Allotments 4 All

Produce => Edible Plants => Topic started by: juniper on November 29, 2005, 12:22:52

Title: Broad Beans and the Frost and Snow
Post by: juniper on November 29, 2005, 12:22:52
I waited until mid November to sow my Aquadulce Claudia broad bean seeds, and also my autumn garlic. However, all of the frost happened before I could get out there and get the seeds in the ground.

Have I missed my chance? Do you think I could get away with germinating them inside and then put them out once the frost stops? Would it be better to wait for the weather to warm up a bit and sow them into the ground directly?
Title: Re: Broad Beans and the Frost and Snow
Post by: the_snail on November 29, 2005, 12:31:08
That is what I am planning to do with my garlic this year. Plant them in trays then when ground is digable then place them into the final growing position in early feburary. I dont know about broad beans as I have never had any luck with autumn sown ones. Always sow mine in mid march to early april foe a june/july crop.

The_Snail
Title: Re: Broad Beans and the Frost and Snow
Post by: Derekthefox on November 29, 2005, 12:41:51
I am doing as you intend to do juniper, ie plant in seed trays and then plant out when suitable. I do this to avoid 'misses' due to mice damage or rotting, and ensures a better fill of the rows.

Derekthefox :D
Title: Re: Broad Beans and the Frost and Snow
Post by: juniper on November 29, 2005, 13:27:42
Many thanks to you both. I thought I may have missed the boat!

I grew autumn broad beans for the first time last year. They were superb. I only lost a couple of plants and was able to harvest a long time before my late -ish spring planting.

My fellow allotmenteer (who is in his eighties) planted his saved seed in the autumn, and lost almost all of them. He has planted saved seed for thirty odd years now. His spring sowing was fine.

There are only four of us who grow plants in our allotments, so it is great to have found a wider source of advice.
Title: Re: Broad Beans and the Frost and Snow
Post by: Derekthefox on November 29, 2005, 13:32:45
It is sad to hear that so few of you grow on your plots. Whereabouts are you? Coventry here. My neighbour lost all his seed two years ago as well, we both bought a kilo bag, if we had realised, we would have split the bag. Still, we live and learn ...

Derekthefox :D
Title: Re: Broad Beans and the Frost and Snow
Post by: dandelion on November 29, 2005, 14:08:58
When do you expect to harvest autumn sown broad beans?
I'm not ready yet to sow anything on my new allotment; only just started digging. But I do have sunny spot in my back garden where I grow my dahlias. They've been dug up for winter; I'll start them growing in my porch next spring to plant out by the middle of May. So if broad beans can be harvested before that I'll give them a try! The soil was manured last spring for the dahlias. Would that suit the beans?
Title: Re: Broad Beans and the Frost and Snow
Post by: Lily on November 29, 2005, 14:39:29
I sowed my Aqua Dulce in October, but there's no sign of them yet, I guess the ground is a little too cold.  I'm sure they'll catch up when the ground warms up.  But, I'll keep some seeds back for spring, just in case.

Lily
Title: Re: Broad Beans and the Frost and Snow
Post by: djbrenton on November 29, 2005, 14:47:09
I sowed mine in October along with garlic and onions. All doing very bicely. I put some extra beans in to fill gaps and they've all come up well so I can fill the odd miss in.
Title: Re: Broad Beans and the Frost and Snow
Post by: Lily on November 29, 2005, 14:53:18
Dj - Are those your garlic in the photo under your name.  Did you grow them yourself.

Lily
Title: Re: Broad Beans and the Frost and Snow
Post by: djbrenton on November 29, 2005, 16:45:54
Yes, I'd already sort of plaited the best ones before I found how to do it properly, so whilst that's the best plait it was't the best garlic.
Title: Re: Broad Beans and the Frost and Snow
Post by: juniper on November 30, 2005, 12:23:19
Derek,

It sounds sad that only four of us grow things on the allotments, but it isn't quite as bad as it sounds! They are available  for the hamlet where I live, which has just 18 houses, and the next village just over a mile away, with about 30 houses.

In our hamlet, well over half of us grow fruit and veg in our gardens, but only a couple in the allotment itself. All of the allotments are taken though. Two horses are kept company by chickens and geese, and the couch grass is kept mowed to keep it looking tidy(ish)!

We are only a little to the south of you, near to Bicester.

