back on a cold winters day with a glass of mulled wine, and with a good seed catalogue and give it a bit of thought.

Sorry could not help more

The_Snail
Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: jennym on August 10, 2005, 08:17:59
If you pick healthy looking unblemished green tomatoes from plants when the blight first hits, you can save them by taking them home, washing them thoroughly - use a little drop of bleach or campden tablet in the water, rinse very, very, very thoroughly and allow to dry. This kills off any of the blight fungus. You must lay them out not touching to ripen, and remove any that do start to go brown.
I grow Sungold, Red Alert, Roma, gardeners delight. I understand that Ferline is said to be fairly blight resistant.
Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: the_snail on August 10, 2005, 08:33:34
Well leave it with me periwinkle like I staded I dont grow outdoors much. The best results I had when I tried The Amature (The only time I grew outdoor tomatoes) but I was not comparing it with anything.

The_Snail
Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: Robert_Brenchley on August 10, 2005, 11:05:37
I tried outdoor tomatoes the first year I had the plot, and lost the lot to blight (at least, I'm now told it was probably early blight). This year, I've finally tried again, and got a tomato jungle with masses of tomatoes coming. Even if they got blight now, I'd still get vast amounts of chutney. Keep trying, it will work in the end.
Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: jennym on August 10, 2005, 12:04:23
Quote from: Robert_Brenchley on August 10, 2005, 11:05:37
...This year, I've finally tried again, and got a tomato jungle with masses of tomatoes coming. ...
This year I planted Roma only about 15" apart and it really is a jungle, and I did it with blight in mind too. Some should protect the others I hope, if I get it.
Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: Robert_Brenchley on August 10, 2005, 12:52:15
I put mine 18 inches apart, and can see nothing but tomato leaves. There are plenty of fruit in there, but they aren't going to be easy to get to with the plants sprawling all over the place. At least they grew, that's the main thing.
Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: jennym on August 10, 2005, 12:57:24
Robert - yes, I think this is the best way.
I wish I knew how to do pictures with my messages, I've sent a Paypal payment, but still can't find out how to do it. Is there a particular thread that will help me? I am an amateur when it comes to computers.
Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: moonbells on August 10, 2005, 14:22:37
My Dad's lost all his indoor tomatoes now. He was moaning last night - everything has gone brown and the tomatoes squishy and rotten. If it's not blight then it's something darn like it... and this in a greenhouse.

Does anyone else here rely on a drip watering system for greenhouses and have problems? Dad's only seems to have hit this since he installed his...

moonbells
Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: redimp on August 10, 2005, 14:33:24
Quote from: jennym on August 10, 2005, 08:17:59
If you pick healthy looking unblemished green tomatoes from plants when the blight first hits, you can save them by taking them home, washing them thoroughly - use a little drop of bleach or campden tablet in the water, rinse very, very, very thoroughly and allow to dry. This kills off any of the blight fungus. You must lay them out not touching to ripen, and remove any that do start to go brown.
I grow Sungold, Red Alert, Roma, gardeners delight. I understand that Ferline is said to be fairly blight resistant.
If you water blight infected ground with camden, will it clean the ground of the virus?
Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: plot51A on August 10, 2005, 21:39:08
Thanks the snail and jennym. Was too depressed on Monday to think about doing anything with the green tomatoes - OH suggested Green Tomato chutney but I always think of that as a last-gasp-use-them-all-up-in-the-autumn sort of thing and the jars sit in the cupboard and don't get eaten so that was a definite no-no. Have definitely got quite a lot of green ones there so will follow your advice jennym and hope for the best.
Would windbreaks or shields help in the future? Trouble is we seem to get potato blight regularly in this area, and there are rogue pots pop up everywhere in my plot where others have grown in the past, so I don't think it's possible to find anywhere that won't have the spores in the soil. The price one pays for living in the warm but wet west I suppose but at least some other things like it
Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: Scufftastic on August 11, 2005, 09:17:14
All my tomatoes have succumbed to blight too!  They'll have to be dug up, but what's the best method of disposal of the diseased plants?
Should I burn them, or will this just release the spores into the air and condemn everyone else's tomatoes?
Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: wardy on August 11, 2005, 09:29:37
Lots of peeps toms are still green but it's still only early August so plenty of time for them to ripen yet (always optimisic I am)  :)
If soil is blighted then you can grow outdoors in growbags and containers in compost rather than your soil
I have always grown outdoor tomatoes and find them to be pest free and easier to look after but they are later to ripen which you'd expect.  The excess foliage causes problems with ripening so the foliage which has not got fruit on it has to come off.  All the plant's energies are supposed to go on creating fruit -not foliage  :)

Having said all the above, and defoliated my toms, I've still not got one ripe one yet.  I still expect great things  :)
Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: RosieM on August 11, 2005, 10:09:16
Hi All,

I have drastically reduced the density of my tomato plants this year having lost the lot last year, defoliating and trying to generally increase the airflow. I now have loads of toms, none ripe but they are finally starting to get that yellowy gold look, I'm still keeping everything crossed as the big hit last year was at the end of August so I know I'm not out of the woods yet.

I know I ought to be even more strict with the defoliation and side shoots but I can't bear to see those stringy, nude, yellowing vines even if they do have a good crop, I like to feel (and smell!) healthy green abundant leaves and don't those bush plums have a lot of them!

Good luck everyone,

Rosie
Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: wardy on August 11, 2005, 10:15:25
Yes me too Rosie.  I love healthy abundant foliage and I like the smell of tomato foliage.  Some folks hate it    So I had to be strict with myself and get rid of it  ;D
Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: Roy Bham UK on August 11, 2005, 21:37:12
Quote from: RosieM on August 11, 2005, 10:09:16
Hi All,

I have drastically reduced the density of my tomato plants this year having lost the lot last year, defoliating and trying to generally increase the airflow. I now have loads of toms, none ripe but they are finally starting to get that yellowy gold look, I'm still keeping everything crossed as the big hit last year was at the end of August so I know I'm not out of the woods yet.

I know I ought to be even more strict with the defoliation and side shoots but I can't bear to see those stringy, nude, yellowing vines even if they do have a good crop, I like to feel (and smell!) healthy green abundant leaves and don't those bush plums have a lot of them!

Good luck everyone,

Rosie

How do you go about pruning back, do you take a whole stem/stems or just cut bits off?
Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: ina on August 11, 2005, 23:18:54
Quote from: the_sexy_snail on August 10, 2005, 05:39:17
There are allot of varaities that are resistant to many diseases like blight!

The_Sexy_Snail (aka The_Snail)

So far I have only found two varieties of blight resistant tomatoes, both have been available only recently.
Dingerbells, you may want to try Ferline. Every year I lost almost all my tomatoes to blight (even tho' they were in the greenhouse) and was just about to give up on tomatoes two years ago. After I participated in the Ferline trial, my hopes returned, I had a good harvest with just a touch of blight that spread so slowly that the fruits had time to ripen (of course I removed the affected parts immediately). This year, all around on the allotment complex potato and tomato crops have been severly affected by blight, my Ferlines are still standing proud.
Next year I'm going to try Legend, also a blight resistant type.

Snail, if you know of other blight resistant tomatoes, I would be very interested.

Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: carloso on August 12, 2005, 01:52:55
yes my Ferline are doing well at this minute and i believe that my Beef toms have the dreaeded blight the leaves have started to go rusty and there always seems to be something wrong with the beef ones from the strat they also seemed to suffer from End pollock rot or something (the underneath of the Tom started to go dark and inwade as such) any way theyll not on next yrs list !!
My yellow pear seem to be doing ok at this time but dont hold ya breath lol 
The blight hit the potatoe sin my neighbours about 2 week ago so i guess im not suprised
But i have had a few toms already so ill not complain (Much)
My allotment is about clear of everything no except fruit and the odd cali and carrot as it all needed to be double dug which 75% is now completed and it can rest a bit over winter but it better be ready to start to earn its keep next yr !!

Question

would fleece keep the blight out ???

carl
Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: ina on August 12, 2005, 13:57:26
Interesting question Carl.
Somehow I don't think fleece will keep blight out, it is a micro-organism and I think that where air gets through, blight will too plus the fact that it might be in the soil waiting for a chance to pop out.
I hope there's someone who really knows it for a fact.
Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: beejay on August 12, 2005, 15:28:12
As I have always understood things, blight is airborne so fleece would not necessarily protect the plants. It can survive on old vegetation & I have always assumed not in the soil itself but I'm not sure on that. It also needs wet. I seem to remember Mr Flowerdew doing some trial a few years back erecting plastic over his outdoor toms to see if that would help (it was designed so the water run-off went to the plant roots!), but don't know what happened. As it can occur in green houses I can't see it being worth it.

You would have thought there would be more work/research on blight resistant toms.
Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: plot51A on August 12, 2005, 20:54:22
QuoteYou would have thought there would be more work/research on blight resistant toms

Couldn't agree more beejay. When I first thought I had tomato blight I searched the net extensively - came up with very little. It was all about potatoes.
Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: Robert_Brenchley on August 12, 2005, 22:42:27
Blight's a fungus which willdoubtless be spread by spores. These things are microscopic, comparable in size to a bacillus; fleece definitely won't stop them.
Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: Nathan on August 12, 2005, 23:04:46
Now now periwinkle don't diss green tomato chutney.  Just thinking about my mother-in-laws on a slab of cheshire cheese in a white bread sandwich makes my mouth water.
Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: jennym on August 13, 2005, 01:35:48
[quote author=redclanger
If you water blight infected ground with camden, will it clean the ground of the virus?


The blight is a fungus, and I imagine that the chemical acts as a sort of fungicide. Wouldn't think it would work in the soil, too much to tackle and the blight is airborne anyway. Jenny
Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: wardy on August 13, 2005, 09:23:48
I googled and found information on the HDRA sight which talks about growing in fresh compost (which Tim did) but apparently it can be spread on your boots and tools.  I've looked at most of the seed catalogues and I don't think there are any statements about any tomato variety being blight resistant, and Ferline is described as blight tolerant so, seems the best one to be growing where you've got the dreaded disease  :(
Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: beejay on August 13, 2005, 09:33:02
But does Ferline taste any good? No good growing a tom which is resistant but lacks taste.
Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: ina on August 13, 2005, 14:57:14
Of course...!  I wouldn't  grow 'em if they didn't taste any good. They have a most wonderful flavour.

PS: Wardy, look in the T&M catalogue for 'Legend tomatoes' as well, also blight resistant or tolerant whatever.
Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: Doris_Pinks on August 13, 2005, 15:03:06
Thanks to Ina this is my second year of growing Ferline, lost all my toms to blight inside and out last year, and the ferlines hung on the longest!
This year the Ferlines on my plot are holding up well, hope I haven't put the moccas on them now! :-\
Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: ina on August 13, 2005, 23:18:45
Nice of you to mention that Doris, I'm keeping my fingers crossed for you. It was Skinny Liz (who we don't see on here very much anymore sadly) who first told me about Ferlines and I'm very grateful to her for that.
I'm not going to tempt fate anymore by mentioning how my Ferlines are doing but I can tell you that most allotmenteers on our complex have lost their tomatoes. Oh hell, I'm not superstitious, they are doiing great and we are enjoying tomatoes every day since three weeks and with any luck, for many more weeks.
Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: plot51A on August 14, 2005, 07:51:30
Seems like it will be Ferline for me next year  ;D thanks all!
Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: redimp on August 14, 2005, 10:47:29
Quote from: jennym on August 13, 2005, 01:35:48
[quote author=redclanger
If you water blight infected ground with camden, will it clean the ground of the virus?


The blight is a fungus, and I imagine that the chemical acts as a sort of fungicide. Wouldn't think it would work in the soil, too much to tackle and the blight is airborne anyway. Jenny
My understanding of late blight is that if you get a bad case of it and spores get into the soil, they can survive there, dormant, for up to 8 years.  If potatoes are planted, it infects the plant and then spreads to other plants by distribiuting airborn spores - when conditions are right e.g. Smith Periods.  If the soil were not involved, then rotation would not be a way of preventing infection.
Title: Re: Tomato Disaster
Post by: campanula on August 14, 2005, 21:12:36
yep, ferline are winners for me - I am the only tomato grower on site as blight seems to do for everyone - they all grow toms at their homes. However, |Ferline, and several others doing OK so I don't think it is a given that once blight rears its head, all plots will be affected forevermore. I have noticed a bit of blossom end rot on my Romas though.