I need to get those beans and the garlic planted in trays this week. I think I'll leave them to germinate in our unheated greenhouse, and will give some peas the same treatment.
Title: Re: Broad Beans and the Frost and Snow
Post by: Meg on November 30, 2005, 12:34:09
My beans are up and growing well!!!!!!!!!!!
Title: Re: Broad Beans and the Frost and Snow
Post by: spacehopper on November 30, 2005, 13:08:52
I sowed beans mid/late october. Most of them came up, but there are a few gaps. I'm going to sow some in pots to fill the gaps. I dropped a couple between paving slabs, and they have come up nicely!
Title: Re: Broad Beans and the Frost and Snow
Post by: Obelixx on November 30, 2005, 14:42:14
I sowed  a whole packet of broad beans in October and they've come on well - except for a few gaps.  They are all now under their own personal 1.5litre plastic bottle cloche which is just as well as the recent snow came up to the neck of the bottles.
Title: Re: Broad Beans and the Frost and Snow
Post by: Derekthefox on November 30, 2005, 15:00:24
Your location sounds idyllic to me Juniper, I live in a big noisy city! So my allotment is my escape ...

Derekthefox :D
Title: Re: Broad Beans and the Frost and Snow
Post by: Lily on November 30, 2005, 17:42:47
I sowed a whole packet of broad beans in October and they've come on well - except for a few gaps. They are all now under their own personal 1.5litre plastic bottle cloche which is just as well as the recent snow came up to the neck of the bottles.


Hi Obbelix, How are you. 

The seeds I sowed in October have not come through yet, but the ones I grew in the Greenhouse and then planted out need a little protection, so I think I'll save a few plastic bottles and cover them for a little protection.

Lily
Title: Re: Broad Beans and the Frost and Snow
Post by: timmyc on December 01, 2005, 16:38:54
The weather has warmed a little now, it's raining outside and will stay a little warmer for a while (which is just as well as the office Boiler has just given up the ghost and will need replacing, so we've no heating now!) so you could give it a go now and hope they germinate on time - alternatively sow in pots - 2 to a pot (pick out the weaker one once they germinate) and then put them in a coldframe/greenhouse if you have one - or alternatively leave them outside (but maybe give them a couple of days somewhere warm to germinate) and once germinated get them in the ground as soon as there is a bit of a thaw!
Title: Re: Broad Beans and the Frost and Snow
Post by: juniper on December 02, 2005, 13:35:49
Thanks Timmy. It is much warmer here today. Have been too busy sealing our kitchen floor and getting to know A4A to plant anything yet.

However, this weekend will see broad beans, peas and garlic sown into pots in our conservatory. As soon as the first couple have germinated, they will be straight out into the cold greenhouse. From there, I plan to stand them outside in Jan/Feb, whenever there is a frost free period - and following that they will at last GO INTO THE ALLOTMENT.

Oh well - back to seal the last few slabs of the kitchen floor with their final coat.......
Title: Re: Broad Beans and the Frost and Snow
Post by: Obelixx on December 02, 2005, 15:46:30
Hi Lily - been busy and also had ADSL probs so only been able to visit the boards occasionally. 

We've been having cold, clear frosty days but got up to 1C yesterday and 4C today and it's just clouded over and started drizzling.  I'm hopingthis lasts a few days now so I can get out and finish the last jobs.

When are you doing your Xmas market trip?

Obbelix

Title: Re: Broad Beans and the Frost and Snow
Post by: Robert_Brenchley on December 02, 2005, 22:02:11
I'm hoping to get my garlic in this weekend, weather permitting, and the broad beans will just have to go in in the New Year, whenever the ground's unfrozen. It's definitely not too late; even if you had got them in just before the freeze, they'd just have sat through it doing nothing.
Title: Re: Broad Beans and the Frost and Snow
Post by: redimp on December 02, 2005, 23:58:18
don't broadies rot like other beans?
Title: Re: Broad Beans and the Frost and Snow
Post by: jennym on December 03, 2005, 09:30:39
don't broadies rot like other beans?

Not once they're well rooted and growing nicely.  ;D...
things only rot when they die... :(
Title: Re: Broad Beans and the Frost and Snow
Post by: redimp on December 03, 2005, 12:20:23
Didn't phrase my question properly.  It was the getting them in when the ground has thawed and they will sit through the cold doing nothing.  Won' the seeds rot in the ground like other beans if they are planted when the ground is too cold - even though broad beans can stand colder than others?
Title: Re: Broad Beans and the Frost and Snow
Post by: Derekthefox on December 03, 2005, 12:47:03
I have often pondered this same question myself ...

Derekthefox :D
Title: Re: Broad Beans and the Frost and Snow
Post by: jennym on December 03, 2005, 12:52:05
They won't rot if they are alive - if you can get them to germinate and start growing properly - that's why some people start then in trays and put out later,  I do if I miss the right time to plant them.
Once growing well (3 - 4" high), they might then die off if the weather is really cold, and the soil waterlogged (which would "drown" the roots) but otherwise seem to do ok. To be honest, I wouldn't put them in my soil now, I'd start in trays if you are doing it now. I reckon the best time to put them in is October.
Title: Re: Broad Beans and the Frost and Snow
Post by: Derekthefox on December 03, 2005, 19:57:32
I have set some off in trays, just so I might have some early ones, but they are Masterpiece Green Longpod, so I don't know if they will do any good ...

Derekthefox :D
Title: Re: Broad Beans and the Frost and Snow
Post by: karrot on December 03, 2005, 22:00:20
Where about in cov are you Derick?
I was brought up in Corley Moor,(lovely village on outskirts) then my dad moved to Radford/Kersley
Title: Re: Broad Beans and the Frost and Snow
Post by: Derekthefox on December 03, 2005, 23:40:21
Lower Coundon karrot, just behind Carbodies ...

Derekthefox :D
Title: Re: Broad Beans and the Frost and Snow
Post by: karrot on December 04, 2005, 22:50:30
Derek,
i went to coundon court school, and my dad worked at the Shepard and shepherdess for years.
Title: Re: Broad Beans and the Frost and Snow
Post by: Derekthefox on December 04, 2005, 23:35:45
Whitley Abbey here, I hark from Willenhall originally ...

Derekthefox ;D
Title: Re: Broad Beans and the Frost and Snow
Post by: dandelion on January 01, 2006, 17:14:38
 I germinated some broad beans indoors and planted them out mid December. The first one has justed started poking through the soil! So they're still alive, yippee!
Title: Re: Broad Beans and the Frost and Snow
Post by: John_H on January 01, 2006, 21:06:39
I went down to the plot today and the first 10 broad beans have just broken the surface of the soil. I planted these in November so with a bit of luck they will be low enough down to avoid a real blasting from winter winds and able to stand anymore snow (we have had a fair bit in Hastings this week).

I lived in Coventry for a while too Derek (just off the Radford Road)
Title: Re: Broad Beans and the Frost and Snow
Post by: Derekthefox on January 01, 2006, 21:58:11
Not that far from me then John, as I live just off the Holyhead Road. On the beans front, I have heard it said that growth wants to be held back now because the winter can otherwise hurt the plants ...
Title: Re: Broad Beans and the Frost and Snow
Post by: MaryM on January 02, 2006, 19:27:24
Do any of you think I have left it too late to plant my broad beans in modules if I keep in a covered place?
Title: Re: Broad Beans and the Frost and Snow
Post by: Robert_Brenchley on January 02, 2006, 21:29:32
Not at all, though I'd wait till the soil's a bit warmer now. If they sit in soil which is too cold for them to germinate then there's the danger of rotting. If I were you I'd wait till it warms up a bit now; I normally plant mine about March.
Title: Re: Broad Beans and the Frost and Snow
Post by: MaryM on January 04, 2006, 18:42:33
Thanks Robert
Title: Re: Broad Beans and the Frost and Snow
Post by: Lady of the Land on January 05, 2006, 21:35:24
Have been to the allotment today and broad beans are just starting to break through. My fathers planted a week or two after mine are showing no signs as yet. We were both admiring a neighbouring plot whoose beans are now small plants all neatly in rows with not one missing.
Title: Re: Broad Beans and the Frost and Snow
Post by: flowerlady on January 05, 2006, 23:09:25
Clearly he had no little miceses digging up the seeds!!  Lost half by Suttons to mice, the other half now safely under milk bottle cloches! ;)
Title: Re: Broad Beans and the Frost and Snow
Post by: supersprout on January 07, 2006, 10:23:49
Don't worry Lady, your lottie neighbour obviously has a secret broadie reserve in his backyard and fills in the holes in his lottie rows when the meeces have their way. Some people eh? ::)  8)
Title: Re: Broad Beans and the Frost and Snow
Post by: jennym on January 07, 2006, 11:14:32
Ooh sprout, you are giving all the little secrets away! :) Afraid I do that too, fill in the gaps from a secret reserve, but it does look so nice and neat... :D
Title: Re: Broad Beans and the Frost and Snow
Post by: Derekthefox on January 07, 2006, 12:12:24
I do it the other way round now, I germinate the seeds in trays of compost, then when a couple of inches of growth are there, I plant them out.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal