Allotments 4 All

Produce => Edible Plants => Topic started by: JanG on April 20, 2023, 10:02:30

Title: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on April 20, 2023, 10:02:30
It’s time to think ahead for seed saving 2023. Surprisingly soon corn salad will be in seed followed by lots of over-wintered brassicas and plenty more. So seed gathering can soon commence!

I hope the season’s growing is well under way and going well in spite of a rather strange spring. Last year’s seed circle included many exciting varieties generously given, and I imagine many of these are already being grown and enjoyed in members’ gardens and allotments. It would be good to hear of particular surprises, successes etc as the the season goes on. I’m hoping the 2023 Seed Circle will carry on the high standard of variety and interest! So please do say here on this thread if you’d like to be involved, whether or not you have before, and then begin to think what you might be able to set aside for seed-saving. It would be good to have some new members but I hope previous participants will also join again.

For those who haven’t participated before, here’s some information to help you decide if you would like to join.

The Seed Circle is open to all A4A participants; it’s great to have new people join too. The group is all about setting aside a little growing space, and time, to raise some crops for seeds, keeping the group informed as to how the season is going, then at the end of the season, probably in November, sharing some growing information and your saved seeds with the group.

Each person decides what 2 or more crops they will grow and save seed from (we do inc. tubers, bulbs and cuttings, but do make sure they are well wrapped so that they don't dampen any seeds), and saving enough seed for every other member to grow a crop the following year. The group could be up to 12 people but is more often under 10. Varieties will generally need to be heritage or open pollinated so that they will come true from seed (potato seeds won’t come exactly true). If you include grown out hybrids please state this clearly.

Some vegetables are easier and more reliable than others to save seed from. But generally peas, French beans, tomatoes, perhaps potatoes and some herbs are the easiest. Chillies, sweet peppers, squash, courgette and to some extent lettuce will need isolating from other varieties to keep seed pure.  Parsnips, onions, leeks, beetroot, carrots, celeriac and many brassicas only go to seed in the second year and need isolation from other varieties and so are more time-consuming and a little trickier.

Real Seeds created the idea for the circles. Their site gives some great seed saving tips as well as being a great seed catalogue http://www.realseeds.co.uk/seedsavinginfo.html.
There is also a brilliant series of shortish videos on seed saving for different vegetables at: https://www.diyseeds.org/en/

For anyone interested, what we finally shared in 2020, 2021 and 2022 can be found with images and donors’ notes at https://airtable.com/shryC20nRNmUcgT30. Try Gallery View.

The seeds exchanged from 2017-2019 can be found at https://seedsaverscircle.home.blog/
And for seed exchanging from 2010 to 2016 at http://seedsaverscircle.org/seed-circle/a4a-seed-saver-group-2014/


And some previous threads for the Circles:
Seed Circle 2022 https://www.allotments4all.co.uk/smf/index.php/topic,83279.0.html
Seed Circle 2021 https://www.allotments4all.co.uk/smf/index.php/topic,83047.0.html
Seed Circle 2020 https://www.allotments4all.co.uk/smf/index.php/topic,82679.0.html
Seed Circle 2019 https://www.allotments4all.co.uk/smf/index.php/topic,82221.0.html
Seed Circle 2018 https://www.allotments4all.co.uk/smf/index.php/topic,81651.0.html
Seed Circle 2017 https://www.allotments4all.co.uk/smf/index.php/topic,81010.0.html


Please could a Moderator pin this? 
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: ruud on April 24, 2023, 16:49:35
You can count on me,already busy to plant some intresting stuff
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on April 25, 2023, 06:15:07
Great, Ruud. Looking forward to hearing more. Happy growing.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: markfield rover on April 25, 2023, 13:12:51
I am a little more organised this year , I do have some interesting seeds and if all goes to plan , could well contribute. Thank you JanG.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on April 26, 2023, 05:27:44
That’s good to hear, MR. I hope your growing season goes very well. Progress reports very welcome as things develop.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on May 01, 2023, 15:25:13
Jang, I would also like to join again.  Have replanted carrot Solvita for growing to seeds and also hope to be able to add an interesting pea.  No doubt more seed saving will be happening along the year, but a pea and a carrot are definitely on the plan, all going well. 

Happy growing everybody.  Our box from last year is a treasure I love dipping into and sowing.  Several of the new to me tomatoes are up and getting to transplanting size, despite a very cold spring.  Have prestarted Thelma Sander's today also and will try my very best to save seeds this time! 
 
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on May 01, 2023, 18:45:07
I'm delighted, Galina, that you're up for participating again. I'll be very interested to hear of the progress of the second year of your Solvita carrots, having never tried seed saving with biennial root crops. Have they started to throw new green shoots?

Like you, I'm growing most, if not all, of the rich range of tomato varieties from last year's circle. I've just today dared to move tomato plants to my unheated greenhouse as it looks as though here in the East Midlands we could just about escape without another frost.

Good luck with Thelma Sanders. My record with cucurbit hand pollinating is very poor. My only successes to date have been Crown Prince and Delicata. Must try harder this season!
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on June 09, 2023, 20:15:49
Well, the Solvita carrots came through winter fine in a box of sand in the basement and I still had all 44 carrots by spring.  Which I planted out.  For some reason only 31 came up and a couple with red foliage which later perished.  Still enough and way more than the 20 plus that are necessary for saving good carrot seed. 

Right now they are getting ready to start flowering.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on June 09, 2023, 20:21:55
Also hope to save seeds from a lettuce, Rossia.  Very crisp and crunchy.  I sowed late last year.  These lettuces stayed over winter in the greenhouse, no mildew, and we have been picking the outside leaves for months now.  Rather than bolting, they just make more leaves.  Long since planted out in the garden and doing good, with big crunchy heads, loose leaves on the outside and a tighter centre. 
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on June 10, 2023, 07:29:14
Exciting news on your carrot. What kind of carrot is Solvita?

Your lettuce sounds amazingly resilient. I have lettuces I sowed this spring which are already nearly in flower so the resistance to bolting of Rossia is a great advantage. Except perhaps when you’re waiting to produce seed!
I’ve been looking into lettuce varieties which are heat resistant and I get the impression that varieties which are cold resistant are also sometimes good for not bolting in summer. It would be interesting to know whether Rossia is so obliging in summer too.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on June 15, 2023, 21:42:58
Well it certainly seems to be so, as we have had some quite hot days and during winter it went into the 2 digit minus degrees many nights too, although we did not have weeks of -18C like the winter before last.  And it would have been a bit warmer in the unheated greenhouse.  But I never expected them to do well there and really only planted them because my seed donor encouraged me to grow them over winter.  Still no signs of stretching and bolting.  Yes, both cold and heat resistant. 

My donor originally got the variety from here.  https://www.dreschflegel-shop.de/sorten-zur-aussaat-in-der-zweiten-jahreshaelfte/blattgemuese/726/eissalat-rossia


A bit more about Solvita

https://www.bingenheimersaatgut.de/de/bio-saatgut/gemuese/moehren.html
Breeding history and breeder.  https://www.kultursaat.org/dateien/zuechtung/sorten/solvita.pdf

They were bred under the biodynamic Bingenheimer seed label.  They are a registered variety, but are free in a way that is very similar to an OSSI seed variety.  You can grow them, multiply them, share the seeds, but you cannot own them or patent them for yourself. The description translates to something like this.  Wüchsige Möhre mit hohem Ertragspotenzial für die Verarbeitung. Flakkeese-Typ mit konischer Form. Schnelle Jugendentwicklung und sehr gesundes, starkes Laub. Kräftig aromatischer und süßer Möhrengeschmack.  Strong growing carrot with high yield potential.  Of the Flakkee type and conical.  Rapid early development and very healthy strong foliage.  Strong, aromatic and sweet carrot flavour. 

One of the breeding aims was to have the foliage not recessed but on top of a rounded carrot, so there is no waste in the kitchen cutting off a 'hollow crown' (to borrow a description from a parsnip). 

I can attest to rapid and strong growth and great flavour, but not all of my carrots were conical, some were pretty straight.  As indeed the ones in the photo which are not all that conical looking either.  Others were more conical.  So I expect to get a variation in shape from the seeds also.   

My seed source was not however Bingenheimer, but a small Czech seed company, Permaseminka, that specialise in good seeds for the home gardener and also seeds for permaculture. 

Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on June 16, 2023, 06:29:50
Great detailed information, Galina, much appreciated. Looking forward very much to both varieties.

I’ve used Permaseminka too, and found their range to be very appealing and reliable.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: garrett on June 17, 2023, 15:21:06
I'd like to join in again. I was just planting out my Rugosa Friulana courgettes earlier today and it reminded me about the seed circle. I'm growing lots from last year and looking forward to trying the varieties we shared.

Here's my provisional list for the circle this year:
Tomato Piglet Willie's French Black (medium dark red/brown)
Tomato Girl Girl's Weird Thing (large red/brown/green)
Tomato Reinhard's Purple Sugar (purple cherry)
Tomato Jaune Flamme (small orange)
Sweet Pepper Jimmy Nardello (small red horn)
Chilli Pepper Basque (Piment d'Espelette)
Bean Tresnjevac (dry shelling bean)
Bean Melbourne's Mini (short green pod)
Bean Selma Zebra (mottled purple/green pod)

They're the ones I'm confident about. The tomatoes all have fruit set and the peppers have also been bagged and set fruit. I'm going to attempt to isolate and hand pollinate a couple of squash, but we'll see how well I succeed there haha. I'll throw in some flowers too, I'll see what does well this summer.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on June 19, 2023, 06:19:24
That’s a wonderful list, Garrett, and very good to have you in the circle again. Amazing tomato names! Looking forward to growing the first two for the names alone!
I’m interested in how you have bagged your pepper as I’ve had very limited success doing that. Do you bag the whole plant or individual flowers/ groups of flowers?
Good luck with you hand pollination.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on June 19, 2023, 08:02:47
Lovely list Garrett.   Good to have you join in again. 

Indeed great names Jang, especially the girl tomato.  Named after a tomato eating dog called girl girl - the mind boggles, every bit as intriguing as some of the Tom Wagner names.  Have just planted up his Betimes MacBeth, but definitely not set its blood red fruits yet, despite the hint that this one is early.  So no promises yet. 

Matt's Hornet  and Ciliegia are doing well.  Very interested in Matt's Hornet as I have been growing Matt's Wild Cherry.
https://www.juliadimakos.com/product/girl-girls-weird-thing-tomato/
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: garrett on June 19, 2023, 15:18:43
I use organza bags to stop pollinating insects. Here's a picture of the Jimmy Nardello bagged until I notice fruit forming:


Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: markfield rover on June 19, 2023, 16:17:12
I’ll pop up a list shortly, but and I am saying this quietly fingers crossed and all that , I managed to germinate tomato Blaby Special, the seed was ten years old and I had saved it from the seed sent out from a doctor at Lancaster university who was trying to reintroduce it  to Blaby in Leicestershire, MIL who remembered the tomatoes (she was local) she was one of the original recipients. I did share the seed on here many years ago but I don’t know if it’s still grown much .
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on June 20, 2023, 05:46:23
Yes the variety is still grown in my garden MR, not every year, but from time to time and I have a small seed portion in the freezer for back up too.  They always did well for me in Northamptonshire.  Haven't grown them here yet though.  Thank you for offering again to keep this variety going and glad they germinated well. 
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on June 20, 2023, 06:13:29
Thanks for the photo, Garrett. I think yours are outdoors? Mine are in a polytunnel and I think lack of wind to aid pollen distribution is probably the difference. I need to do more jiggling when mine are in their bags. I’ve managed to set fruit on Capriglio Rosso this year by isolating it. I’ve enjoyed this sweet pepper as it has particularly thick walls.

A great background to Blaby Special, Markfield Rover, with its specific connection to both Blaby and your grandmother. Great to keep this variety going. I wonder whether anyone else still grows it apart from you and the small band of seed circle past and hopefully present and future. All the more important for us to keep it going. Hope it grows well for you this season.

Thank you for the further insight into the Girl Girl tomato, Galina. The mind does indeed boggle. Ciliegia also doing well for me - one plant under cover and one outdoors. I’m growing all the ‘icicle’ varieties we shared last year. Pink Icicle in particular romped away and gained height very quickly. I’m also interested to try the different ‘Ambrosia’ varieties for their sweetness. Great pleasures to come!
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on June 22, 2023, 05:52:13
Blaby Special has its own Wikipedia entry!  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blaby_Special
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on June 24, 2023, 09:27:13
Ambrosia is grown too here with great anticipation, but not ready yet.  Cantarix lettuce is a beauty indeed.  The Rossia lettuce has finally started to stretch on a few plants following a 35C day!  Blue Pepe nasturtium, which I overwintered indoors and replanted, is producing seeds after never quite getting to this point last summer. 

Tonight we shall enjoy the first Albarello courgettes.  The Outdoorpse Bruine (sp?) shallots are doing their stuff beautifully, after a late start (my fault, but it really proves their superior keeping qualities!).   Other lettuces are shining this year - fingers crossed for seeds.   

With the fabulous Green Beauty large mangetout peas we received seed for, I decided to grow several other peas of the extra long mangetout pod type - Eat All from HSL and Eat Me (which was shared in this seed circle many years ago), also Bajka which are not quite as long.  https://deaflora.de/Shop/Erbsen/Zuckererbse-Bajka.html?language=de

Have harvested the first almost dry seed pods of dwarf mangetout Norli, which is a very early dwarf variety.  My seeds were from Samen Mauser in Switzerland originally.    https://www.hornbach.ch/de/p/kefe-norli-gemuesesamen-samen-mauser/8100902/

We may get pea seeds for this year's circle, all going well.  Including the very special pink flowered Golden Sweet, but like other yellow podded mangetouts it shows much greater heat resistance than the green ones.   So too early to definitely promise at this moment. 

I know it is a bit boring, but I have lamb's lettuce seeds ready.  That really useful winter salad, which survives any level of frost for very early spring harvests.   It and American Landcress which is nearly ready,  are a great boon very early in the year.   Both just shrugged off weeks of -18C at night the winter before last.  Also the unnamed rocket from the Italian salad mix seed packet, which I had been growing in Rushden for very many years.  It is a cultivated rocket and also fits the bill of 'will thrive through everything winter can throw at it'.  Let me know if there is any interest.  These are not particularly special, but so hardy and reliable for year round gardening, I would not want to be without them.   

I spotted the first bees on the fully opened carrot flowers doing their stuff.  There is very little Queen Anne's Lace here and the few plants I noticed, went in the compost, so I don't expect a problem, fingers crossed.

How is everybody else getting on?





Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on June 25, 2023, 06:02:34
I’m very pleased your Alberello courgette is doing well as the two plants I grew from my own seed didn’t prosper and I was feeling apologetic for contributing poor quality seed.

Blue Pepe nasturtium I love and have grown it now for three years I believe. The dark bluish leaves and intense red flowers are a lovely combination. Thank you, Markfield Rover.

Your long podded mangetout trial promises to be very interesting as well as yielding some great eating! I’m growing Oregon Giant, much loved of Carol Deppe, and could well contribute that to the circle. I too am growing the special pink flowered Golden Sweet. As you say, it soldiers on when other become tired and start to look like producing seed. Fingers crossed for seed.

By way of tomato varieties I’m interested to see what Stonor’s Most Prolific is like. It was an HSL choice this year.

It’s rather early to predict the quality and success of beans but I’ve become interested in trying yellow podded Romano types so hope to find one or two which might fare well and give good seed.

Great to hear of your progress, Galina, with seed circle varieties past, and hopefully to be. I hope others are enjoying similar delights!
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on June 25, 2023, 12:19:39
This is one of my three plants of Albarello.   Nothing wrong with that seed Jang, thank you for it.  Very yummy last night.  And the winner in the courgette race too. 
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on June 26, 2023, 06:48:43
Looks excellent. I’m very pleased! Not sure where I went wrong with mine. I’ll try again next year.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: Elfeda on June 26, 2023, 14:45:11
Hello All.

I am interested to join too. how ever, I do french beans to make it easy for my self. 

both dwarf and climbing.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on June 27, 2023, 05:41:53
It would be good to have another member, Elfeda. Do you have any particular varieties of beans in mind?
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: juliev on June 27, 2023, 12:53:37
Hello everyone,

I have joined the forum in the hope to take part in the seed swap, I hope it’s ok.

I have been saving seeds for “easy” crops for a few years (beans, peas, squashes, courgettes, tomatoes, lettuce, herbs). Last autumn, I discovered the works of Joseph Lofthouse and Carol Deppe and have fallen down the rabbit hole of modern landraces and plant breeding…
For the swap, I have a nice mix of lettuces (mix from Wild Garden Seed and a few of my own seeds, originally from a gourmet mix) and some coriander that cropped in the autumn, survived the winter snow and deep freeze to crop again in the spring. Fingers crossed, there will also be plenty of beans and cucurbits (I’m planning to hand pollinate). Under cover in a small polytunnel, I have some tomatoes, peppers, chillies, aubergines, basil, cucumbers and melons. I am not sure yet what varieties I will be able to offer as I have planted a small number of many things… may the strongest ones give plenty of seeds!
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on June 27, 2023, 18:54:47
Welcome Juliev,  I had to smile at your post because it is almost identical to my first ever post on this forum 13 years ago asking to take part in the seed circle and describing what I planned to offer. 

Your possible choices for the circle sound very interesting.  Let's hope for a good season for gardening and seed saving for all of us. 
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on June 28, 2023, 05:55:34
Welcome from me too, Juliev. I like your description of falling down the rabbit hole, suggesting how compelling it is once you get to that point! I started with getting hooked on the incredible range of bean varieties and widened out from there. You are certainly casting your net widely already.
Good luck with your hand pollinating. It certainly opens up a lot of possibilities for cucurbits and peppers.

It will be great to have you join. Do feel free to share how things are going - successes and failures - as we can all learn from each other and enjoy our common enthusiasm.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: markfield rover on June 29, 2023, 10:10:36
The plan is… tomatoes ,Seattle Best of All, Salt Spring Sunrise, Imur Prior Beta, Pigeon Egg and Blaby Special. Runner bean  Gramp Nicholls ( well isolated)  Pea Tincture A Fleur Blanc , Stokesley, Espoir de Gembloux  Mange tout Born.  DFB Black Valentine and Yugoslavian No 4 . Barlotti Gramma Walters . Possibly some dahlias too ! Fingers crossed.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on June 30, 2023, 07:05:47
That’s a great list, Markfield Rover. Lots of bean, pea and tomato varieties new to me.

Fingers crossed indeed. I think you mentioned dahlia seeds last year. I’ve never harvested seed from dahlias. I imagine they need quite a long warm season?
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: markfield rover on June 30, 2023, 08:06:58
Yes I did , but got caught out by an early frost. I had a packet of mixed seed from The National Collection many years ago and was astounded how big they grew in their first year. There are a number of growers ( from seed) in the States one of whom has collaborated with growers in Europe and is brilliant with step by step guidance , I have braved pinching out but dis- budding another time perhaps, I have low vases !
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: juliev on June 30, 2023, 11:33:18
Thank you for the warm welcome!

The beans are doing ok so far (the ones that survived the pill bugs...). Madera marroon and borlotti are competing to reach the top of their cane. Dwarf bean bobis d'albenga was the first to set pods, 2nd was jersey beef grex (brown envelope seeds).
I'm very impressed with the aubergine czech early. Should I only let the first fruit develop for seed saving and remove all the other flowers on the plant?
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on July 01, 2023, 05:40:37
Good question Juliev.

I wonder why we should only let one fruit ripen for seed saving.  On other similar plants we would not do that.  Courgettes are being seriously slowed down in their further production while the first fruit matures for seed, but we get to eat any subsequent fruit that the plant develops.   I would definitely mark up which fruit are for seed and only let the earliest fruits ripen for seed, but if you get more, well then enjoy.  As aubergine is left on the plant to ripen a bit beyond the edible stage, before mature seed harvest, I would say any second and third fruits are for you, just like you would with courgettes.  I think the plant itself will determine whether it stops flowering and developing more fruit.  I will have a look in seedsaving books later and come back if that advice is different.

Good to hear that your beans are now out of danger and starting to come good.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on July 01, 2023, 14:53:36
Nothing further than letting aubergines get really overripe, before harvesting, cutting open and sort of massaging and washing seeds off the flesh over a bowl of water, straining seeds, then drying Juliev.  Bet you knew all that anyway.  :)
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on July 01, 2023, 18:12:26
Question for you all.  I am growing Phrik key nuu this year.  But I am a bit mystified at its appearance.  Which is very unexpectedly pretty. 

The leaves are variegated and now that fruits are developing they are yellow with green patches too.  Did  not expect this from the photos.  How are others people going with this variety?

Is this the same as Fish Pepper?  It looks like it?
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: Elfeda on July 01, 2023, 19:55:26

I grow basic beans:

dwarf french bean paulista,
climbing green  elegance, blue lake
purple climbing blauhilde.

Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on July 02, 2023, 06:58:00
Question for you all.  I am growing Phrik key nuu this year.  But I am a bit mystified at its appearance.  Which is very unexpectedly pretty. 

The leaves are variegated and now that fruits are developing they are yellow with green patches too.  Did  not expect this from the photos.  How are others people going with this variety?

I grew Phrik Key Nuu last year. It made a small variegated plant but didn’t ever produce any peppers as I think I was rather late to get it going. Interestingly I’m growing it again this year but, from the same batch of seeds, it has produced a plant which isn’t variegated. Your variegated peppers sound interestingly unusual. I’ll have to see if I can grow it for a third time next year to see what emerges.

Is this the same as Fish Pepper?  It looks like it?

Does Fish produce the same yellow and green fruit? I have a plant of Fish growing this year. I must look at it more closely. My peppers are probably well behind yours.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on July 02, 2023, 06:59:50
I haven’t mastered the art of quoting yet! In my last message I replied in the middle of a quote so my comment appears as part of the quote. Sorry for the confusion.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on July 02, 2023, 09:29:52

Does Fish produce the same yellow and green fruit? I have a plant of Fish growing this year. I must look at it more closely. My peppers are probably well behind yours.


Quote is ok Jang as we read all of the text anyway.  No, this is the only pepper that actually has fruit so far.  Most others are still barely in bud or flowering.  And the Locotos are not even growing well so far.  I have never had seeds for fish pepper, so don't have any comparison, bar their description and www photos.  Mine looks like the fruit top centre on this photo.  https://www.epicurious.com/ingredients/fish-peppers-african-american-garden-article

Whatever this variety is, it is very welcome and fabulously early, outdoors too.  Noted that is may be an odd one out, however the variegation happened with some of your plants too. 
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on July 03, 2023, 06:25:09
Here is a photo of it.  The whole plant is just over a foot tall. 
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on July 03, 2023, 07:07:39
Interesting, and an interesting article. I have to doubt my original Fish seeds as I’ve not had a striped fruit like that when I’ve grown it before.
I’m growing Purple Tiger too, with seed originally received from you, Galina, which has lovely variegated foliage too but purple rather than variegated fruit. I wonder if there are many other variegated pepper varieties.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on July 24, 2023, 07:42:33
From last year’s seed circle, I’m growing Panther dwarf French bean. Interestingly I have three plants with yellow wax pods and two plants with green pods. Both are delicious filet type. Is anyone else growing it, and finding a mix of yellow and bean pods?
It’s marketed by Nikitovka as a yellow bean so either I’ve mixed up seeds are perhaps some crossing has happened.
https://nikitovka.com/en/bean/298-bush-bean-panther-4823094015073.html
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: ruud on July 24, 2023, 10:48:41
That bean i added to the circle,maybe it is a cross.Or i have mixed some seeds.The main reason is that you enjoy eating them.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on July 25, 2023, 06:26:46
Yes indeed they are delicious. Thank you. I’ll just save seed from the yellow ones and see if they all come yellow from that seed. And maybe someone else will say if they have any green podded plants.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: markfield rover on July 25, 2023, 09:10:46
I had a sneaky taste of the Black Valentine dfb as they are so prolific, although the beans were possibly past the optimum picking point they were certainly tasty and not stringy.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on July 26, 2023, 05:20:07
Definitely one to look forward to! I’ve grown it once before and remember how prolific it was. It will be great to have some fresh seed.

You also mentioned Yugoslavian No 4 which is a completely new name to me. How’s it going? I’d be interested to know your source and any other information you might have.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: markfield rover on July 26, 2023, 07:50:50
In haste .. source HSL  I am away from the plot for a few days but will report back.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on July 27, 2023, 08:44:48
Ruud, these things can happen to all of us. I have tall and short plants too.  The beans are all delicious.  Only the short ones are going to be used for saving our own seeds.  Thanks for the explanation. 
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on August 05, 2023, 18:28:30
Green Beauty.  Have just been shelling seeds.  Several pods with 9 seeds, no wonder they are such a mighty long mangetout pea.  Tasted great too.  Looking forward to growing them again. 
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on August 06, 2023, 10:31:22
Glad you enjoyed Green Beauty, Galina.

I hope seed saving is well under way for everyone in spite of rather strange weather, in England at least. For me, peas reached a rather early end with fewer pods setting than usual because of the extremely hot dry June. Now also, quite a lot of beans, especially the dwarf ones, have rust, which badly discolours the pods. I think this might be a result of the very wet cool July. Other things, like brassicas, are very much enjoying the constant rain but polytunnel crops are very slow, with tomatoes quite reluctant to ripen. Ah well, these are minor peculiarities compared with areas elsewhere.

Time to take stock a little. Our small but busily productive group is, I believe:

Galina
Garrett
JanG
juliev
Markfield Rover
Ruud
Vetivert

The end of November deadline has worked well for the last couple of years. I’d like to repeat that this year if possible but do let me know if any particular factors make that difficult.

As we save seeds through the next couple of months, it would be good to share here what becomes available, as some of us have already. I have just harvested seeds of Black Spanish Round radish, dill and coriander, peas - Roi de Carouby from HSL and Winterkefe from Brown Envelope seeds - and lettuce - Arctic King, possibly Brighton (Vital Seeds) and hopefully one or two more.

I'll start to get together a list of what you've all so far said that you hope to contribute, but of course this is very provisional and might well change as the season develops further.

Happy growing - and harvesting!

Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on August 06, 2023, 13:14:54
Thank you Jan, so far safely gathered in, peas Pink Flowered Golden sweet,  Auralia, Norli.  Lettuces are coming along.  The first heads of the carrots are finally getting near maturity for harvesting, others have only just started flowering.  It will be a protracted seed harvest, but there should be plenty of time for a portion for everybody. 
Tomatoes, determinate cherry from Tom Wagner Betimes Macbeth was indeed early here, so seed will be saved too, but I haven't fermented any yet.  The fruits are very red, you could say blood red as the name implies, cherry tomatoes with thick walls and extremely shiny skin.  They will last without spoiling for several weeks, but all achieved with normal breeding methods, not with genetic modification.  Thank you Jayb for the seeds a few years back.  Broad Ripple Yellow Currant from HSL is also ready, a yellow currant tomato said to have grown out of a crack of a concreted yard in the USA.   
And - UK has for the fifth time delayed import controls.  Should still be possible to get seeds to you without issues by late November. 
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on August 06, 2023, 17:10:19
Thank goodness for UK inefficiency!
The tomatoes sound great. I've come across references to Betimes Macbeth online, been intrigued by it, and love the name together with your description of the fruit. Especially looking forward to that one.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: garrett on August 09, 2023, 16:57:44
I thought I'd take a photo as I was saving seed from the Girl Girl's Weird Thing tomato.

"Originally discovered around 2010 as a variant of 'Green Zebra' by Jessica Hughes in Canada, she ended up naming it 'Girl Girl's Weird Thing' after her dog "Girl Girl" who would steal tomatoes and eat them." Olive green/brown tomato with red stripes, indeterminate with regular leaves.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on August 10, 2023, 05:20:20
That’s a remarkable looking tomato,Garrett. Somewhat larger than Green Zebra? Does it taste good?

Are you still growing all your tomatoes outdoors? My only ripe outdoor tomatoes so far are Sungold.

The Ciliegia Cerise which you contributed is also early and has so far given us our other small cherry tomatoes. But the season is very slow here in Lincolnshire.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: garrett on August 10, 2023, 07:49:25
I have to admit that I wasn't blown away with Girl Girl's Weird Thing, it tasted fine but I wasn't wowed. Given the unusual weather this year maybe that's unfair though, I don't think the wet and cool July has been great for our tomatoes.

That said, I am still growing all my tomatoes outside and I've had at least one or two ripe fruit from everything except the Tumbling Tom Red which usually gives me my earliest fruit. A lot of green fruit remaining on everything else though.

Last weekend I went out and topped all the indeterminate tomato plants to hopefully focus on ripening all the stubborn green fruit.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on August 13, 2023, 19:44:32
Finally the first seeds of lettuce Rossio, that took its time!  And other lettuces are also coming in.  I have started taking off the first seed heads of the carrot.  Not quite sure at what stage to take them off.  Some of the seeds in the seed heads are very brown, others light brown.  Did they get dark brown because they got rained on for several days?  Very much experimenting here.  Anyway, they are being fully dried off indoors, before the seeds get rubbed off.  From memory, a long time ago when I last saved my own carrot seeds, this is a bit hard on the lungs, but left over Covid masks will come to the rescue. 
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on August 14, 2023, 07:08:51
My lettuces are also taking their time to get their fluffy seed heads, except for one early variety.

Very exciting to be experimenting with the carrots. I have one unexpected carrot seed head, from a carrot accidentally left in the ground. I’m not sure at all what variety it is, but I’m inclined to gather seeds just for my own interest and as a practice run for a more managed procedure!

I hope your Solvita proves not too difficult or harsh on the lungs.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on August 14, 2023, 11:17:03
Update:
These are the seeds which so far members of the Circle have said they hope to contribute. It's already a very rich and varied collection

Garrett

Tomato Piglet Willie's French Black (medium dark red/brown)
Tomato Girl Girl's Weird Thing (large red/brown/green)
Tomato Reinhard's Purple Sugar (purple cherry)
Tomato Jaune Flamme (small orange)
Sweet Pepper Jimmy Nardello (small red horn)
Chilli Pepper Basque (Piment d'Espelette)
Bean Tresnjevac (dry shelling bean)
Bean Melbourne's Mini (short green pod)
Bean Selma Zebra (mottled purple/green pod)

Galina

Carrot Solvita
Lettuce Rossia
Mangetout pea Norli
Lambs lettuce
Rocket Unnamed
Mangetout Pink Flowered Golden Sweet
Pea Auralia
Tomato Bedtimes Macbeth
Tomato Broad Ripple Yellow Currant


Juliev

Climbing French bean Madera Marroon
Climbing French bean Borlotti
Dwarf French bean Bobis d'Albenga
Dwarf French bean Jersey Beef Grex
Aubergine Czech Early


Markfield Rover

Tomato Blaby Special
Tomato Seattle Best of All
Tomato Salt Spring Sunrise
Tomato Imur Prior Beta
Tomato Pigeon Egg
Runner bean Gramp Nicholls 
Pea Tincture A Fleur Blanc 
Pea Stokesley
Pea Espoir de Gembloux 
Mangetout Born
Dwarf French bean Black Valentine
Dwarf French bean Yugoslavian No 4 
Dwarf French bean Borlotti
Climbing French bean Gramma Walters.
Possibly some dahlias

And so far I've collected seeds from the following peas and lettuce but hope also to collect bean and tomato seeds before too long
Pea - Frühe Heinrich, Roi de Carouby, Winterkefe, Spring Blush
Lettuce - Arctic King
Coriander


Obviously these lists are very provisional, so do adjust as and when. Ruud and Vetivert will I'm sure give us tasters of what they may have been growing as the season goes on. In the meantime I hope harvesting is very successful and enjoyable for everyone!
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: markfield rover on August 18, 2023, 14:52:09
A quick update , three of the five tomatoes are in , peas and beans too except runner . Black Valentine dfb has yielded so many seeds , the beans are delicious !
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on August 20, 2023, 16:29:50
Here are a few photos.  A bean to add to my offer.  This one is also in the flat, long category.  I got my first seed from the huge packet of different beans from Georgia that Jaap Vlaming was gifted and shared with us.  This is Georgian bean Number 22.  None of these Georgian beans were named, so Jaap named them after their packet numbers.  Plants are tall and need support. 

Has done very well this year.  The beans that were harvested for seed are fully dry already and the second generation on the same plants is now producing more for the kitchen.  They are stringless, but in dry weather the pods can get a little woody, if left too long.  Then they are best as shelling beans. 

On top of my garden book are second generation pods of Geo # 22 and tiny Herrenböhnli pods (that we got last year from Jang, thank you) for comparison. 

Then we have the Betimes MacBeth cherry toms, determinate, 'betimes' as in early and 'MacBeth' as in blood red.

The third photo shows Broad Ripple Yellow Currant, tiny yellow pop in the mouth tomatoes, which are so good.  There are hundreds of them on each plant.  This is from the Heritage Seed Library collection.  A bit more info in this video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4RHjg7snUbE

PS I don't know why the thumbnails are sideways, but the photos open the right way up. :)
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on August 20, 2023, 21:16:39
Really appreciated the Airtable database today.  Looking at Ambrosia Pink in the greenhouse and wondering whether this can be right, as there is a definite orange hue on the fruits.  Exceptionally sweet delicious tomatoes.  Airtable to the rescue, where they are described as apricot pink.  That fits.  So all is well.  Delicious addition to our tomato list. 
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: Vetivert on August 20, 2023, 23:41:10
Hi all, looks like the gardens are growing well and I hope you're all in good health and high spirits.
Difficult season for me this year, and not just because of the weather. But, I believe the few plants that are flourishing may provide a useful contribution to the seed circle.
Hoping that the following will yield in good time:

Tomato
Ivory Tears (white pear/grape tomato)

Pepper
Jimmy Nardello (C. annuum - long Italian American sweet frying pepper. Family heirloom)
Sugar Rush Stripey (C. baccatum - peach with red stripes, mutant of Sugar Rush Peach. Breeding of Fatalii and Chris Fowler)
Habanada (C. chinensis - heatless Habanero. A maybe because it is completely covered in flowers but no fruit yet. Bred by Cornell prof. Michael Mazourek)

Dwarf Bean
Bis
Galopka
Tytania
Wstęga
(these are all Polish wax beans)

Others TBC
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on August 21, 2023, 06:20:43
Very good to hear from you, Vetivert, in the midst of what is clearly a difficult season for you. It will be great to have your contributions and I hope the next few weeks go as smoothly as possible.

Like you, Galina, I was puzzled just yesterday by Ambrosia Pink. Mine seem to be decidedly yellowish-orange, rather than even apricot-tinged pink, not at all like the photo from J and L reproduced on the Airtable base.

Will be interested to compare with any others. Not fully stable, perhaps?
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on August 21, 2023, 07:32:17
Ambrosia Pink here.  Top right hand side is the most mature fruit and has the most developed pink hue.  I think ours match quite well Jang, my not quite ripe fruits on the plants are the same colour as yours.  The pink seems to develop with maturity. 

Pink tinged apricot, rather than apricot tinged pink would be a better description perhaps. 

 
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: Vetivert on August 21, 2023, 09:16:07
Galina's 'Ambrosia Pink' look just like what I harvested last year, slightly oval and should taste very sweet. I suspect what I have distributed are an offtype or the line is still segregating.
Yours still have some way to go JanG - they should get a pinkish hue once they're fully ripe, but before that they develop from yellow to orange to shades of apricot.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on August 22, 2023, 06:23:49
Very interesting colouring. Unusual perhaps to develop from a yellowish colour to a pinkish colour but I shall certainly wait with anticipation for further colouring to develop. Thanks, both, for the clarification of the full range of stages.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on August 26, 2023, 12:23:31
About a third of the seed heads of carrot Solvita are now harvested and drying off indoors in the basket.  I think we will get enough seed for the circle  :sunny:

Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: InfraDig on August 27, 2023, 11:48:18
I have lots of empty Benecol containers, basically small plastic bottles with a plastic lid. Can anyone tell me if these would be any good for storing small seeds?
Thanks.

Infradig
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on August 27, 2023, 14:59:37
They are suitable, providing the seed is really dry before you put it in as they have nice tight fitting lids.  They should be stored in cool and dry conditions, not in a garden shed etc.  If you have any of the tiny silica gel sachets that come with Covid testing kits or with new shoes and bags, you can add one into each Benecol container with the seeds for extra assurance that the seed stays dry and viable.  I have actually asked at a local shoe shop to save me the silica gel sachets and they did.  I also use fizzy drink vitamin tablet tubes for seeds, which have an inbuilt drying agent in their lids.     
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: InfraDig on August 27, 2023, 17:25:57
Thanks very much!

Infradig
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: markfield rover on August 28, 2023, 09:05:06
I’ve grown cosmos Apricotta my favourite cosmos  to date , almost luminous , I have plenty of seed if anyone is interested? Veg wise just waiting for Blaby tomatoes.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on August 28, 2023, 11:04:41
I’ve grown cosmos Apricotta my favourite cosmos  to date , almost luminous , I have plenty of seed if anyone is interested?

Yes please, they sound delightful.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on August 29, 2023, 06:46:16
And another yes for Cosmos Apricotta, please.

I also grow Cosmos sulphureus, which is a different species from Cosmos bipinnatus which has the pinkish shades. Cosmos sulphurous has, as the name suggests, yellow shades, although in my case, just orange. I love them. They’re quite delicate spots of colour through a border, say, but, at the same time, make quite an impact. Original seed from Seed Co-operative. If I start letting some seed develop we can have a bit of a cosmos theme.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on August 30, 2023, 17:26:55
Tomato Velmozha  . Oh WOW!   :icon_cheers:
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: tricia on August 30, 2023, 18:17:10
Beats my heaviest 583g Brandywine by some margin galina! Enormous crop here this year and most of the fruit weighing in at over 300g each - and still no sign of blight  :icon_cheers:.

Tricia  :wave:
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on August 30, 2023, 19:33:35
That's good going for Brandyvine Tricia.  Congratulations. 

These are not 'supposed' to be much over a pound, but clearly nobody told this particular fruit.  It is by far the largest I have ever grown for sure. 

Long may the dreaded B word stay away.  I have been removing some leaves, but we nevertheless are getting a good harvest here too. 
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on August 31, 2023, 06:51:15
The Velmozha fruit is certainly very Wow! I ran out of space to grow it this year but looks like a definite for next year.
No blight to speak of here either, which seems rather surprising given the wet July. But it has been very dry again for much of August. Particularly fortunate as the tomatoes were so late to start ripening. .
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on September 01, 2023, 16:42:15
I have enough seeds for the circle from lettuce Liller.  Originally from HSL.  This is a large green soft lettuce, outer leaves slightly tinged with red.  HSL description: 
A huge, cabbage-headed lettuce that can weigh anything up to 500g. The unusual pink tinge on leaf margins is temperature-dependent, apparent on planting out the young plants in the spring but disappearing as they start to mature. Leaves are large, full and smooth, ideal for adding to a sandwich.  https://oldhsl.gardenorganic.org.uk/seedlist?page=4




Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on September 01, 2023, 16:52:07
Also just harvested seeds from French bean Juanita Smith.  These also have the very beautiful 'frosted' seeds we talked about last year.  The pods were a surprise, as they are so very similar to Cherokee Trail of Tears, maybe an inch shorter give or take.  They start off green, then get a purple hue and finally they turn entirely purple.  Flavour is outstandingly 'beany' eaten as a green bean.  Just like CH T o T they have a string, or should that be called a 'wire'  :happy7: .  However, because the string is so strong, it is very easy to remove.  Seeds originally from Belle Epoque Meise, my seed donor was Vetivert, thank you.  https://belleepoquemeise.be/wp-content/uploads/2023/02/Bonenlijst-2023.pdf
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on September 02, 2023, 07:30:18
Your list of contributions is growing apace, Galina. All very exciting.

Interesting to have your comments on Cherokee Trail of Tears. I have grown them this year from Markfield Rover’s contribution to the last seed circle. I was expecting them to be purple from the outset as I grew them many years ago and my vague memory was just of purple beans - faulty memory again. So it was a surprise when this year’s pods started off green and only gradually acquired the purple colouring. Now I’m reassured that this is the real McCoy!

It will be lovely to have that colouring with frosted seeds into the bargain.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on September 02, 2023, 08:17:02
Sorry my Juanita Smith photos are upside down.  I tried to cure the sideways and have made it worse it seems.  Also needed to restart my computer and my phone before I could upload photos yesterday at all, then the phone lead had an intermittent.  Not my easiest day with technology and did not spot the error either.  Please rotate them for the airtable or I will try again Jang.     :BangHead:
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on September 03, 2023, 07:00:15
To be honest I hadn’t noticed that they’re upside down as the pods are kind of pointed at both ends! But the leaves, stalks etc such have been a give-away. Such lack of observation! But I’m certainly happy to rotate them for the Airtable base so don’t worry.
Good luck with your technology today.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: markfield rover on September 08, 2023, 10:46:48
Talking of seeds…. We visited Pennard Plants in their walled garden in Somerset yesterday , they have occasional open days , 12 October next one , I am possibly the only one here within easy reach , the sort of place that makes one go weak at the knees.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on September 08, 2023, 22:35:28
Did you take any photos? 
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on September 10, 2023, 06:32:02
Am I right in thinking you’re also within reach of Adam Alexander’s base, Markfield Rover? You are indeed favourably situated!
I’m within easy reach of the Seed Co-operative and have visited a couple of times. It has been good and fascinating to see them grow.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: markfield rover on September 12, 2023, 10:35:55
Sadly I forgot to take pictures, was too in awe! I had mentally moved in . I did remember to buy seeds , one lady bought £100 worth , I like her style!
Yes Adam Alexander is just over the border and sometimes talks at the seed swap.
The last of the tomatoes have ripened , all gathered in.
Talking of seeing a company grow , I have some early Sarah Raven packets , no pictures  and plenty of space to write notes .
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on September 21, 2023, 09:59:57
I now also have enough seeds of lettuce Red Evolution to contribute to the circle.  Bought seeds originally from Adaptive Seeds.  Mine were a 'blacker' red that their photo shows and no green at the base of the leaves either.  This lettuce stands out in a salad bowl (just like the beautiful Cantarix lettuce seeds we were given last year).    https://www.adaptiveseeds.com/product/vegetables/lettuce/lettuce-red-evolution-organic/

Grows quite tall and goes to seed very late even in hot weather.  Leaves are a bit more crunchy than Cantarix.   

PS just read a bit more and wanted to share the history of this lettuce with you.  Red Evolution has 'evolved' (been bred) from lettuce Revolution, which in turn was bred from Lollo Rosso.

Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on September 23, 2023, 06:12:12
That’s a great deep red. As you say it’s striking to have some deep red in a mixed salad bowl. I also love the effect in the garden too. I really enjoy the look of an old- fashioned lettuce bed of mixed colours, in rows even!
The only other deep red I’m aware of is Bijou, which I think I shared a couple of years ago. It would be interesting to grow the two for comparison.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on September 23, 2023, 06:59:31
Having grown both, they are both equally dark red here.  As is Relic, that I shared a few years ago.  And the best part is that the slugs seem confused by the dark red colour.  There is far less slug damage on these lettuces. 
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on September 23, 2023, 12:46:52
I grew Relic in 2019 which I think was the season after you shared the seed. It wasn't quite as red for me, but unfortunately I don't seem to have taken any photos. Perhaps soil conditions? A good lettuce nevertheless.

I hope to have enough seeds of Brighton lettuce, which I found to be an excellent over-wintering green butterhead. The seeds came from Vital Seeds.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on September 23, 2023, 19:06:15
I only had the one Relic plant this year thanks to voles destroying the others, but that was as dark.  Soil and sun intensity also play their part, so even in the same garden there can be differences from year to year.

Frank and Karen Morton from Wild Garden seeds are retiring.  Frank is a well known breeder, among others, of lettuce.  I understand that some of Frank's breeding work is being maintained by Real Seeds now.  It would be a crying shame if with retirement his varieties would disappear, so Real Seed's adoption is most welcome.  Frank Morton's lettuce creations are all OSSI pledged.  Last year Vetivert shared with me 2 of Frank's varieties and I would like to pass seeds on to the circle.

They are Flashy Troutback
https://www.wildgardenseed.com/index.php?cPath=43_72%22

and Flashy Butteroak. 
 https://www.wildgardenseed.com/product_info.php?cPath=43_73&products_id=156

 Now when Frank says 'flashy' this is true.  Vivid purple speckling that says Oh Wow! to the passer-by.  Troutback is a romaine aka cos lettuce, but its leaves are quite soft, whereas Butteroak's leaves are delightfully crunchy and can be harvested a few at a time. 

2 photos each of Flashy Troutback and Flashy Butteroak



 
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on September 25, 2023, 07:42:18
That’s very interesting. Thanks for the update. I’d be interested to know where you read of Real Seeds’ involvement.
Real Seeds have offered Flashy Butter Oak and I believe Frank Morton’s Secret Mix for a number of years so I assume they’ve had some kind of understanding for some time.
I became interested in Morton’s lettuces back in 2016 and ordered about ten of his varieties from his company, Wild Garden Seeds. I’ve collected seed from some of them but the only one I’ve grown this year is Jester (which the man himself has said is his favourite heading lettuce) which unfortunately yielded a very small amount of seed. With the news that the Mortons are retiring, I’ll try all my 2016 seed next season and see what, if any, will germinate, plus any I’ve grown more recently. I’ll aim to pass on any I can successfully grow and collect from.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on September 25, 2023, 08:16:08
Jang, you wrote  "That’s very interesting. Thanks for the update. I’d be interested to know where you read of Real Seeds’ involvement."

This is where I read it. 

"Frank & Karen have now retired and we are taking on maintenance of this incredible genepool on our farm in Wales"

https://www.realseeds.co.uk/lettuce.html
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on September 26, 2023, 08:28:46
I think I should make clear that all of Morton's lettuces are not absolute final versions with guaranteed uniformity like you get in commercial seed packets.  They are  intended to have small differences still coming out with every new generation.  The basic type is fixed, but there is still scope for variabilities, so that the gardener can select their best version for their growing conditions.  This way, Morton's varieties are uniquely suited to a larger growing community in various locations.  Tom Wagner's and Tim Peter's varieties are often also offered with that philosophy.  A broader genetic base for the gardener to make their personal 'final' selection. 

I have taken seeds from every plant to preserve as much of this diversity as I can for members of the circle.  Although both Vetivert (my donor) and myself have already, simply by saving seed and taking these lettuces a generation further, made some selection choices.   
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on September 27, 2023, 08:15:47
Vetivert will perhaps clarify at some point whether her seeds came originally from Frank Morton’s wider mix (which both he and Real Seeds offer for sale) or from seed offered as Flashy Butter Oak (also sold by Real Seeds) and Flashy Troutback (quite widely available). If it was the wider mix then much more variability is to be expected.
I’m unsure of the relationship between Forellenschluss and Flashy Troutback. MoreVeg for example, offer Flashy Troutback and say its other name is Forellenschluss, but Forellenschluss is a much older lettuce, I believe. I’ve always guessed that Morton selected and possibly crossed a little from Forellenschluss and then added the ‘Flashy’ to its translated name. MoreVeg’s assumption that they’re the same might, in that case, be misleading. The original Forellenschluss is speckled to start with, hence the troutback name.

 
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: Vetivert on September 27, 2023, 14:20:44
Hi, the seeds were sourced directly from Frank Morton's company in 2019. Packet labelled 'Wild Garden Mix'. The seeds I shared with Galina were from plants grown from this mix. I've no way of knowing what the exact cultivars in this mix are named, or even if they were all ever released. From the selections I made from this mix, If I recall correctly, what I did was name the seed packets 'Flashy Troutback-like' and 'Flashy Butteroak-like' or something to that effect. Those two look extremely similar, if not identical, to the cultivars released by Morton with those names.

As far as I'm aware, Morton selected Flashy Troutback from Forellenschluss for a more uniform population.

There was another 'Trout' adjacent selection from that mix. I cannot remember off the top of my head which one I shared with Galina but it'll be in my notes somewhere. One had greener, slightly thicker and more savoyed leaves. The other was distinctly more yellow and had smooth, flat leaves. Slight but noticable differences.

Apologies from being absent from discussion, time eludes me lately but shall have a lull in work in soon and hope to catch up shortly. Loving the look of Red Evolution!  :wave:
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: Vetivert on September 27, 2023, 14:49:51
By the way, if you grew any of my contributions from last year, I'd love to know how you got on with them; germination rates, opinions, etc. The scabious self-seeded again so I haven't tried the seed batch from last season.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on September 27, 2023, 18:46:45
Great to hear from you again, Vetivert. I hope the work lull allows you full enjoyment of  harvesting and growing for a while.

Your dark-flowered scabious germinated very well and I've enjoyed the delightful rich colour. Similarly the calendula - excellent germination and good to have the different colour forms to add to a rather ordinary self-seeding gene pool.

All your French beans have germinated well. I've specially enjoyed the flat yellow pods of Uzice Speckled Wax and for a Romano-type it's drying down now quite quickly, and the seed is lovely too. Robert Hazelwood was good and early too.

Rugosa Friulana was probably my most prolific courgette so I'm very pleased to have that one to look forward to again. Rosalaba radicchio is growing away now and has produced very vigorous plants. I'm looking forward to seeing the colour develop.

I love the Oudorpse Bruins shallots. It seems a really reliable classic shallot and multiplied beautifully It's one I intend to keep going.

The only slight disappointment I had with your wonderful range of contributions was the Ambrosia tomatoes. I had trouble germinating Ambrosia Blue for some reason and the one plant I ended up with didn't develop any vigour but I will try again next year. I wonder whether anyone else had the same trouble. The flavour of the pink, gold and red (I didn't grow the Rose UBX) wasn't as sweet as I was expecting and, though perfectly pleasant, didn't seem particularly outstanding to me. Again I'd be interested in anyone else's opinion.

Thanks for prompting feedback. We have exchanged a few reflections but it would be excellent to swap notes rather more on last year's circle contributions and, like Vetivert, I'd very much welcome feedback on any varieties I shared.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on September 28, 2023, 06:26:55
Hi, the seeds were sourced directly from Frank Morton's company in 2019. Packet labelled 'Wild Garden Mix'. The seeds I shared with Galina were from plants grown from this mix. I've no way of knowing what the exact cultivars in this mix are named, or even if they were all ever released. From the selections I made from this mix, If I recall correctly, what I did was name the seed packets 'Flashy Troutback-like' and 'Flashy Butteroak-like' or something to that effect. Those two look extremely similar, if not identical, to the cultivars released by Morton with those names.

As far as I'm aware, Morton selected Flashy Troutback from Forellenschluss for a more uniform population.

There was another 'Trout' adjacent selection from that mix. I cannot remember off the top of my head which one I shared with Galina but it'll be in my notes somewhere. One had greener, slightly thicker and more savoyed leaves. The other was distinctly more yellow and had smooth, flat leaves. Slight but noticable differences.



Thank you Vetivert for the full explanation of the history of these lettuces. Yes it did say 'like' on the packet from you, the significance of which had eluded me.  What you shared with me is the greener version of Trout most likely, not a yellower selection.  There was one packet, not two. The basic colour is green rather than yellow.   And what a joy to grow these.  Having grown Trout in the past, these were nothing like as vibrantly coloured as the Morton version on the same theme. 
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on September 28, 2023, 06:46:59
All beans were great.  However, I had a vole disaster with the Uzice Speckled Wax and full sized plants with early pods were being severed at ground level and could not be rerooted.  One pod emergency ripened with seed and more seeds in the original packet.  Salford Black runner bean had the same fate, but did reroot successfully.  We had several early meals of these and after the vole incident a few emergency ripened seeds.  The new green shoots are not going to flower and make pods in time, so this is a candidate for overwintering this year.  This is usually very successful for runner beans.  Unfortunately voles have certainly arrived in this garden too after two years of hoping I had left them behind.  So I will need to grow through bottles again here too like we did in Rushden.   Robert Hazelwood had both greener and more yellow pods, just like on the SMAC photo.  And that very fine frosted seed pattern.  The red Ambrosia had a salad sized plant as well as the cherry.  Flavour nice, but nothing like the Ambrosia Pinks, which are just outstanding.  Ambrosia Pink is also very blight resistant and blight resistance was certainly tested this year.  Still picking pinks now.  In the greenhouse the later fruit developed more and more the look of pink on the airtable photo, the outdoor ones not, except that I picked the outdoor ones earlier and left them on the windowsill to post harvest ripen indoors in case blight got to them and would spoil them.  Ambrosia Red was not as blight resistant, especially not the salad sized one, which I have not saved seeds from.  The other Ambrosias I have yet to grow. 

Red Venture gave us lots of greens earlier in the year and I have my own seeds now.  Senposai from own seeds also has a prominent spot for a late autumn green.  These were from last year's seeds. 

The shallots were fantastic.  I took the seed parcel home in two parts and stupidly had left the shallots in my daughter's fridge first trip.  Nevertheless, they had not deteriorated which attests to their extra long storage capabilities.  They then burst into life and produced good quality 'nests' of shallots, ready not much later than normal shallots.  Definitely no need to plant these in autumn.  Nice round shallots too.    Rest of seeds in the freezer for next year or the year after. 
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on September 28, 2023, 10:29:59
Interesting the different colouring you experienced on Ambrosia Pink, Galina. Mine have remained stubbornly orange (to my eyes). Photo taken this morning in the polytunnel. I agree that they're delightfully blight resistant. Here there's not been too much blight this season but, as you'd expect, there are signs now on quite a few plants but AP remains blight free and still producing.

I'd also like to echo what you say about Redventure celery. It's wonderful and now self-seeds quite generously here are there around our vegetable garden. Lovely to have this vigorous red stemmed celery popping up. And the shallots - a real favourite and, as you say, seem to keep wonderfully. Mine also were planted in early spring (1st March) and divided very well.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on September 28, 2023, 10:50:45
Here are some French beans I'd like to contribute to the Circle.

Climbing:

Myrtle Allen
A quite early small podded, productive white seeded bean. I received it from a Polish donor who cites his original source as Remy Orlowski. Unfortunately her Sample Seed Catalogue no longer seems to be available online so I haven’t been able to find any other information about the origin of this variety

Pete Ingram Fall
I’m not sure whether a ‘Fall’ bean is supposed to be later but I am finding this one has produced plentiful, very attractive red seeds seeds in good time. It’s from Knott County, Kentucky

Semi-runner

GagGa Hut
A semi-runner bean from the Seneca Native American tribe. I found it to be early and productive with attractive pinto-type seeds.
 
Dwarf

Ukrainian Comrades
Seeds were from HSL. It’s two varieties grown companionably. Good snap beans, one with green pods and one with yellow.

Coco Nain Blanc
I had heard of Coco de Paimpol which in the Paimpol region of France is traditionally eaten demi-sec or freshly shelled. I couldn’t find seed at the time, as it’s a protected variety, so bought Coco Nain Blanc instead which was offered by a French company Alsa Garden as a Coco de Paimpol type. CNB is a very prolific producer of rounded white meaty tender beans which need to be caught at just the right time for demi-sec shellies but make great dried beans if missed.

Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on September 28, 2023, 17:49:23
Yes fall beans are traditionally sown later to come into their own when the weather is a little cooler.  Which makes them excellent for ordinary beans grown at the usual time in Britain. 
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on September 30, 2023, 20:19:56
Sowed a random handful of carrot Solvita seeds on Sunday, today they are up, less than a week.  Won't do anything now but it was only meant as a germination text and we are good.

Harvesting the Like Flashy Trout and Rossia seeds, there were a few spills, which have also germinated.  Here young plants of both lettuces in comparison.  The vivid purple spots on Troutback are already prominent even at this stage. 

Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on October 01, 2023, 08:08:01
Good news on the Solvita carrots, and the splashes on your one young lettuce are indeed very marked.

 As I understand it, Morton’s Secret Mix are all varieties he is/was still breeding from rather than a mix of his offered and finished varieties.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on October 03, 2023, 10:49:16
Climbing French Bean Canadian.  This was one of my guardian seed beans for several years.  And it had its first grow out here and produced enough seeds for eating, seed renewing and sharing.  It is not very late, despite the HSL description.  It always made seeds easily in Rushden.  But definitely one that comes into its own after the summer holidays, when other beans start flagging.  Stringless and full dual use, either as a green bean or for eating the fat seeds.   

https://www.gardenorganic.org.uk/seeds/french-bean-canadian
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on October 03, 2023, 10:56:11
 

 As I understand it, Morton’s Secret Mix are all varieties he is/was still breeding from rather than a mix of his offered and finished varieties.

Indeed, we don't know what went into the Mix (it's a  s e c r e t  :drunken_smilie: ) or which generation after a cross these seeds are.  Not finished, uniform and narrowly defined varieties, but unlikely to change looks substantially. 
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: markfield rover on October 03, 2023, 14:11:57
A query , my friend has grown sunflowers from germinated seed under a bird feeder, which she transplanted to the allotment,the resulting plants have about  five heads each a different colour. I have never seen this before , is it common? Thank you for reading.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: Vetivert on October 03, 2023, 14:18:07
Canadian looks like an interesting addition. The seeds and unusual blush flower colour are identical Kahnawake Mohawk, a Canadian variety that I grew this year.

Morton's Secret Mixes are indeed as you describe them JanG, though I haven't yet grown any. What I had purchased was 'Wild Garden Mix', since delisted. It's a mix of everything, released and unreleased.
https://web.archive.org/web/20200814000742/https://www.wildgardenseed.com/product_info.php?cPath=43_75&products_id=112

I'm sorry to read that the tomatoes weren't as sweet as you had hoped. Do you think it may be down to our cold wet summer? These past two seasons have been very different, and in 2022 I grew them in a polytunnel with restricted water. I'll germ. test the Blue Ambrosia and send you some more seeds this winter.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: Vetivert on October 03, 2023, 14:19:50
Markfield, don't recall ever seeing that before, all on the same plant?? Very odd.

Edit: were they like these? https://www.takii.eu/products/helianthus-annuus-summer-lovin-f1/

If so, I've grown some like it, where there are gradations of the same colour palatte on one plant, but not wildly different colours on the same plant.
I'm under the impression that it is fairly common on decorative sunflowers, but would be surprised to know they are a birdseed type too.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: markfield rover on October 03, 2023, 15:09:36
Vetivert, thank you for your reply , I thought my friend had grown several different varieties and picked a bunch , apart from size they are very different , it’s like picking a bouquet but on the same stem. We will keep seed but have no idea what might happen , we know how to have fun! The bird seed was from Poundstreacher .
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: markfield rover on October 03, 2023, 18:01:07
I hope I’ve attached the photo!
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: markfield rover on October 03, 2023, 18:03:42
Oh my I’ve done it ! The above is the sunflower just one plant and eight variants .
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on October 04, 2023, 07:57:16


Morton's Secret Mixes are indeed as you describe them JanG, though I haven't yet grown any. What I had purchased was 'Wild Garden Mix', since delisted. It's a mix of everything, released and unreleased.
https://web.archive.org/web/20200814000742/https://www.wildgardenseed.com/product_info.php?cPath=43_75&products_id=112

I'm sorry to read that the tomatoes weren't as sweet as you had hoped. Do you think it may be down to our cold wet summer? These past two seasons have been very different, and in 2022 I grew them in a polytunnel with restricted water. I'll germ. test the Blue Ambrosia and send you some more seeds this winter.


Thanks for the clarification on the two Morton mixes. I hadn’t appreciated that there were two different mixes, nor the subtle differences between the two. Interesting. In the wild mix, there is the possibility of actual marketed varieties, whereas not I believe in the secret mix. It’s the secret mix which I bought about 7 years ago and have grown from.

And thanks for the comment on the Ambrosia varieties. My watering in the polytunnel is from drip hose, and I suspect that if anything the tomatoes are over-watered. It’s always quite difficult to tell, and some plants are nearer drips than others. But an abundance of watering might well be a factor.

The difficulties with the Blue Ambrosia might well have been in my hands. The Pink Ambrosia marches on and on producing. Beautifully productive.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on October 04, 2023, 08:01:11
A query , my friend has grown sunflowers from germinated seed under a bird feeder, which she transplanted to the allotment,the resulting plants have about  five heads each a different colour. I have never seen this before , is it common? Thank you for reading.

I’ve certainly not come across anything like this. Most surprising. It will be very interesting to see what comes from the next generation.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on October 05, 2023, 07:24:10
The Pink Ambrosia marches on and on producing. Beautifully productive.

I can only second that.  Wonderfully blight resistant, so tasty and very high production.  One of three tomatoes that are still going strong outside now.  The other two being Tim's Taste of Paradise and Broad Ripple Yellow Currant. 
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on October 05, 2023, 13:35:12
I had a bit of a disaster with squashes this year.  I tried again to add Todo el Año to the circle, but voles severed the plants at ground level with half mature hand pollinated squashes on.  I also handpollinated a big favourite, Sibley.  This has a very pleasing flavour and stores well too.  One of those fruits was destroyed possibly by slugs.  Fortunately the other one with pure seed did well.  Currently post harvest curing on a growbag tray indoors to mature the seeds for the circle.  Fingers crossed it contains many seeds when I cut it open. 

My first seeds were bought from the Abundant Life Seed Foundation.  Fortunately this squash is making a bit of a comeback.  I have noticed that RealSeeds is offering it.  It has excellent flavour and grows well (beasties permitting). 

A description of its origins is here:

https://www.siskiyouseeds.com/products/winter-squash-sibley#:~:text=The%20Sibley%20Squash%2C%20which%20is,vigorous%2012%2D15%20foot%20vines.

Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on October 06, 2023, 08:05:57
Canadian looks like an interesting addition. The seeds and unusual blush flower colour are identical Kahnawake Mohawk, a Canadian variety that I grew this year.



Interesting information.  Could absolutely be the same or a very similar variety.  Both hailing from Canada and without any origin information beyond 'somebody ate these in Canada, liked them and sent them to HSL', they may be the same.  However there are also similar beans in circulation elsewhere, for example the Wildschweinchen (wild young boar, referring to the striping on the bean seeds) here in Bohnenatlas that is known in Germany.  Clearly a popular type.  Chances are that the origin of all the variants is the Kahnawake Reserve of the Mohawk First Nation people.  A genetic study would give clarity here on whether the variants are identical or near identical or whether they have developed away significantly.   
https://www.bohnen-atlas.de/sorten/w/348-wildschweinchen
   
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on October 06, 2023, 08:36:52

 As I understand it, Morton’s Secret Mix are all varieties he is/was still breeding from rather than a mix of his offered and finished varieties.

Indeed and quite different and separate from his Wild Garden Mix, from which both lettuces came that I grew (from seeds from Vetivert). 


I found a little extra information on Morton's Secret Mix on the OSSI group pages.

"Morton’s Secret Lettuce Mix 2021
Crop: Lettuce (Lactuca sativa)

Breeder: Frank Morton (Wild Garden Seed)

OSSI Pledge Date: 1/1/2021

Release Date: 1/1/2021

Bred for Organic Systems: Yes

Commercial Availability: Yes

Stability: Breeding Population

Source: https://www.wildgardenseed.com/product_info.php?products_id=713

Description
I reached back in time this year to grow out a cross of some olde and favorite varieties, ‘Blush Butter Cos’ X ‘Hyper Red Rumple Waved.’ These are truly of a different era, a project I set aside in the heat of other chases. Great taste and color in short romaine heads. There are also crosses of ‘Lotus’ and ‘Manoa’ X “Pointed Red To Heart,” and the next generation of ‘Red Ball Jets’ X ‘Wavy Dory.’ The diversity of shapes, colors, and textures in this mix is pretty overwhelming, and as original as it gets. I like to think his mix gives growers a broader view of what lettuce can be, and some appreciation of all the choices a plant breeder gets to make. Enjoy."




https://osseeds.org/ossi_variety/mortons-secret-lettuce-mix-2021/

Where it gets really complicated is that there seems to be a different 'secret mix' selection offered in 2020, 2022 and 2023.  With different lettuce crosses and different breeding aims. 
https://www.wildgardenseed.com/index.php?cPath=43_75%22


I have just rechecked the Real Seeds page and they refer to an even older secret mix, to which they themselves appear to have added too.  https://www.realseeds.co.uk/lettuce.html


Other Morton lettuce breeding mixes under the OSSI pledge are The Headhunter's Mix a mix of crisphead or iceberg lettuces and the Funny Cut Mix, a mix of oakleaf, frisee types. 





Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on October 06, 2023, 10:42:24
Just harvesting Rose Family Beans, aka Racoon, aka Coon bean seeds.  This is one of the prettiest, but also one of the oddest beans I know.  My original seed batch came from John Yeoman, who got them from the USA.  This is his description. 

Coon
Climbing french Phaseolus vulgaris
Massive knobbly 11-inch long fat flat green bean pods, up to 8 seeds per pod, as wide as a cucumber, succulent and delicious when young; good as a dry bean when mature. Late.  Unknown in the UK. [JY]. 'An Eastern Kentucky heirloom, also known as Rose Bean, collected locally. A multi-purpose bean, good fresh and also dried.'
(eoq)

Mr Yeoman has both names for this bean and says Rose Family and Coon (Racoon) are identical.  However Beans with these names are also listed in the Sustainable Mountain Agriculture Center catalogue.  As two different beans!  With two different locations as origin, both however in Kentucky USA.

Here is Rose aka Rose Family bean.  It has the same type of seeds as mine.   
https://www.heirlooms.org/store/p45/Rose_Bean.html

And here is Coon aka Racoon bean.  This has a pink hue when mature as do mine, but the seeds look different. 
https://www.heirlooms.org/store/p211/Coon_Bean%3A.html

In other words, I don't know which is the exact bean I have, but call them by the prettier name Rose.  As this is also a bean that tends to be more prone to crosses than most, presumably because the flowers are more open and more likely to get visited by bees, maybe it is a third - an onward selection from either or both made by Mr Yeoman.  From the SMAC photos it appears that Rose seems to have fatter pods than Coon, again more similar to what I am growing. 

The pods are indeed very large and of the 'swollen' type, getting more twisted and gnarled as they get older with deep indentation between the seed bumps.  As wide as a cucumber, well that was perhaps a bit of poetic license by Mr Yeoman, but as wide as a gherkin definitely.  Their colour is interesting too, depending on the light, they are either a greenish yellow or a yellowish green.  Pods start off light green and get yellower with age.  The pods stay delectable as a green bean, even when the seeds inside have already developed.  And it doesn't take many to fill the pot, due to their size.  The seeds have the pattern which we call 'frosted'.  Very pretty, similar to Juanita Smith bean, but much larger seeds.  They have a strong string, which is easily removed.  This bean is late.  While I have never had issues saving seeds in Rushden nor did John in in his cool Ridgeway garden, nevertheless an early start is recommended. 


 


 

Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on October 06, 2023, 12:27:50
I had a bit of a disaster with squashes this year.  I tried again to add Todo el Año to the circle, but voles severed the plants at ground level with half mature hand pollinated squashes on.  I also handpollinated a big favourite, Sibley.  This has a very pleasing flavour and stores well too.  One of those fruits was destroyed possibly by slugs.  Fortunately the other one with pure seed did well.  Currently post harvest curing on a growbag tray indoors to mature the seeds for the circle.  Fingers crossed it contains many seeds when I cut it open. 

My first seeds were bought from the Abundant Life Seed Foundation.  Fortunately this squash is making a bit of a comeback.  I have noticed that RealSeeds is offering it.  It has excellent flavour and grows well (beasties permitting). 

A description of its origins is here:

https://www.siskiyouseeds.com/products/winter-squash-sibley#:~:text=The%20Sibley%20Squash%2C%20which%20is,vigorous%2012%2D15%20foot%20vines.



I second the commendation of Sibley squash. It's an excellent variety. I obtained seeds from Plant World Seeds in 2020, and have grown it each year since then. Given my failure to hand pollinate, it will be great to have 2023 seeds to keep growing it for longer.
Good to have the explanation of its origin too. Thanks for that.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on October 06, 2023, 12:36:43

I have just rechecked the Real Seeds page and they refer to an even older secret mix, to which they themselves appear to have added too.  https://www.realseeds.co.uk/lettuce.html

That's a great summary of the Morton mixes. Thanks Galina. Indeed there are plenty of unknowns. In particular it's unclear, as you say, whether Real Seeds added their own varieties or some other Morton varieties in 2014 and 2015. It would be rather surprising, perhaps, to carry on calling it Mortons Secret Mix if they added non-Morton varieties?
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on October 06, 2023, 12:44:11
Just harvesting Rose Family Beans, aka Racoon, aka Coon bean seeds.  This is one of the prettiest, but also one of the oddest beans I know.  My original seed batch came from John Yeoman, who got them from the USA.  This is his description. 



I'm very excited to hear that you're able to contribute Rose beans, Galina, having heard quite a lot about them. The pod formation and history sound fascinating and another frosted bean would be lovely.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on October 06, 2023, 12:45:51
Would anyone be interested in receiving bulbils of Babingtons leek? I have a good crop this year and would be very happy to share with some or all of the Circle.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on October 07, 2023, 08:26:27
Yes please.  I lost my garden ones in winter and only have a single plant as greenhouse reserve which could do with beefing up to get a bit more of a population going.  It has stubbornly refused to flower.  Maybe these would also come to nothing, but I would like another attempt to adapt them to conditions here. 
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on October 07, 2023, 09:40:35
Good to have at least one taker for Babington leek. I hope your second attempt prospers more.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: markfield rover on October 07, 2023, 12:29:16
Yes please JanG, thank you. I have just been given four years worth of guinea pig ‘bedding’ so things are looking up for next year!
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on October 08, 2023, 06:03:16
This year I’ve grown Long Blood Red beetroot from seed you shared in 2021, Markfield. I’ve just liberated the bed from quite a covering of chickweed etc, and found LBR to be enormously vigorous, making beets several times the size of three or four other varieties in the same bed. When I roasted a couple of beets though, they weren’t red as per the HSL description but mainly white with a pale pink stripe, like a paler Chioggia. They were delicious!
I wonder whether anyone else has found the same.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: markfield rover on October 08, 2023, 12:46:51
Interesting, I haven’t grow them or grew them , they were directly from HSL swap but I’ll give them a go next year to compare notes .
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: saddad on October 08, 2023, 20:24:52
I have plenty of Babbington Leeks, I have found they are happy under an old Damson tree I have, out of the way and just doing their own thing!
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on October 09, 2023, 07:05:19
Interesting, I haven’t grow them or grew them , they were directly from HSL swap but I’ll give them a go next year to compare notes .
That’s interesting. Do you mean that you and someone else swapped seeds which had come directly from HSL? It would be good to know whether your friend had grown them on and saved seed or whether they were HSL seeds.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on October 09, 2023, 07:11:00
I have plenty of Babbington Leeks, I have found they are happy under an old Damson tree I have, out of the way and just doing their own thing!

Yes, I think Babington leeks are quite tough once they get going, except perhaps for a certain amount of susceptibility to very cold temperatures if that was what threatened Galina’s. Mine grow in a bed where other alliums have succumbed to white rot but these seem to shrug it off. They did take about three years to build up strength though. I kept thinking in those three years that they had disappeared for good.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on October 09, 2023, 12:35:30
What happened to mine was indeed the double whammy of very acidic soil and sustained freezing temperatures, like weeks of -18C.  And yes, it does take several years to build up a nice population and my greenhouse planted reserve plant isn't there yet, but at least it has survived in the slightly more protected conditions.  In Northamptonshire I had 3 populations, the first in the greenhouse where I planted the original bulbils from HSL, a second underneath one of the big flowering bushes along the borders of my veg patch and a third underneath the Autumn Olive oleagnus plants.  Never an issue and they were being harvested every year. 

The soil acidity here has been addressed and leek, onion and garlic growing is now much easier as a consequence, but the more severe weather conditions, we can't do a lot about.  Greenhouse growing is the obvious way to go - or go without, as unsuitable for the area.  It is a British and Irish coastal plant after all!  As with many things I grew in Britain, here we have to do things differently or give up on them.  So I am looking forward to continuing to acclimatise BL here to at least greenhouse growing and an extra portion of bulbils will be welcome. 
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: markfield rover on October 09, 2023, 14:23:32
Interesting, I haven’t grow them or grew them , they were directly from HSL swap but I’ll give them a go next year to compare notes .
That’s interesting. Do you mean that you and someone else swapped seeds which had come directly from HSL? It would be good to know whether your friend had grown them on and saved seed or whether they were HSL seeds.
I got the seeds from our local Seed Swap and the seeds were from the HSL given to the organiser. Hope this helps.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on October 09, 2023, 14:41:45
Is this a misunderstanding? 

The roots are not meant to be blood red, just the leaves.  Looking at Chiltern Seed's website.  If CH S are now retailing this variety, there is no need for HSL to maintain this variety, and this may well be why they gave packets to a seed swap.

Here is the CH S description.    https://www.chilternseeds.co.uk/item_1714c_bulls_blood_or_beetroot_leaf_blood_red_seeds

This also shines some light on the subject.  Roots are described as "pale red/pink in colour, with clear zoning."   
http://sfnottingham.blogspot.com/2018/02/beetroot-selected-cultivars-long-blood.html
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on October 10, 2023, 12:44:45
Here are some French beans I'd like to contribute to the Circle.

Climbing:

Myrtle Allen
A quite early small podded, productive white seeded bean. I received it from a Polish donor who cites his original source as Remy Orlowski. Unfortunately her Sample Seed Catalogue no longer seems to be available online so I haven’t been able to find any other information about the origin of this variety.

Had a quick search on how to use the wayback machine for old cached copies of pages.  Not that there is any meaningful information here, but this was the old catalog entry. 
https://web.archive.org/web/20210410212122/http://www.sampleseeds.com/?page_id=3725

 Remy writes:  Myrtle Allen bnMyrA
This a small white seeds variety that I can find no info for! It was early to mature so this would be a good one for the north. 
.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: markfield rover on October 10, 2023, 13:16:15
I know this is referring to 2019 , but this year I grew Dwarf Sweet Sue tomato , seed from Vetivert , it was hands down the tastiest tomato this year , up there with Coyote which I believe was from Galina . Thank you.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on October 10, 2023, 17:01:04
MR, Silverleaf was the donor of Coyote.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: Vetivert on October 10, 2023, 17:29:08
Glad to read you liked them Markfield, and that I wasn't alone in thinking that they're jolly good!

JanG, I'd love a few more Babington bulbils please, thank you. The Minogues did well this year, but the Babingtons seemed less entusiastic for some reason.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: markfield rover on October 10, 2023, 18:46:14
Thank you galina , silverleaf the seeds have been shared far and wide, thank you.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on October 11, 2023, 09:10:40
Is this a misunderstanding? 

The roots are not meant to be blood red, just the leaves.  Looking at Chiltern Seed's website.  If CH S are now retailing this variety, there is no need for HSL to maintain this variety, and this may well be why they gave packets to a seed swap.

Here is the CH S description.    https://www.chilternseeds.co.uk/item_1714c_bulls_blood_or_beetroot_leaf_blood_red_seeds

This also shines some light on the subject.  Roots are described as "pale red/pink in colour, with clear zoning."   
http://sfnottingham.blogspot.com/2018/02/beetroot-selected-cultivars-long-blood.html


I am definitely quite confused! Are you thinking, Galina, that Long Blood Red is the same as Bull's Blood, aka Blood Red. I've grown Bull's Blood for years and although I haven't closely examined the roots as I've grown them for leaves, I believe the roots are generally reddish whereas my Long Blood Red is predominantly white with quite pale pink rings, like a paler Chioggia.

I was assuming that Long Blood Red is a different variety from Blood Red, and certainly I haven't come across colouring like that of the Long Blood Red I've grown. The leaves aren't as red or dark as Bull's Blood and, as I mentioned, the vigour is pretty prodigious!

Stephen Nottingham's Food Blog does deal with Long Blood Red, which perhaps he got from HSL, but his roots are nothing like the colouring of mine. Mine aren't long and tapering either, nor particularly prone to forking. I'm still somewhat mystified. Perhaps the seed was donated to the seed swap because it was unstable but perhaps that could have been indicated
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on October 11, 2023, 09:16:36
Here are some French beans I'd like to contribute to the Circle.

Climbing:

Myrtle Allen
A quite early small podded, productive white seeded bean. I received it from a Polish donor who cites his original source as Remy Orlowski. Unfortunately her Sample Seed Catalogue no longer seems to be available online so I haven’t been able to find any other information about the origin of this variety.

Had a quick search on how to use the wayback machine for old cached copies of pages.  Not that there is any meaningful information here, but this was the old catalog entry. 
https://web.archive.org/web/20210410212122/http://www.sampleseeds.com/?page_id=3725

 Remy writes:  Myrtle Allen bnMyrA
This a small white seeds variety that I can find no info for! It was early to mature so this would be a good one for the north. 
.


Thanks for this. Even though Remy didn't have any answers it's good to be able to have her word on it.

I hadn't heard of the Wayback Machine but Google throws it up. I haven't tried it out but it looks as if it could be very useful.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on October 16, 2023, 11:56:44
Tim's Taste of Paradise.  This is a tomato, barely larger than a currant tomato.  Yellow to golden when ripe and very sweet, like biting into a fruit.  Impressive blight resistance too on strong plants. 

Tim Peters is the breeder.  This tomato arose as a selection out of Fruity Mix.  A different selection from the same Fruity Mix that last year's cherry tomato "Fruity Yellow" hails from.  I happened to be chatting to Canadian seed saver Diane Whitehead about the 1999/2000 Internet tomato trials that we both had participated in and I mentioned that one of my tomatoes was Fruity Yellow from Fruity Mix (added to last year's circle).  She then told me how a seed saver, Tien Chiu, had also grown a selection from Tim Peter's tomato Fruity Mix, from an ancient seed packet, and she had then sent on seeds to Wild Boar Farms.  Tien thought she was the only person still to have seeds, even Tim himself no longer had them.

Wild Boar Farm renamed this tomato to Tim's Taste of Paradise, did some selection, and now it is available in their catalogue.  Diane and I swapped seeds both ways, I grew 4 plants, and would like to share Tim's Taste of Paradise with you.  Same robust growth and superb blight resistance coupled with very sweet flavour, and a note of spice if allowed to ripen fully to golden yellow.    My 4 plants were all yellow, ripening to golden. 

Diane sent extracts from the salient pages of Tien's blog.
"MARCH 9, 2018 BY TIEN CHIU

I've decided that I want to breed the excellent flavor of "Fruity Mix" (my favorite tomato from the year I grew 83 kinds of tomato) into larger-fruited tomatoes. There's only one small problem: "Fruity Mix" seems to have disappeared. I've searched all the tomato databases, Googled high and low, and can't find it. Even the original breeder doesn't have seeds. So – assuming my ex manages to locate my original seed packet –  I've decided that my main goal, at least for this year, is to do what I can to preserve that strain. It's a breeding pool, so there is quite a bit of genetic variability – I'm currently researching how to maintain the gene pool. It's not as trivial as it sounds, because tomatoes are natural inbreeders, so under normal conditions you lose a lot of genetic variation in every generation. Heirloom tomato strains – which have naturally inbred for many generations – are pretty close to genetically identical. So if I want to keep the variation, I'll probably have to do some crosses. But I don't know yet how many crosses I need to keep enough variety. (Life is complicated.)
In addition to that, I want to try breeding Fruity Mix into larger-fruited varieties. Fruity Mix is a currant tomato, so while it tastes delicious, the fruits are tiny – maybe half an inch across. Better for grazing than harvesting. If I can breed its flavor into a larger tomato, it would make harvesting and using them much easier.

APRIL 18, 2018 BY TIEN CHIU


These seeds are precious. As far as I know, they are the last remaining seeds of the Fruity Mix and Fuzzy mix tomato breeding pools developed by legendary plant breeder Tim Peters. Tim described Fruity Mix as "one of the best tasting tomato breeding pools I ever developed". And I think he's right – it was easily the tastiest of the 83 tomato varieties I grew in my previous experiments with tomatoes.
Fuzzy Mix, while less important to me, is also really interesting. This mix was bred for its foliage – fuzzy gray leaves – in some cases, as gray and fuzzy as the popular ornamental "Dusty Miller". I don't feel as fanatical about Fuzzy Mix as I do about Fruity Mix, but again, these may be the last seeds of this pool and I would like to keep it going.
I originally got these seeds from Tim in 2000 or 2001. Sometime between then and now, Peters Seed and Research (Tim's business) went out of business.
Unfortunately, the seeds are 17-18 years old now. Tomato seed germinates well up to 10 years, but somewhere between 14 and 16 years germination rate goes over a cliff. So I expect a low germination rate. And for the same reason, I'm planting all the seeds this year – because germination will be even lower next year. It's now or never.
Since the seeds are both delicate and precious, I asked some tomato experts for hints on germinating old seed before planting them. Tim Peters (who bred the pool originally) recommended using bright (non-heating) lights directly above the seed blocks, and keeping the soil at 85-95 degrees. Craig LeHoullier, author of Epic Tomatoes, recommended a couple possibilities and sent data from his experiments. I looked at his data and decided to try soaking in 1 part bleach and 4 parts water for ten minutes, followed by a thorough rinse and brief soak, followed by patting dry and planting in the soil blocks.

JULY 2, 2018 BY TIEN CHIU

I'm surprised that the Fruity Mix tomatoes are so large – I remember Fruity Mix as being a currant tomato, which are supposed to top out around 1/2″ – really tiny. These are more the size of a small cherry tomato. But I'm not complaining! It will make picking them a lot easier. Currant tomatoes taste delicious but are so small that they're really only suited to casual grazing.

AUGUST 20, 2018 BY TIEN CHIU


FRUITY MIX AND FUZZY MIX ARE ALIVE AGAIN!! That is to say, not only are the plants growing, but they are producing new seeds to propagate the varieties forward. They aren't in full swing yet, but I have enough fruits to taste and evaluate each variety, and I am starting to save seeds from the earliest fruits (which were not isolated from cross-pollination) as a hedge in case some massive disease outbreak takes out all the plants in each of the four locations I've got them growing in the Bay Area. (Uh, yes, I'm paranoid, why do you ask?)
It is looking like the Fruity Mix are not all "true to type". Some are larger fruited and some smaller. The smaller ones are the ones with the unforgettable flavor, and there aren't that many of them – at least, not at my place, where the tomatoes are bearing early. So far only four have borne fruit – two of which are insanely good, two mediocre. I've marked the plants to make sure I save more seed from the better ones. But it's clear that I'll have to do at least a couple generations of breeding work to stabilize the variety. Next year I'll see whether I can cram two breeding seasons into one year. They are not exceptionally early varieties, but two generations from seed to fruit is about seven and a half months according to my calculations. We have an amazingly long growing season, but that's still stretching things. I'll probably try it with a few seeds.

The paste tomato on the left side is "Sweet Cream," also by Wild Boar farms, and is the most delicious Roma-shaped tomato I've ever tasted. Plus, gorgeous!

SEPTEMBER 15, 2018 BY TIEN CHIU

The National Heirloom Expo

That's me with Brad Gates and Ben Cohen, both of whom are professional tomato breeders. I'm holding a branch of Fuzzy Mix, and Brad is pointing at a baggie full of Fruity Mix samples that I brought to the Expo. Both of them are very interested in breeding with both Fuzzy and Fruity – which means that the lines will not be lost again. Which means I have achieved my goal of rescuing both varieties and ensuring their future!
Brad and Ben aren't the only ones interested, either – I spent two hours walking the vendor hall, handing out samples of Fruity and showing people the branch of Fuzzy that I'd brought with me. It was impressively unwilted despite having been broken off the previous day – Fuzzy is very drought-tolerant – and of course attractively furry. I now have a list of five or six tomato breeders who are interested. As soon as I get enough seed to send them, I'm pretty sure that the future of Fuzzy and Fruity Mix (or rather, of the genes and characteristics they represent) is secure. What a relief!" 
This is the blog url.
https://www.tienchiu.com/tag/tomatoes/

Today we had our first frost and I literally harvested the last pound of mostly green tomatoes yesterday.  And the first fruits were early too.  A couple of photos. 

 
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on October 16, 2023, 12:38:13
The questions about this beetroot remain Jang, so it seems. 
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on October 17, 2023, 08:12:16
What an interesting history. It’s great to have that detailed background. I wish the history of more of our varieties were so fully documented. Thanks for reproducing it here.
I’m interested in the fact that Tien Chiu states more than once that currant size tomatoes are better for browsing than harvesting. I tend to agree, and quite a lot split if kept off the plant too. How did you find Tim’s Taste of Paradise in those respects?
Great that it has such blight resistance. Whats’s the growth habit like? Did you grow it as a two or three stemmed indeterminate like Fruity Yellow?  I picture it as potentially a large and sprawling plant. Looking forward to growing it next season!
Thank you the large number of contributions you’re preparing to make, Galina. What a lot of small packets you’ll be cutting and folding! In the next day or so I’ll draw together a revised list of contributions so far and repost.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on October 17, 2023, 15:38:39
Split not so much, but if you pick quite a lot of them in a container, the lower ones can get squashed easily, especially if they are very ripe.  Picking order is after more robust tomatoes for that reason.  I also make a tomato salad and then put a handful of them on top. 

Yes, I let them sprawl and support when necessary.  Would have taken quite a bit of pruning to keep to one neat stem.  And it isn't really that necessary either, because with small fruit you do not get such a big weight on the branches. 

Diane who has never watered her plants, found the skins to be somewhat tough, not so here.  She thinks it may have to do with not watering.  She will do so when she grows them next.  When Tien first grew them,  she also mentioned that they were bigger, maybe more like Fruity Yellow.  With this and other Tim Peters varieties  small variations in size can certainly happen.  They are not entirely stable varieties.  Neither do we know exactly what Wild Boar Farms have done with the seeds and what they have selected for.   

Yes it is nice to have the full history and would be even better to have Tim's input too.  We are often concerned that actual heritage varieties should not be lost and do our best to maintain them in circulation, but those newer ones are often at much more risk, than actual old varieties that have found their way into seed libraries and other conservancies.   See also the lettuce discussion.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on October 20, 2023, 10:42:43
Last year I added some square seeded Giant Bolivian Achocha seeds to the circle, in the hope that they may have adjusted to produce earlier.   

I had produced these seeds from a January 2022 sowing, transplanted in May, and enjoyed a great harvest and much earlier than ever in Britain.  But moving a substantial 'house plant' in May was not without its logistical problems. 

This year I both sowed in January and got good early fruit.  However I also sowed some of these seeds in May (as I always used to do in Rushden).  Previously these were far too late for here, even in the greenhouse and literally produced nothing. 

However, this year, from the seeds that potentially have evolved to mature earlier and be less daylength sensitive, I not only got fruit, but also mature seeds.  The first  change I noticed was that the fruits started flowering much earlier than they did in Rushden.  But they then took their time producing fruits from these flowers.  Eventually they did and made mature seeds too.   

I wonder whether anybody else has tried out these seeds this year and whether they also got earlier fruit.  We can only hope that in time it will be as easy to grow Giant Bolivian Achocha, as it is to grow their smaller fruited cousins Lady's Slippers and Fat Baby. 

Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: Vetivert on October 23, 2023, 18:55:17
I haven't yet attempted to grow them galina, but I'll have a go next season aiming for a late Mar-April sowing.


A couple more varieties for the Circle:
Shimonita - Japanese bunching onion (A. fistulosum). Giant winter type that needs a long growing period to achieve full size.

Zapallito de Tronco - Argentinian 'avocado squash' (C. maxima). I've read that these are meant to be a bush but mine invaded nearby beds with vines ranging between 4-7ft. Looks like a blue-green kuri  but eaten immature as a courgette.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on October 24, 2023, 07:28:29
I’m afraid I didn’t grow from your achocha seeds either this season, Galina, but like Vetivert will aim to grow them next year and keep a close eye on when fruits form.
Thanks for your additional contributions, Vetivert. Both sound very interesting. Where did your seed come from for these two?
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on October 24, 2023, 08:54:17
Shimonita, same family as Welsh Onion, but with a much fatter stem.  This sounds a wonderfully useful addition to the garden.  And hopefully equally frosthardy.

The achocha seeds should stay viable for several more years, so no rush to grow them.  Would really appreciate reports when you do.   
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on October 24, 2023, 10:13:05
Shimonita, same family as Welsh Onion, but with a much fatter stem.  This sounds a wonderfully useful addition to the garden.   
Is Shimonita perennial like Welsh onion?
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on October 24, 2023, 10:43:50
We're nearing the end of October so the end of November, our agreed deadline, is not very far away.

The Circle numbers seven keen members so when dividing up your seeds, please could you make up six portions of each variety.

Here is what I believe people have mentioned as probabilities, but of course seed saving is never certain so please don't worry if some seeds haven't made it. And do let me know if I've missed out any that you've mentioned. I think you'll agree it's a pretty amazing collection.

Garrett

Tomato Piglet Willie's French Black (medium dark red/brown)
Tomato Girl Girl's Weird Thing (large red/brown/green)
Tomato Reinhard's Purple Sugar (purple cherry)
Tomato Jaune Flamme (small orange)
Sweet Pepper Jimmy Nardello (small red horn)
Chilli Pepper Basque (Piment d'Espelette)
Climbing French bean Tresnjevac (dry shelling bean)
Climbing French bean Melbourne's Mini (short green pod)
Climbing French bean Selma Zebra (mottled purple/green pod)

Galina

Carrot Solvita
Lettuce Rossi
Lettuce Liller
Mangetout pea Norli
Mangetout pea Pink Flowered Golden Sweet
Pea Auralia
Tomato Bedtimes Macbeth
Tomato Broad Ripple Yellow Currant
Climbing French bean Georgian bean #22
Climbing French bean Juanita Smith
Climbing French bean  Rose
Climbing French bean Canadian
Lettuce Red Evolution
Lettuce Flashy Troutback type
Lettuce Flashy Butteroak type
Climbing French Bean Canadian
Squash Sibley
Tomato Tim’s Taste of Paradise


Juliev

Climbing French bean Madeira Marroon
Climbing French bean Borlotti
Dwarf French bean Bobis d'Albenga
Dwarf French bean Jersey Beef Grex
Aubergine Czech Early
Coriander?
Lettuce mix?


Markfield Rover

Tomato Blaby Special
Tomato Seattle Best of All
Tomato Salt Spring Sunrise
Tomato Imur Prior Beta
Tomato Pigeon Egg
Runner bean Gramp Nicholls 
Pea Tincture A Fleur Blanc 
Pea Stokesley
Pea Espoir de Gembloux 
Mangetout Born
Dwarf French bean Black Valentine
Dwarf French bean Yugoslavian No 4 
Dwarf French bean Borlotti
Climbing French bean Gramma Walters.
Possibly some dahlias
Cosmos Apricotta

Ruud

Not yet specified

Vetivert

Tomato Ivory Tears (white pear/grape tomato)
Sweet Pepper Jimmy Nardello
Chilli pepper Sugar Rush Stripey (C. baccatum)
Sweet pepper Habanada ?(
Dwarf French bean Bis
Dwarf French bean Galopka
Dwarf French bean Tytania
Dwarf French bean. Wstęga
(these are all Polish wax beans)
Squash/courgette Zapallito de Tronco
Bunching onion Shimonita


Jang

Mangetout pea Frühe Heinrich, 
Mangetout pea Roi de Carouby,
Mangetout pea Winterkefe, 
Sugar snap pea Spring Blush
Pea for shoots Dou Miao
Lettuce  Arctic King
Lettuce  Brighton
Lettuce Australian Yellow Leaf
Lettuce Speckled Amish
Cosmos sulphureus
Climbing French bean Myrtle Allen
Climbing French bean Pete Ingram Fall
Climbing French bean Jimenez
Climbing French bean Trout bean
Semi-runner French bean GagGa Hut
Dwarf French bean Ukrainian Comrades
Dwarf French bean Coco Nain Blanc
Leek Babington
Tomato Indigo Apple
Tomato Indigo Cherry Drops
Tomato Stonor’s Most prolific
Tomato Black from Tula
True potato seed from Heidi Red
True potato seed from Blue Annalise

I've added a few to my own list and will go into a bit more detail in the next day or so. Well done, everyone.

 


Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on October 24, 2023, 12:18:29
Lettuce is called Rossia.

Here is the information about Auralia pea, which I got from Silverleaf.  It is a cooking pea, think hummus, mushy pea etc.  And the orange cotyledons give a different nutrient spectrum.   Mine grew a little taller, more around the 5ft mark and yes, better than reasonably productive. 

Here are Silverleaf's comments:
"I thought I’d pop in some Auralia (orange cotyledons).  I got it from JIC with that name, but I similarly found no info about it online. I seem to remember it being around 3 or 4ft, nice healthy looking plants and reasonably productive"   

Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on October 24, 2023, 12:56:20
Pea Norli, is a fairly short, very early maturing mangetout pea with medium large sized pods.  One of the first peas to harvest in the year, but with robust plants that can tolerate quite a bit of adverse weather too.  High yielding.  My source was Samen Mauser from Switzerland. 

https://www.samen-mauser.ch/index.cfm?content=shop&shopcategory=1013&shoparticle=10096004&spr=de


Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on October 24, 2023, 13:32:52
Pink flowered Golden Sweet

This is a variation on the standard Golden Sweet, but with pink flowers. 4 and a little bit ft tall.   Both Jang and myself were given a few seeds from Vetivert.  Who in turn had received them from pea aficionado Andrew Barney in the USA, who reported that the change to pink flowered just happened to show up in a field of ordinary Golden Sweets.  He said  "Pink flowered yellow snow was a mutant of Golden Sweet."

This is very rare indeed.  We don't know whether these are still grown by the unnamed original source who gave these to Andrew.  The first seeds that Vetivert obtained grew into weak plants that took a bit of nursing to produce any seeds at all. 

There was no weakness apparent here.  They grew without issues and produced well.  The pink flowers are very pale pink indeed and the whole plant is just slightly smaller than our normal Golden Sweets. 

All my pea seeds had a spell in the freezer, as we get pea beetles - similar to Broad bean beetles - that make holes in the peas.  Freezing should have taken care of any eggs which might otherwise be lurking in the seeds. 

Jang, your photos are much better quality than mine, and show the variety off better for airtable. 



Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on October 24, 2023, 13:38:32
Yes this is going to be a very exciting special seed share out again, thank you everybody.  And thank you so much Jang, that you again will take care of the distribution, which is not a small task. 

I hope I have now described every variety of mine.  Just one slight comment, Jang.  The tomato is called "Betimes Macbeth", (not bedtimes).  Fingers crossed for Sibley, which I am going to open later today. 

PS Norli is about 2 ft tall and only needs minimal staking or none. 
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: ruud on October 24, 2023, 16:47:48
I will let you know my list for the seedcircle in the weekend
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on October 25, 2023, 18:15:14
Lettuce is called Rossia.

Sorry, you had pointed this out elsewhere and I forgot to correct it. I know very well that it's Rossia but spellcheck thought it knew better and I forgot to spellcheck spellcheck!
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on October 25, 2023, 18:23:12
Lettuce is called Rossia.


Sorry, you had pointed this out elsewhere and I forgot to go back and correct. I knew very well that it's Rossia but spellcheck thought it knew better and I forgot to spellcheck spellcheck!
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on October 26, 2023, 06:59:28
I will let you know my list for the seedcircle in the weekend
Thanks Ruud. Looking forward to hearing what you’ve got up your sleeve!
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on October 26, 2023, 07:17:39
Just one slight comment, Jang.  The tomato is called "Betimes Macbeth", (not bedtimes).  Fingers crossed for Sibley, which I am going to open later today.   
Oh dear, another one. Sorry Galina. As someone who taught Macbeth to teenagers year in, year out, I am very fond of the name ‘Betimes Macbeth’ and have wanted to grow it for some time. And from what you said previously it is indeed betimes. I’ll try to make sure I control the spellcheck in the Airtable base.

Fingers crossed for Sibley.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on October 26, 2023, 08:16:31
No issue Jang.  Thankyou, yes we have Sibley seeds drying after washing the debris off.  And already eaten some squash last night.  It was very sweet with dry orange flesh and that wonderful melon smell, as you cut into it.  Didn't quite make up for the melons being a wipeout this year, but the at least the squash worked.  And with further storage it can only get better flavoured. 
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: lezelle on October 27, 2023, 10:25:00
Hi all, I really like the look of those yellow tomatoes you have grown Galina nd wondered where can I buy them? Thankyou.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on October 28, 2023, 17:40:35
When I am in England next, I could send you a few seeds.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on October 29, 2023, 11:11:13
Here are a few notes and a couple of photos relating to the lettuce and tomato varieties I'm hoping to contribute to the Circle.

Lettuces

Arctic King
A very hardy butterhead lettuce. I can’t find any information about when it was first offered commercially but it is certainly a variety that can be grown successfully for either over-wintering or sowing early in spring

Australian Yellow leaf
My seed originally came from Real Seeds. It is extremely productive making large loose heads of yellowish frilly, pleasingly crunchy leaves. I’ve found it very reliable. It makes lots of seed too and I have it popping up here and there in the garden. I rate it highly.

Brighton
My seed came from Vital Seeds. It is another reliable cold weather lettuce. I sowed it in October last year, kept it under cover over winter, planted it outside in February, and it made very pleasing buttery heads.

Speckled Amish
I included this partly because of the recent discussion about Frank Morton and his breeding and selecting work. I had this seed from his company, Wild Garden seeds in 2016. The seed still germinated and so I managed to save seed this year.
Information from Fedco Seeds says, “An ornamental bibb of spectacular beauty, its apple-green leaves splashed with maroon flecks, a stunner whether in your garden, on your table or in your salad. Small firm mild-flavored 10" heads shaped like Merveille des Quatre Saisons, centers with soft leaves blanching creamy yellow. Mennonites brought seed in a covered wagon from Lancaster County, Penn., to Ontario in 1799. Introduced into commerce in 1880 as Golden Spotted. Frank Morton has been selecting to alleviate tipburn”

Tomatoes

Indigo Apple
I very much enjoyed this variety this year. It grows abundantly like a cherry tomato but is larger with a slight hint of beefsteak in its shape. It is quite early and productive.

Indigo Cherry Drops
Another excellent tomato, a cherry one, from The OSU indigo breeding programme. I bought my original seed from Thompson & Morgan

Black from Tula
This is a large tomato which is a dark red beefsteak-type with dark green shoulders. There seems some doubt as to whether it originates from Tula in Russia or is a family heirloom from Ukraine. It is said to have a complex smoky flavour. I’m not sure that I could detect the smokiness but the flavour was pleasing and complex.

Stonor’s Most Prolific
This is a variety held by HSL. It is quite prolific, medium sized and orangey-red. The HSL description reads, HSL:
“The donor of this tomato is a 1940s enthusiast and saw this variety mentioned in adverts dating back from at least 1940, before Suttons acquired the seeds from F Stonor of Southampton.
Suttons began marketing the variety in around 1942, when it made its first appearance in their seed catalogue.
It produces strong plants and small, firm, orange-red fruits with pinkish-red flesh, perfect for eating raw in salads and sandwiches.” 
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: ruud on October 29, 2023, 13:11:31
my contribute for now will be :tomatoes- balikesin kivircik
                                                           seftali
                                                            grandma`s viney`s
                                                           blue beauty
                                                           uriasu de dolj
                                                           giant oxheart
                                                           mari de salaj
                                                           appetytnyi
                                         peppers- mozart
                                                       tepecik yakan
                                                       menderes
                                                       carliston
                                                       demre
                                        beans-    turkey craw
                                                      vignerone/weinlanderin
                                                      ice bean crystal wax
                                                      golden sunshine
                                                      large white runner
                                                      controne
I will look if i can contribute some other vegetables too but that will depends on the amount i got from one variety.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: lezelle on October 29, 2023, 16:33:05
Hi All,
           Wow I didn't think there were so many different plants to grow. Amazing. I now the ones in shops must be mainly f1. I have grown butternut squash and so pleased with results. I will do more consideration now. Brilliant. Thankyou all
Lezelle 
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on October 29, 2023, 16:50:18
That's great, Ruud. Thanks for getting your list together. A great selection. Some interesting sounding tomatoes especially. Are some of them Turkish?
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: ruud on October 29, 2023, 21:46:13
some from turkey and some from romanian.They are old heirloom types of tomato.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on October 30, 2023, 07:23:42
Thanks, and really interesting. When you have time, it would be good to have any information or experiences you’ve got about the most unusual ones, especially the Turkish and Romanian varieties.
I’ve very much enjoyed your Turkish peppers. Çarliston for one has been amazing.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: markfield rover on October 31, 2023, 14:38:41
For the circle…
Tomatoes.. Seattles Best of All. Indet,78 days. Medium red fruit grows well outside.
                 Salt spring Sunrise.  Semi determinate,some blight resistance, medium size red fruit sturdy plant , grow in or out Canadian variety.
                  Imur Prior Beta . Grows to about 4 foot , happy outdoors, small red/pink fruit. Potato leaf . Originated from Norway. HSL
                   Pigeon Egg. Cordon medium red fruit.  Seed passed on from Seed Savers Exchange Iowa USA in 1992, who no longer conserve it.HSL
                   Blaby Special . My MIL received the seed from Dr Russell Sharp from Lancaster
University who was reintroducing the tomato to Blaby Leicestershire having ceased cultivation after the Second World War, I believe this was about 2006. A medium red fruited cordon.

Runner bean …Gramp Nicholls , HSL , still growing strong! (31/10/23)

Pea …..Tinc A Fleur Blanc , tall white flowered , long pods 6/7 peas good flavour, ex commercial
Variety. HSL

            Stokesley …( as in North Yorkshire ) 4/5 foot tall yellowish pods, white flowers ,sweet tasting.
             Espoir de gembloux…..4/5 foot. Good cropper , originally from Belgium.

Mange Tout….Born …..tall pink/magenta flowers , can be sown early . Named after a Swiss teacher Ester Born. HSL
 
DFB …..Black Valentine, fresh or dry , cool weather tolerant. A really good all rounder. My favourite to date. HSL

            Yugoslavian No4 ….Green flat pods , flowers pale pink lilac. HSL
CFB …….Gramma Walters barlotti.  I haven’t cooked these but it’s recommended for drying.

My dahlia seed saving failed again , but I do have cosmos , Apricotta , and no end of pink morning glory if anyone fancies .
Sorry for lack of information, there just isn’t too much out there.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on October 31, 2023, 16:47:53
Great to have that information. Thanks Markfield R. I had you down for a dwarf Borlotti separate from Gramma Walters. Think I got that wrong. It seems it's time for another updated list with Ruud's on and my mistakes corrected. I'll get to that shortly.

And after we get the seed together and redistribute, I'll put all the info you've given onto the Airtable base again.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on October 31, 2023, 17:03:24
And some more background info from me - peas and true potato seeds

Peas

Mangetout Frühe Heinrich
My seed came from Vetivert - thank you Vetivert - who originally had seed from Heritage Seed Library. It is a really good mangetout for sowing very early as it’s  quite hardy. I’m trying to growing it overwinter this winter and will see how that goes.There seems to be some question as to whether it’s Dutch or German in origin. It’s a prolific and hardy round seeded mangetout. Plants are about 4’ (1.2m) tall.

Mangetout Winterkefe
Another hardy, possibly more hardy mangetout. I have sown it in October and in February and both worked well. Traditionally in Switzerland it has been grown over winter. About 6’ (2m) tall. My seed was originally from Brown Envelope Seeds in Ireland. 

Mangetout Roi de Carouby
Seed came from HSL. This is quite similar to the more widely available variety, Carouby de Mausanne as both have large sweet pods.There has been discussion on another forum as to whether they are in fact the same variety but it’s thought that they might be different but share a common ancestor.  I haven’t grown the two varieties side by side so would welcome feedback from anyone familiar with Carouby de Mausanne. In the meantime it is an excellent, productive, large podded mangetout 5’ -6’ (about 2m tall

Sugar snap  Spring Blush
This is one of several excellent varieties bred by Alan Kapuler in US. It has a pink blush to the edible pods. It is now quite widely available commercially. Grows to about 6’ (2m).

Pea shoots Dou Miao
I received this in a seed swap with no information. When I looked online I found that it seems to be a dwarf variety grown in China for shoots. Interesting that it has hyper tendrils which I’ve not otherwise come across in a very dwarf pea. It grows only to about 2’ /60cm tall. I'd be interested to know of any other dwarf hypertendril pea varieties.

True potato seed

Tps from Heidi Red. Heidi Red or Heiderot is German bred, dating from 1977. It has deep red skin and flesh, and oval tubers. The seed saved from its berries might well be quite variable in what it produces

Tps from Blue Annelise/Blaue Anneliese. Blue Annelise was bred in the same area of Germany known for its potato growing, Luneburg Heath. It has blue skin and blue flesh, and fair blight resistance.  Again the seed from its berries should produce an interesting range of possibilities.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: ruud on November 05, 2023, 08:55:07
wenn do you want the seeds on your doorstep
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on November 05, 2023, 11:17:20
https://www.urbanharvest.sg/products/maple-pea-shoots-dou-miao-microgreens-organic

Dou Miau information. 

Maple peas, also known as pea sprouts, pea shoots, or dou miao, are a local favorite in Singapore! They have long, pale stems with tender leaves, and taste best stir fried. Pea shoots can also be enjoyed raw in pastas, sandwiches, as garnishes or in salads.

Sweet and delicate tasting, pea shoots pack a powerful nutrient punch, containing vitamin A, C as well as a myriad of other antioxidants and phyto-nutrients. Maple peas also have a high protein and fibre content.

Peas have to be soaked for 8-12 hours before sowing. Maple pea shoots grow fast and can be harvested in just one week's time, making them perfect for beginner gardeners or those who want to enjoy their delicacy fast. Easy to grow, and tastes fresher than any store bought pea shoots!

eoq

I also know the Mrs Lei aka Mrs Lee pale pink flowered pea is said to be best for pea shoots (its pods are really lovely!) and that one does not have the maple type seeds.  So maple seeds do not automatically equate to peas being used as pea shoots.  Other maple seeded peas, like HSL's Latvian Soup and Latvian Christmas peas are simply non-sweet soup or stew peas.  And neither is that Victorian oddity, the Parsley Pea, which is  most suited to pea shoots because of its leaf shape.   
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on November 06, 2023, 06:57:47
Hi Ruud and everyone else. Please could you have seeds ready to arrive by the end of November. I will pm all involved with my details in the next 24 hours.
I hope final sorting into six little packages of each variety goes smoothly. Looking forward to some great sharing!
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on November 06, 2023, 07:16:14
https://www.urbanharvest.sg/products/maple-pea-shoots-dou-miao-microgreens-organic

Dou Miau information. 

Maple peas, also known as pea sprouts, pea shoots, or dou miao, are a local favorite in Singapore! They have long, pale stems with tender leaves, and taste best stir fried. Pea shoots can also be enjoyed raw in pastas, sandwiches, as garnishes or in salads.

Sweet and delicate tasting, pea shoots pack a powerful nutrient punch, containing vitamin A, C as well as a myriad of other antioxidants and phyto-nutrients. Maple peas also have a high protein and fibre content.

Peas have to be soaked for 8-12 hours before sowing. Maple pea shoots grow fast and can be harvested in just one week's time, making them perfect for beginner gardeners or those who want to enjoy their delicacy fast. Easy to grow, and tastes fresher than any store bought pea shoots!

eoq

I also know the Mrs Lei aka Mrs Lee pale pink flowered pea is said to be best for pea shoots (its pods are really lovely!) and that one does not have the maple type seeds.  So maple seeds do not automatically equate to peas being used as pea shoots.  Other maple seeded peas, like HSL's Latvian Soup and Latvian Christmas peas are simply non-sweet soup or stew peas.  And neither is that Victorian oddity, the Parsley Pea, which is  most suited to pea shoots because of its leaf shape.   

Thanks Galina. I didn’t include this information, although would probably have put it in the database, partly because I’m not familiar with the term Maple peas. Can you clarify what they are? I also wouldn’t say they have to be soaked for 8-12 hours. Mine germinated as readily as any other pea. Mine also didn’t grow as fast as is claimed on this site but that was perhaps influenced by the fact that I planted them outdoors from their modules in March while it was still cold.

I can’t be absolutely sure that mine are the authentic Dou Miao. I included them because I was fascinated by the hypertendrils in dwarf peas. (Can it be that maple peas = hypertendril peas)

Any more clues around the question of maple peas gratefully received. And also I’d very much like to know whether dwarf hypertendril peas occur commonly. If in doubt I’ll simply label my seeds as dwarf hypertendrils.

And of course, any variety of pea can be grown for shoots. The abundance of tendrils adds a little something though.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on November 06, 2023, 08:44:21
Maple refers to the seed pattern.  The Unity pea which we had in the circle has the maple pattern. The seed packet in the previous url shows the pattern too.  Marbled on a brown background is maybe the best way to describe the colour of this seed.

https://www.midlandsnz.com/our-products/seed/maple-peas

This seed colour does not necessarily go with the semi leafless, aka hypertendril feature.  However all maple peas I know are non sweet peas, neutral starchy, rather than sweet and therefore fit well with savoury stews etc.  Whereas the classic green mushy pea has a sweetness to it, mushy peas or hummus made from maple seeded peas are not sweet.  Maple ie marbled seeds come in large and medium sized.  Unity and Latvian Christmas are large,  Latvian soup is medium sized.  Picture shows maple pea Latvian Soup. 

Hypertendrils are very frequently bred into short, farmed petit pois or garden peas (think Birdseye freezer packets rather than savoury peas), as they prevent lodging, ie the whole stand of peas falling over flat on the ground in high winds, which would make it impossible to harvest with combine harvesters.  The hypertendril feature makes plants cling to each other much tighter than ordinary pea tendrils do.  I grew a batch of Sugar Magnolia with hypertendrils and rather than needing several tall support sticks and tying my tall peas up, the Sugar Magnolias only needed one sturdy stick and they clung to that and to each other.  It is a useful feature, but mostly employed in commercial pea farming. 
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on November 06, 2023, 10:17:36
Thank you for a full explanation. I'm familiar with the marbled-type seed coat but hadn't come across the term 'maple' before. I wonder why that term is used. I can't think of a connection between maples and that patterning.

So, my Dou Miao doesn't have maple seeds so clearly not Dou Miao!

I had previously connected hypertendrils with Alan Kapuler varieties like Sugar Magnolia. But it sounds as though my peas are very like the commercial ones you refer to. In fact they look like a typical wrinkled pea. I didn't taste them so can't vouch for their sweetness. It's probably best not to send these to the Circle then, unless anyone wants a dwarf self-supporting pea for either shoots or for trying for sweetness.

Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on November 06, 2023, 10:54:42
I understood 'Dou Miao' to mean pea suitable for pea shoots, rather than a distinct variety name.  This applies whether it is the maple seeded variety in the first url I sent or not.  As I said, Mrs Lei aka Mrs Lee is also 'meant' to be for pea shoots, but we love the sweet long pods and its beautiful pale pink flowers, having found out only much later to try its shoots too.  :) 

From what I understand, in Singapore a Dou Miau pea is not a single variety, but whatever somebody considers to be a good variety for pea shoots.  There may be a great many different pea shoot varieties.  Dou Miau simply being the label on a box of pea shoots on the market.   

Why not include, if you wish, with appropriate labelling.  A short hypertendril marrowfat pea for pea shoots or similar. 

You will know your seed source and maybe ask further questions there of actual origin, OS.  Is it from Singapore?  Or might you get similar features from a health food store packet of dry peas bought in Britain, that your donor grew and liked for Dou Miau pea shoots, Singapore style.  Either way, if it is a good variety, it is good for the circle. 

It is a bit like the Lancashire Lad purple pea from HSL we were growing for many years, that turned out to be wrongly named, the real LL being green podded.  And nobody knows the name of the purple one.  Should we have dropped this purple variety as a consequence?  No, of course not.  I once added the purple 'not' LL with the annotation that it isn't the real deal, but nevertheless a great pea with really great productivity.    It isn't the fault of the pea that we don't know its actual variety name.   And so it is here.   

Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on November 06, 2023, 12:08:23
Thanks again for the further very helpful clarification. I don't think it's a marrowfat pea. As I said, it looks probably more like a sweet variety as it has white flowers and wrinkled seeds. But yes, I will keep it in the Circle but add notes in the way you suggest.

My donor is quite unreliable over naming and not very forthcoming with information but he does have a wide range of varieties and his seeds are always interesting if often perplexing. This is why I included the seed with reservations. I thought it was interesting enough to offer but I wasn't sure of the accuracy of its naming. I might try asking for further information about its provenance but I'm not very hopeful! However, on the grounds that Dou Miao indicates suitability for pea shoots, I'll keep the name for now but with lots of explanations.

Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: juliev on November 06, 2023, 13:48:37
Hello everyone,
here are the seeds I have available for the circle:

aubergine Czech early, seeds from https://www.incredibleseedlibrary.com/product-page/aubergine-czech-early (https://www.incredibleseedlibrary.com/product-page/aubergine-czech-early)
grown in polytunnel

beans (dwarf)
bobis d'albenga
, I've been saving seeds for years. very tasty pods, stringless, can be a bit enthousiastic when growing in rich soil but I've never used supports for them
red swan, seeds from https://www.organiccatalogue.com/seeds/vegetable-seeds/bean-seeds/bean-red-swan_MH8009 (https://www.organiccatalogue.com/seeds/vegetable-seeds/bean-seeds/bean-red-swan_MH8009)
such a pretty bean! mainly grown for seed this year so can't comment on taste.
flageolet flagrano, seeds from https://mr-fothergills.co.uk/products/dwarf-bean-flagrano-flageolet-seeds (https://mr-fothergills.co.uk/products/dwarf-bean-flagrano-flageolet-seeds)
trying a second variety of flageolet, performed really well compared to the usual chevrier.
mogettes, seeds from French supermarket "edible" dry beans
not sure what the commercial variety is, maybe mogex. It is similar to cannellini bean (don't tell my dad I said this...) As it is protected, it shouldn't be called mogette unless it is grown in Vendée, but nevermind. I got an earlier and better yield than cannellini.
annellino di trento, seeds from https://www.happygreenshop.com/veg-herb-seeds/vegetable-seeds/dwarf-italian-bean-40-seeds-anellino-di-trento (https://www.happygreenshop.com/veg-herb-seeds/vegetable-seeds/dwarf-italian-bean-40-seeds-anellino-di-trento)
I was hoping for a similar bean to bobis d'albenga, unfortunately they are smaller and  fill up quicker, a bit like major cook. I'll be growing them with the drying beans and will use them like borlotti.

climbing beans
borlotti, I've been saving seeds for years.
madeira maroon seeds fromhttps://www.beansandherbs.co.uk/product/madeira-maroon/ (https://www.beansandherbs.co.uk/product/madeira-maroon/)
tarbais seeds from https://www.beansandherbs.co.uk/product/tarbais/
like the mogette, it is protected so technically shouldn't be called tarbais... all that matters is that it produces well and tastes amazing in stews.
italian snap seeds from https://www.beansandherbs.co.uk/product/italian-snap/ (https://www.beansandherbs.co.uk/product/italian-snap/)
a pretty mottled bean turning pink/purple as it ages. big beans inside. a bit of a mystery though, as apart from the beansandherbs listing, I can't find anything similar under that name...

winter squash
mantovana
C Maxima, a few seeds given by a friend from a friend who grows them in Italy. handpollinated
After doing some research, it seems different squashes are called "mantovana". this one looks like delica mantovana. It is a small dark green heirloom, like a buttercup/black forest. sweet dry flesh. I had one fruit so not many seeds to share but I only have one original seed left so would feel better sharing them this year just in case...
 

summer squash ? I need to do a germination test on those as they seem flatter than usual, although they are bigger than usual...
tromboncino/ trombetta d'Albenga C Moschata, from saved seeds. handpollinated
ronde de Nice C pepo, from saved seeds. hand pollinated

garlic chives

lettuce mix
mix of https://www.premierseedsdirect.com/product/lettuce-gourmet-looseleaf-cutting-mix/ (https://www.premierseedsdirect.com/product/lettuce-gourmet-looseleaf-cutting-mix/) saved seeds and https://vitalseeds.co.uk/product/lettuce-wild-garden-mix/ (https://vitalseeds.co.uk/product/lettuce-wild-garden-mix/)
I still have the original packet of seed for the wild garden mix so will grow them separately next year to save seeds (following the conversation about Frank and Karen Norton's retirement).

calendula descendants of snow princess. pretty pale lemon flowers, I save from the best plants every year. 
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: juliev on November 06, 2023, 14:36:29
a little bit about me and my garden...
I grow in my back garden and more recently on an allotment plot, on the Essex/Suffolk border.
I like to grow a wide range of varieties to find out the ones which can cope without too much fuss.
I grow because I like to cook and I cook because I like to eat! (probably thanks to my French-Italian roots...)
Last year, after realising I needed yet another seed box (and discovering landrace gardening and breeding my own varieties), it was clear I needed to find a way to share my surplus seeds, and quick! I started small seed libraries that I distributed to local schools, businesses, outside my house etc. At the moment, they are packets of mixed varieties but I'd like to replace them with locally adapted mixes. I really enjoy working with the schools and sharing heirloom beans and multicoloured popcorn (the look on their faces!) and hope to help them develop some seed saving habits too.

I am so grateful for being part of this year's circle and can't wait to grow out all those wonderful varieties.



Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on November 06, 2023, 17:46:54
Thank you for your great contribution Juliev.  So much to look forward to.

For the bean Italian Snap, I may be able to provide a bit of extra info.  It is preserved by Arche Noah, the Austrian Heritage Seed Library equivalent.  For some reason it also circulates under the name of Italian Snape and there are a few more seed sources under this name. 

The variety description catalogue of Arche Noah says this:  Wurde 1909 aus Italien in die USA gebracht. Seit 1995 von SSE.  Was taken to USA from Italy in 1909 and since 1995 safeguarded by Seed Savers Exchange, the USA version of the British Heritage Seed Library.  From there it went to Arche Noah.  https://sortenhandbuch.arche-noah.at/suche/nach?utf8=%E2%9C%93&query=Italian+snap
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on November 07, 2023, 06:36:02
Thanks from me too, juliev, for a great range of contributions and for the notes you include which are very helpful. I’m especially interested in some of your dwarf beans. The Flagrano sounds delicious. Do you grow it for fresh shelling or for drying? I’m beginning to really like bean varieties which give good fresh shelled beans. Good to have your researches too on Italian Snap, Galina. I grew the variety many years ago and like you, juliev, was rather frustrated by the lack of information I could find.
Interesting that you found that Vital Seeds also sell the Mortons’ Wild Garden lettuce mix. Nice that you’re able to offer another continuation of their selecting and breeding efforts. The calendula sounds very pretty.

Thank you also for filling in with some insights into you and your growing. Your work with seed libraries sounds great and clearly you produce a lot of seed! With schools, for example, are your seed libraries gifts which you go in and talk about, or is the idea that they ‘borrow’ the seeds and aim to return in kind? Either way, it sounds an amazing way of encouraging growing and seed saving.

Really good to have you join the Circle.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: ruud on November 07, 2023, 15:24:18
    Grandma`s viney`s-                                                  Family heirloom from Grayson County, Kentucky.

Large fruit weighing 200 to 400 grams, beefsteak type, flattened and ribbed at the top, the shoulders tend to curve for large sizes.

Magnificent multicolored dress, a shades of orange-red and yellow pink.

Beef flesh marbled with yellow and pink, containing very few seeds.

Taste completely devoid of acidity, sweet and fruity, excellent.

Plant with great development, moderately vigorous, large stem, regular foliage, indeterminate growth.

Good, regular and long production, better in the second half of the season.

Good natural disease resistance.

Bag of at least 12 seeds - Harvest 2021. limited quantity.

TOMATO, BLUE BEAUTY
Rating:
88% of100 73  Reviews Add Your Review
80 days. This recent Brad Gates introduction was selected from a cross between ‘Beauty King’ and a blue tomato. Fruit is modest beefsteak-type slicer, weighing up to 8 ounces, and the flavor is as good as its outstanding antioxidant content! Gorgeous, deep blue-black shoulders make this unique among slicing types. Excellent potential for market, as the fruit holds well on the vine. Sunburn and crack resistance are a welcome bonus.

Giant Oxheart Tomato
#00300Questions? Call 1-800-345-5977
90 Days
This well-named giant produces large, pink, 12 oz. to 2 lb., firm, meaty, heart shaped fruits with thick walls, few seeds and a mild flavor. The vigorous vine
s produce high yields of fruits that mature late but are well worth the wait!
Indeterminate.


balikesin kivircik
red curly village tomato seeds originating from Balıkesir

It is a very productive variety. More than 7 kg of yield can be obtained from one seedling. I recommend you to plant this variety, which is one of the delicious village tomato types, in your garden. It takes approximately 130 days from seed to harvest. It is more productive and fruit size is better in loamy soil. It likes loamy permeable soil. It is one of the tomato species. If you take good care of it, you will be very satisfied. Since it is a mature tomato, leave the seedling spacing wider when planting.

Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: ruud on November 07, 2023, 15:59:41
beans

runner bean golden sunshine
This is the showiest runner bean we've found! The chartreuse foliage appears to glow in the sunlight and provides a contrast to the loads of scarlet red flowers that beckon hummingbirds. The climbing plants produce a bumper crop of tender, flattened, 5-6 in. green pods that are excellent for eating fresh, canning and freezing. Golden Sunshine Runner Bean grows 5-6 ft. tall and requires some type of support, such as a fence or trellis. It's sure to add color and interest to the flowerbed, garden or edible landscape. 85 DAYS.

turkey craw
Turkey Craw Pole Snap Bean, 14 g

HeirloomEspecially well-suited to the Southeast
Product Image for Turkey Craw Pole Snap Bean
$3.75


67 days. [Heirloom from VA, NC, and TN. According to folklore, a hunter shot a turkey and removed a bean from its craw; the bean was later planted and saved, hence the name Turkey Craw.] Often used as a cornfield bean. Excellent fresh flavor. Good canned. Similar to other beans for freezing and drying quality (“leather britches on a shuck”). Pods grow 3½-4 in. long and cling to the vines. Seeds are buff, frosted with brown on one end. Pkt (~52 seeds)

vignerone/weinlanderin

'Weinländerin La Vigneronne' Beans are a classic of Swiss garden culture. This little known variety has been cultivated and preserved by the country women of Switzerland. Known as 'Wine country beans' this vigorous, old variety of pole bean has distinctive pods that are marbled and speckled with purple, as if stained by drops of wine.
The plants are hardy and can cope with both cooler weather and longer periods of drought while still producing excellent yields. This stringless pole bean can be used both as beans pods and as grain beans, the pod has a beautiful colour, and the kidney-shaped kernels are also beautifully mottled.

A vigorous mid to late season variety, the plants grow quickly giving rise to dark pink flowers, quickly followed by an abundance of stringless, fleshy purple-marbled pods that grow up to 25cm (10in) long and are round in cross-section.
Sow indoors from mid April for transplanting later on, or direct sow outdoors from late May to July. The plants also stand out due to their very high yield that can be harvested from mid-July through to the end of October. Harvest continually, at least once or twice a week, when they reach 12 to 15cm (5 to 6in) in length.
The pods are stringless and after cooking, they retain their bite very easily. Keep picking for harvests that last all summer. They are also suitable for freezing and drying.

'Weinländerin La Vigneronne' can be grown against a trellis, up netting or up tall canes set 100cm (3ft) apart. They can be interplanted with peas or runner beans. Because they use vertical space, they free up the horizontal rows in the vegetable garden for other varieties while bearing abundant harvests and they are easier than bush beans to harvest.
Many gardeners prefer pole beans for their distinctive 'beany' flavour. Eaten raw they make a tasty and crunchy addition to summer salads, but their versatility doesn't end there as they are perfect for freezing - and any left at the end of the season can be dried and the beans used as haricot beans.

ice bean crystal wax

Phaseolus Vulgaris ( Crystal White Wax Bean )
‘Crystal White Wax’, also known as the ‘Ice’ bean, is an heirloom variety which is best staked to keep the beans off the ground until they are mature, 45 to 60 days after sowing. The pods are 3 to 3 1/2 inches long, and must be checked daily for ripeness, for they do not keep well on the vine. As a shelly bean it has a delicious nutty flavor, but the dry bean is good as well, and can be cooked like barley. This is a bush bean that nonetheless has runners emerging, up to 3 feet long. Best grown forced, in a greenhouse. This group of beans is a favorite for the home garden and can be grown just about anywhere because they have a relatively short growing season. They can be planted from seed as soon as the soil is warm (day temperatures are around 60 degrees Farenheit), in full sun and loose, well drained soil. Bush type beans are very easy to grow and manage, reaching a height of only 2 feet tall. To control harvest, bush beans can be planted every two weeks. To decide how many crops you can plant, divide your growing season by the maturation period of the variety you are planting. When preparing soil, be sure not to mix in too much nitrogen (5-10-10 is best) or you will get all plant and no beans. 1 pound per 100 square feet is plenty. There is no need to soak beans prior to planting and no need to heavily water right after planting. If coat is cracked too early, germination may be poor. Beans should be planted about 1 inch deep and two inches apart, with rows at least 2 feet apart. Pole type beans should be planted at least 4 inches apart, 6 inches being better, and have rows 3 feet apart. Pole beans will require some type of trellising system, with the tee pee system working quite well. It is alright if beans are a little crowded, as they lend each other support, however, thinning to 4 inches is best.

large white runner
(Phaseolus coccineus) Large white runner bean. Vigorous climber. White seeds have fantastic flavour and texture both fresh and dried. Keeps on producing. 15 seeds. Heirloom from Denman Island, BC

controne
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on November 08, 2023, 12:43:41
Thank you very much, Ruud, for making the effort to contribute detailed notes on your tomatoes and beans.

If you are able to also say where you yourself originally got your seeds from - a particular seed company, a market, a swap etc - that would be really helpful and interesting especially for varieties that are most unusual, eg Turkish, Ukrainian etc.
It’s likely that you have access to seeds that UK residents can’t access or don’t know about. So it’s great to have your input and some background. 🙏
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on November 08, 2023, 12:58:06
Carrying on the Dou Miao saga, my donor has responded with the interesting information that he had the seeds from an Italian friend, Alessio Gennari,  who travels to Asia and writes on Facebook as Terre di San Secondo. His friend writes about the variety here:
https://m.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=3060671413984484&id=1059957067389272
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: ruud on November 08, 2023, 16:13:02
beans: turkey craw source bohnen-atlas
           vignerone/weinlanderin source bohnen-atlas
           golden sunshine source bohnen-atlas
            large white runner swap
           controne  source bohnen-atlas
           ice bean crystal wax  source guy dirix webside Belle Epoque meisse.


tomatoes: balikesin kivircik brought from turkey
                seftali means peach in turkish brought from turkey
                grandma`s viney`s swap
                blue beauty   source swap
                uriasu de dolj from my romanian friend Gheorghe Papurica Gradina who has a webside called Bi-Schon
                mari de salaj from the same source
                appetytnyi source swap


Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on November 08, 2023, 23:11:43
Thanks again, Ruud. That’s really helpful. And one more question …..! Sorry to twist your arm.

Are your peppers brought from Turkey too? And which might be sweet and which chilli?
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: garrett on November 15, 2023, 18:22:59
I've posted mine today. I'll check through my photographs and do some posts describing each variety, hopefully I'll get that done by the weekend.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on November 17, 2023, 05:01:32
That’s great, Garrett. I’m away till Saturday but hope to confirm safe arrival on return.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: ruud on November 18, 2023, 12:56:18
 
mozart
This pepper, popularly known as village pepper, is consumed fresh, pickled and dried. Fleshy fruits are dark green in color. The average fruit length is around 10-13 cm.

 

 

Seed Planting

 

-Sowing Time for Outdoor; Spring Summer.

-You can plant indoors in four seasons.

-Seeds should not be buried too deep in the soil, they should be planted about 1 cm below.

-Seed germination time is 12-18 days.

-You need to throw 2-3 seeds into the seed holes you opened.

-Maturation Period is 80-90 days.

-The soil temperature suitable for seed germination is 18-30 degrees.

-The soil in which you germinate should be slightly moist, not too watery.

-You need to germinate in places that receive light.

-Before planting the seeds, keep them in room temperature water or a damp cloth for 2-3 hours. In this way, the seeds that absorb water will germinate more easily.

tepecik yakan

https://zenitttohum.com.tr/tohum/10/tepecik-cin-biber

menderes

PEPPER - MENDERES (BITTER)
It is a hot pepper variety with dark green fruits, suitable for fresh and pickled consumption. The stem side of the fruits is 20-22 cm, slightly bellows. It is thin and pointed in length. It is an early pepper variety that is resistant to tobacco mosaic virus and can reach the first harvest in 45-50 days from planting to the first harvest, with a total harvest time of 140 days. The yield of the variety per decare is around 2.5 tons.
 
carliston
Carliston is originally from Turkey and is very popular there. The peppers are mildly hot and are delicious in salads. They change color from lime green to red during ripening and are usually harvested in the unripe phase. The peppers grow to about 20 cm long and about 4 cm wide.

demre

https://www.tohumevi.com.tr/urun/demre-tatli-biber-tohumu-geleneksel
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: garrett on November 18, 2023, 14:31:02
Melbourne's Mini (also known as Melbourne's Miniature): "A reliable and versatile French bean with creamy white flowers and prolific crops of short tender green beans. If pods are left to mature, the small white seeds are excellent used fresh or dried in soups and casseroles. Allotment holder Syd Melbourne grew and saved this variety for over 30 years before donating it to the Welsh community group Dyfi Valley Seed Savers in 2010 – it has been popular with mid Wales gardeners ever since".

Seed from the Wales Seed Hub. I enjoyed this bean as the pods retained a pleasant crunch even after cooking.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: garrett on November 18, 2023, 14:38:01
Tresnjevac: "Round seed, most unusual colours grey striped with purple. Quite late maturing but lots of slightly striped pods. Pod stage but usually grown for shelling". Generally considered to originate from Croatia or Serbia.

Seed from a seed swap, originally from Beans & Herbs. This is a beautiful bean with grey speckles like a stone, dries very cleanly.

Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: garrett on November 18, 2023, 14:54:26
Selma Zebra: "JC Metze developed this bean from a family bean in the 40-50s and sold the patent to Parks seed which listed the bean in the 70s". The bean was since delisted and lost for decades until some seed was donated to the  Seed Savers Exchange.

Seed from Thompson & Morgan. This is a delicious bean pod. I've read mixed reviews where people say that they need to be picked very young otherwise they are tough, but that was not my experience. I've eaten them when bumpy with beans inside and they have still been tender, full of beany flavour and with a great texture to chomp into.

Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: garrett on November 18, 2023, 15:00:10
Jimmy Nardello sweet pepper: "This true Italian heirloom has been grown by the Nardello family since the 19th century.

The Nardellos took the pepper seeds with them to the USA in 1887, and when Jimmy Nardello passed away in 1983 some were donated to the Seed Savers Exchange.

Prolifically produces slender, twisted fruits, slightly fatter than chillies, that become very juicy and with a sweet, mild-peppery flavour when red."

Seed from Plant World Seeds. Great for growing outside and ripens much sooner than typical bell/bulls horn peppers.

Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: garrett on November 18, 2023, 15:09:07
Basque Pepper: "The “Espelette” chili pepper (Piment d'Espelette in French, Ezpeletako biperra in Basque) is a culinary icon of Basque Country with a production area limited to 10 villages nestled in the foothills of the Pyrenees Mountains. The pepper is the first, and currently the only spice in France to carry the European Union’s “PDO” (protected designation of origin) label which both protects its name and regulates its process of production". Peppers not grown in this area are given the common name of Basque Pepper.

Seeds from Real Seeds. This is a very fruity, sweet hot pepper, very low on the scoville scale at just 4,000. Prolific and early, I was picking ripe peppers by late July.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: garrett on November 18, 2023, 15:15:48
Piglet Willie's French Black tomato: "Mid season, regular leaf, indeterminate with Chocolate coloured fruit averaging 2oz (60g). Variety with unknown origin. Probably a strain that former garden blogger Pigletwillie (US) collected during a trip to France a few years ago.

Round dark red fruits with chocolate coloured shoulders.
Juicy flesh with an intense taste. Excellent yields!"

Seeds from a seed swap.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: garrett on November 18, 2023, 15:18:59
Girl Girl's Weird Thing tomato: "Indeterminate, Regular leaf, Mid season producing Purple oblate fruits with Green stripes averaging 8oz (225g)

Girl Girl’s Weird Thing’ is a beautiful mutation of the ‘Green Zebra’ tomato discovered in Canada by Jessica Hughes around 2010. Jessica’s dog, Girl Girl, found it in a row of ‘Green Zebra’ and brought it to her.
The fruits are oblate, with dark maroon and green stripes, and has softly ribbed shoulders".

Seed from a seed swap.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: garrett on November 18, 2023, 15:22:08
Reinhard's Purple Sugar tomato: "Very recent variety of Reinhard Kraft, Germany. Small purple-red cherry tomatoes with a sweet aromatic taste. Indeterminate growing plants with regular foliage."

Seeds from a seed swap.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: garrett on November 18, 2023, 15:25:23
Jaune Flamme tomato: "Beautiful tomato that originated with Norbert Perreira of Helliner, France. Commercialized by Tomato Growers Supply Company in 1997. Early crops of apricot-colored 4 ounce fruits borne on elongated trusses. Excellent fruity flavor with a perfect blend of sweet and tart." Indeterminate, regular leaf.

Seed from Plant World Seeds.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on November 19, 2023, 11:44:00
I've just returned from a few days away and it was exciting to come back to the packages of seeds from both Garrett and Markfield Rover. Thank you both for the brilliant packaging you did which makes my job very straightforward.

Thanks also to Garrett for very helpful detailed notes and images. It's really good to have the information, especially information which can't be found online - where you yourself got your seeds from and any experiences you had when growing the variety. Your own pictures also add interest and are very helpful. All will be added to the database before too long.

Thanks also to Ruud for adding some details about the peppers you're contributing. I've had great results from your eastern pepper varieties and, speaking personally, you've enriched my pepper growing considerably.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: ruud on November 19, 2023, 13:15:37
Good to hear that my peppers are doing so well,i hope these varieties will do there job next growing season.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on November 19, 2023, 16:10:08
Selma Zebra: "JC Metze developed this bean from a family bean in the 40-50s and sold the patent to Parks seed which listed the bean in the 70s". The bean was since delisted and lost for decades until some seed was donated to the  Seed Savers Exchange.

Seed from Thompson & Morgan. This is a delicious bean pod. I've read mixed reviews where people say that they need to be picked very young otherwise they are tough, but that was not my experience. I've eaten them when bumpy with beans inside and they have still been tender, full of beany flavour and with a great texture to chomp into.

There seems to be a bit of a mystery around this variety. In 2021 Galina contributed Zelma Zesta to the seed circle and pointed out that ZZ is sometimes named Selma Zesta but that this is a separate variety form Selma Zebra even though superficially they're similar.

However, the story of the origin of both beans, Zelma Zesta/Selma Zesta and Selma Zebra is sometimes given as JC Metze developing the bean etc etc.

I wonder whether anyone knows any more or has grown the two side by side. With your contribution, Garrett, it could be possible to grow both varieties to compare. Certainly the seeds look very similar. If anyone wants a few seeds of Zelma Zesta for comparison, I think I probably have some spare.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on November 19, 2023, 16:51:10
I believe Selma Zebra to be a Swiss bean.  HDRA Heritage Seed Library was my source a  long time ago and they mentioned the origin as Switzerland.  Which was the reason I chose it, because our family has a Swiss connection.  No longer offered by HSL, as there are now commercial sources.  When I came across S(Z)elma Zesta, I was told about Mr Metze and the bean he had developed in USA.   And this is the information I provided with the seeds shared. 

But I have been puzzled ever since about how come a very similar named bean was apparently developed in the USA.  Or was it taken to USA by a Swiss immigrant and marketed there.  Does Mr Metze also lay claim to Selma Zebra?   I am not aware of that and haven't read that anywhere before today.  The paper quoted below proves that it was bred from the bean Weinländerin and it does not mention Mr Metze.  The paper also notes its origin as Swiss. 

SZ and Zelma Zesta appear to be separate beans, and there are slight differences from memory, although I have not yet grown them side by side.  Lastly, Rattlesnake is another that is quite similar and so is Cousin Oliver's, which I shared with the seed circle some years ago and which may (or may not) be the same as Rattlesnake, but grown side by side CO is much more high yielding.   


https://www.e-periodica.ch/cntmng?pid=bhl-002:2000:110::232
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on November 19, 2023, 17:37:51
This is the Zelma Zesta description also stating that Selma Zebra is a different bean.

I am Rodger Winn, better known as Rodger on the forum here. I am the grower of this bean for Southern Exposure Seeds. My wifes family is the devbeloper of this bean. My wifes Great Uncle Mr JC Metze developed this bean from a family bean in the 40-50s and sold the patent to Parks seed. Those that are members of Seed Savers Exchange can view pictures of this bean on the online catolog. Everyone else I will try to post a picture in the next couple of days. This is not the Selma Zebra, This is Zelma Zesta as Mr JC had it written when he gave me the seed but it was probably Selma Zesta listed in the Parks catolog. I was not able to find it listed in Parks since they did not retain all catologs and Mr Jc Metze told me it was in the 60s early 70s that it was listed. The bean is best used when pods are pencil size. It is very productive and produces reliably in the summer months here in South Carolina, a time when lots of other common beans fail. So it is a good varity for warmer areas good green bean flavor and very productive, can be tough and stringy if not picked when pods are young about pencil thickness and lenght. Rodger

https://www.houzz.com/discussions/2002122/zelma-zesta-selma-zesta-pole-beans
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on November 19, 2023, 18:01:57
Basque Pepper: "The “Espelette” chili pepper (Piment d'Espelette in French, Ezpeletako biperra in Basque) is a culinary icon of Basque Country with a production area limited to 10 villages nestled in the foothills of the Pyrenees Mountains. The pepper is the first, and currently the only spice in France to carry the European Union’s “PDO” (protected designation of origin) label which both protects its name and regulates its process of production". Peppers not grown in this area are given the common name of Basque Pepper.

Seeds from Real Seeds. This is a very fruity, sweet hot pepper, very low on the scoville scale at just 4,000. Prolific and early, I was picking ripe peppers by late July.


I'm very excited that you've contributed these to the seed circle. I was in Espelette in September and was interested in the whole tradition around growing these peppers in and around that small town in the Pyrenees. Locals decorate their houses with peppers in late summer and have them on stalls to sell to visitors. I was going to buy a  dried pepper or two for seed but found that you could only buy them in rather long strings and as I already had more dried peppers at home than I could ever use, I decided against it and thought I'd try to get seed elsewhere. So, lovely that you've offered it, Garrett, in our very own seed circle!
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on November 19, 2023, 18:12:24
This is the Zelma Zesta description also stating that Selma Zebra is a different bean.

I am Rodger Winn, better known as Rodger on the forum here. I am the grower of this bean for Southern Exposure Seeds. My wifes family is the devbeloper of this bean. My wifes Great Uncle Mr JC Metze developed this bean from a family bean in the 40-50s and sold the patent to Parks seed. Those that are members of Seed Savers Exchange can view pictures of this bean on the online catolog. Everyone else I will try to post a picture in the next couple of days. This is not the Selma Zebra, This is Zelma Zesta as Mr JC had it written when he gave me the seed but it was probably Selma Zesta listed in the Parks catolog. I was not able to find it listed in Parks since they did not retain all catologs and Mr Jc Metze told me it was in the 60s early 70s that it was listed. The bean is best used when pods are pencil size. It is very productive and produces reliably in the summer months here in South Carolina, a time when lots of other common beans fail. So it is a good varity for warmer areas good green bean flavor and very productive, can be tough and stringy if not picked when pods are young about pencil thickness and lenght. Rodger

https://www.houzz.com/discussions/2002122/zelma-zesta-selma-zesta-pole-beans


Thank you, Galina. That's very clear. Rodger Winn obviously has first hand knowledge of the Zelma/Selma Zesta bean and the history of it. It leaves then the mystery of what origin and history Selma Zebra has. As the names and appearance of the seeds and I think also the purple splashed pods are so similar, you would be forgiven for thinking there's some connection at some stage of development. But what that connection might be seems difficult to establish.

Is it at all possible that the 'family bean' from which Zelma Zesta was developed in the 40s and 50s was in fact Selma Zebra?

 
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on November 19, 2023, 18:23:02
I have avoided coming to this conclusion myself, as I have no proof.  We really can only report on what seems proven and that is that S Zebra was bred from another very old Swiss variety and Z Zesta was 'developed' in the USA.  Whether there is a connection or whether this is a fluke of a coincidence, we may never now.  Intriguingly, there is also Rattlesnake, which I have only ever known as a bean from USA.  There is an outside chance that this may be involved in ZZ too.  Again, we don't know. 
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on November 19, 2023, 18:33:42
I have avoided coming to this conclusion myself, as I have no proof.  We really can only report on what seems proven and that is that S Zebra was bred from another very old Swiss variety and Z Zesta was 'developed' in the USA.  Whether there is a connection or whether this is a fluke of a coincidence, we may never now.

Interesting. I certainly wasn't wanting to suggest that that link between ZZ and SZ might be anything other than a floating thought.
I haven't come across the Swiss history for Selma Zebra which you have given here. That certainly helps separate the two varieties from one another. Can you elaborate on it at all?
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on November 19, 2023, 20:08:22
Elaborate any more than quoting a paper on Swiss varieties that  contains Selma Zebra as a Swiss variety?  No I can't unfortunately.  And Samen Mauser who retail them have no origin information or breeder info.  In their current catalogue they only list Zebrina, presumably a further development. 

https://www.samen-mauser.ch/index.cfm?content=shop&shopcategory=1090&shoparticle=10047004&spr=de
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on November 20, 2023, 06:15:33
Thank you. That’s helpful.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on November 21, 2023, 05:46:29

I haven't come across the Swiss history for Selma Zebra which you have given here. That certainly helps separate the two varieties from one another. Can you elaborate on it at all?

Just looked at the pages of Pro Specie Rara (the Swiss equivalent of the British Heritage Seed Library). It has Selma Zebra in its collection.  This is what they say. 

Die Sorte wurde aus Kreuzungsversuchen der Firma Mauser in den frühen 70er-Jahren selektioniert und ist heute nicht mehr im Handel. Gesprickelte, leicht gebogene Hülsen. Die Sorte ergibt gute Erträge. Die Hülsen eignen sich zum Dörren und Tiefkühlen.

This variety was selected from crossing trials made by seed company Mauser in the early seventies (of the last century) and is today no longer available commercially.  Striped, slightly curved pods.  This variety is productive.  The pods are suitable for drying and freezing.

Which suggests it is a younger variety than Zelma Zesta, which was said to have been developed in the 40s and 50s according to Rodger Winn.  From the Pro Specie Rara entry we have the timeline when Selma Zebra was bred, from the above paper on page 9, we have the parent varieties as Weinländerin and various bush beans and we have the breeder, the Swiss seed company Mauser.   

  https://www.prospecierara.ch/de/pflanzen/sortenfinder/detail.html?tx_psrsortenfinder[showUid]=GE-1075

Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on November 21, 2023, 07:57:47
Thank you, Galina, for persisting and successfully sorting out this muddle. We have two entirely separate histories (unless I suppose the family bean which was developed in US could also have originally come from the Swiss Weinländerin, also I believe known as La Vigneronne) which seem by coincidence to be both very similar and have confusingly similar names.

No wonder bean nomenclature is such a minefield!
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on November 26, 2023, 05:49:17
I have another French bean, a dwarf one, to add to the circle. It’s Guryn Golden. I found it to be very productive of pencil-podded wax beans which are good to eat at the pod stage. It has white seeds. I received it in a swap from a grower who originally had it from Revival Seeds in US. Its known history seems to be from within US and to go back to the 1980s.
Many of my beans this year were afflicted with rust but this variety remained pleasingly resistant.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: Vetivert on November 27, 2023, 19:17:16
The Circle parcel from me will be on its way tomorrow.

Due to insuffient crop I've had to cancel the Polish dwarf beans for this year, and the Habanadas produced some weird hollow-looking seeds, so those are out too I'm sorry to say.

But they are replaced by some very nice beans from eastern Kentucky and the southern Ozarks, and a pea and sweet pea.

So the final list from me for this year will be:

Bunching Onion (A. fistulosum)
Shimonita http://kanko.shimonita.jp/journey/en/138/

Dwarf Snap Bean (P. vulgaris)
Cream Six Weeks aka Cream Colored Six Week or Six Week Cream Colored. Not to be confused with Cream Colored Fall Bean.
Woods Mountain Crazy Bean https://seedsavingnetwork.proboards.com/thread/64/woods-mountain-crazy-bean?page=1

Tall Pea (P. sativum)
Alex https://www.gardenorganic.org.uk/seeds/pea-alex

Tomato, Indet. Pear
Ivory Tears https://www.vertiloom.com/en/ivory-tears-seeds.html

Sweet Pepper (C. annum)
Jimmy Nardello https://www.tomatofifou.com/en/produit/jimmy-nardello/

Hot Pepper (C. baccatum)
Sugar Rush Stripey https://www.vertiloom.com/en/sugar-rush-stripey-seeds.html

Summer Squash (C. maxima)
Zapallito de Tronco https://www.gardenorganic.org.uk/seeds/squash-zapallito-de-tronco

Hybrid Sweet Pea (Lathyrus x hammettii)
Enigma https://www.rpsweetpeas.com/product/enigma/
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: Vetivert on November 27, 2023, 19:44:31
I've attached an article from the NSPS Annual in which Keith Hammett gives a brief overview on the origins of 'Enigma'. This is a L. x hammettii sweet pea - an interspecific hybrid of L. odoratus and L. belinensis.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on November 28, 2023, 00:11:50
That’s a very exciting list of varieties, Vetivert. Great that you were able to find alternatives to the varieties which didn’t produce as well as hoped.

The account of the breeding of ‘Enigma’ is fascinating. A quick google suggests that Lathyrus belinensis used in the breeding is a very attractive orangey variety found in a very small area in Turkey. Seed seems to be available in UK and it’s apparently grown in Cambridge Botanic Garden, which I visit from time to time. It feels rather tempting to try to track it down and perhaps to try to grow it along with the variety ‘Enigma’ which you’re offering. It would be good to know your source for ’ Enigma’ seed.

I’m beginning to realise how helpful it feels to have a record of where seed came from before we grew it, in order to contribute to being more likely to be able to trace the lineage of particular varieties. So it would be great if we could pass that information on with the seeds we offer. This is partly a note to self as I’m not sure that I’ve always done that. Many thanks to those who have already included that information.

I’m very pleased to report that two packages have successfully and quite quickly crossed the Channel with one more on its way. Congratulations to everyone for getting seed packages under way in such good time. 



Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on November 28, 2023, 07:56:20
Looking forward very much to Sugar Rush Stripey Baccatum Vetivert.  I have grown Aji Fantasy again this year (seeds from A4a seed circle from goodlife) and love that fruity flavour.  So the Sugar Rush will be one I am keen to grow.  Looked at it in a seed catalogue only yesterday.

Other contributions look great too, thank you. 
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: Vetivert on November 28, 2023, 22:25:33
JanG the sources for all of the seeds are on the packet labels, plus the links on the previous list are also to the sources (with the exception of Shimonita (Unwins) and Cream Six Weeks (Russ Crow).

It would be good to know where you have found available L. belinensis seeds as I haven't had such luck.

There are many other L. x hammettii cultivars out there, though none were stable and usable from the F1 gen with the exception of Enigma and Three Times as Sweet. The previous hybridisation attempts in decades past required backcrossing to L. odoratus as the resulting plants were quite weak.

I'm very happy that to read that Sugar Rush was on your wishlist Galina. The plants were surprisingly easy to grow, large and very productive. I'm definitely dedicating more space to peppers next season!
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on November 29, 2023, 07:54:02
Apologies. Lathyrus belinensis seed is apparently offered by two or three UK companies but in fact they are either sold out or links lead to an empty page. I had only gone by what appears on a Google search and hadn’t gone to next stage. Alas each enquiry led to a dead end. Rather surprising as there seems to be quite a lot of interest in the species.

Thank you for clarifying seed sources. All noted.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on December 03, 2023, 10:37:49
I'm very pleased to say that all seeds have now arrived and safely survived the rigours of various postal systems.

I hope to package them up and get them in the post within the next couple of days. Exciting times!
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: markfield rover on December 03, 2023, 16:20:14
I am way too excited! Thanks JanG.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on December 05, 2023, 21:24:21
All the seed parcels have been despatched today. I hope they arrive with you quickly and safely
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: garrett on December 06, 2023, 16:09:19
My parcel arrived today. Thank you to Jan for organising and everyone who participated. I have everything laid out ready to investigate and decide what to grow next year. I'm particularly delighted with all the beautiful beans and tomatoes, I've already spotted several that were on my wish list.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: Vetivert on December 07, 2023, 09:42:42
It arrived yesterday and it's absolutely marvellous! Thank you everyone  :angel11:
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on December 08, 2023, 10:26:30
I just had word from my friend that my parcel has also arrived safely awaiting our next visit.  Thank you JanG and thank you all.  I am so looking forward to unpacking and growing these treasures.

:icon_cheers:         :blob7:         :wave:
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: markfield rover on December 09, 2023, 13:28:41
Mine has arrived too. I shall place packets into my advent calendar and enjoy the treats until early January . Thank you everyone and especially JanG for making it happen.Merry Christmas and happy gardening.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on December 10, 2023, 07:15:52
That’s great. Thanks, Markfield Rover. Apart from Ruud’s which will take longer (fingers crossed for its smooth transit), there’s just one more we don’t know about. Hope it’s actually arrived safely. 🤞
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: juliev on December 10, 2023, 09:40:58
Hello everyone,
mine has arrived safely too. I am beyond excited! :blob7: (and glad I took on a second allotment plot...ahem...)
A big thank you to everyone and especially Jan for organising it.
I'm hoping for another round in 2024...
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on December 12, 2023, 08:01:35
Great that all the UK parcels have safely arrived. Post from mainland Europe into England has been quite fast. Let’s hope it’s as good the other way.
And yes, looking forward to growing all these wonderful varieties in 2024 and with it of course saving, saving, saving seed!
I’m working on gathering all your very helpful and interesting notes, photos, web links together and putting them on the Airtable database. Those who have access can check by all means though at the moment it’s incomplete and might have errors. I’ll send out links to it in a few days when it’s fuller. Any more photos, info etc always gratefully received.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on January 05, 2024, 10:14:24
We have been able to share, grow and taste several of Adam Alexander's varieties, mainly via MR and also from the Heritage Seed Library.  Here is a podcast that may be of interest from GO with Adam Alexander.  Hope you enjoy it.

 https://audioboom.com/posts/8419485-january-2024-an-interview-with-the-seed-detective
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: juliev on January 16, 2024, 10:45:20
Hello everyone,
I hope you are doing well.
I have been sorting out my seeds and it's definitely time to start a seed back up in the freezer.
How do you go about freezing seeds? jars, bags? long term vs medium term? Any type of seed that doesn't germinate well after freezing? Any advice would be much appreciated...
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on January 16, 2024, 13:41:11
Seeds must be very dry.  We can assume they have been dried well enough from the seed circle.  But we can add desiccant, like those tiny baggies that come with Covid tests or inside shoeboxes, handbags etc. 

Then I pack well before they go in the freezer.  Either in a glass jar with a twist off lid or in 3 layers of plastic.  I (mostly, could do better at times)  label what is in the baggie, so that it can be read from the outside without having to open it. 

When you want to take out a variety, take the whole jar or package and leave it for 24 hours or until it has definitely come up to room temperature.  Because if the seed packets inside the jar are still cold when you open the lid, they just attract moisture.  After taking packets out, just pack it all up again and into the freezer it goes.  Storage is for years and decades. 

If seeds went in dry, then there are none that will not germinate after freezer storage.  Obviously it is different for plant material, seed potatoes or the Babington leek bulbils cannot go into the freezer, but tps can. 
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: juliev on January 18, 2024, 10:21:51
Thank you so much for your reply Galina. I was concerned the repeat thaw-freeze would damage the seeds. You've put my mind at ease.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on January 21, 2024, 12:09:50
Galina’s reply is comprehensive and spot on in my experience. I would keep the thaw-freeze to a minimum but accessing packets now and again when necessary should be fine.
I find organising the seeds carefully the most important thing to minimise needing to rifle through too often.   I make use of plastic boxes which I label as peas, beans, etc and the year or year range. Boxes will stack well and should be air-tight. But I’m sure you’ll find your own way of organising.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on February 10, 2024, 13:31:17
Just got to open and gaze at my marvellous seed package.  Thank you everybody so much.  Can't wait to start this year. 
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on April 12, 2024, 18:39:36
A very happy PS to add.  Last winter wasn't quite as cold as the previous years, the coldest being -13C and not for many nights in succession either.  Seems that self seeded lettuces like similar to Flashy Troutback and similar to Flashy Butteroak can indeed survive these conditions. And similar to Flashy Troutback looks stunning right now!  They are beautifully winter hardy.  Outside in the garden.  I took the self seeded Rossia, planted it in the greenhouse over winter, and that has been feeding us for several weeks now already, as I hoped it would.  Just today I also discovered one tiny Red Evolution among the weeds.   I have taken photos of similar to Flashy Troutback and similar to Flashy Butteroak.  Thank you for these delightful seeds again Vetivert, which have just revealed a very useful additional feature, their hardiness.  Hope they will do equally well for the circle members. 
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on April 13, 2024, 07:31:26
They look amazingly healthy and perky after surviving -13. Great to know.

I’ve planted out both Rossia and Red Evolution from an early February sowing. Looking promising. Pictures later perhaps.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: juliev on April 15, 2024, 12:01:34
Hello everyone,
I just wanted to say a massive thank you for this wonderful seed circle. Everything is growing beautifully so far: chillies, peppers, tomatoes, TPS, lettuces, perennial leeks, peas (despite the voles and slugs... ahem). I can't wait to start sowing beans and squashes  :blob7:

Question about the TPS: they are in cells at the moment, I've thinned to the 2 strongest/cell. Some of them have purple/red on the stem and others don't. I'm curious to see what happens... Can I pot them on and then plant them together? I'm guessing that would reduce the plant vigour and tuber numbers/size but would give me more variety to select from. Any advice on the next steps welcome...
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: galina on April 15, 2024, 17:20:07
Glad your seeds are doing their thing beautifully for you. 

The thing with tps is that in the first year they are not quite the finished product and you don't want to carry on with all of your new types. 

You can expect to get mini tubers, rather than full sized tubers.  But the tuber size does vary, usually between pea and large plum sized.   

Another consideration is yield.  You many have a plant with a single mini tuber and the next may have twenty.  A clear choice which variety to carry on with, all other things being equal.  There are also differences in plant size vs tuber production.  You can have a bonny, large plant with disappointing yield below and equally the opposite.    Blight resistance also varies, make notes to know which are the most resistant plants. 

And you also want to taste test them.  Occasionally you will find a tuber that tastes 'lemony'.  Discard all tubers from that plant and don't carry on with them.  Because that lemony tang means that there is too much of the substance in this particular strain, which makes potatoes very slightly poisonous.  I have forgotten the name. 

What I would stress is that you want to be able to choose between your new potato varieties.  They aren't all equal.  And it is much easier to tell them apart, if you plant them well separated, so you know at harvest time whether that one single mini tuber was all there was, or that the twenty tubers did indeed all come from the same plant. 

Red vs yellowish stems.  You may well have red and yellow or whitish potatoes resulting.  But no guarantees of that fact.  Just make notes which plant (I number my plants for convenience) had red stems.

By the way (and this is way early) when you come to taste your mini tubers, one of each plant, I find it easiest to sit them in in a circle in one of my steamer trays and the first to taste has a toothpick in it, then the others get tasted going clockwise.  Quick notes at the time, as they will all be different.  Steamed gives excellent results and you know which one was which because you start with the toothpick marked potato which is number 1.  Others do it a similar way, but instead of steaming they microwave their mini tubers.  I use the toothpick method, but you can equally put each potato in a small biscuit cutter and have several biscuit cutters in the steamer tray, each with a different variety potato inside. 

I am sure you know that in principle each plant from true seeds is a ready new variety.  Apart from producing full size tubers only in the second year, there is no further change in characteristics or flavour.  What you see is the ready new variety.  Growing from tps is a lot of fun and the new varieties will be virus free.  You will be able to propagate from them for a number of years to come.  With bought seed potatoes you will see deterioration due to virus much quicker. 
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on April 17, 2024, 07:18:05
I agree with Galina that growing potatoes from seed is an enjoyable exploration and you might well be experimenting for a few years with the small tubers you get this year. I grew potatoes from seed in 2020 (and again this year from Galina’s seed like you) and I’m still taste testing and narrowing down what was produced that year. I had 40+ varieties the first year and have narrowed down to about ten now. Of course what you grow on depends a lot on what space you can give them.

To go to your original question, Juliev, I would narrow down to one per cell at some point. If you’re hoping for inky potatoes as in the images on the Airtable base and earlier on this thread, I would narrow down to the ones with darkest stems and leaves but you might want to go for a range. I think potting on after a while before finally planting them out is definitely a good idea so that you’re planting out reasonably strong plants. You can bury them quite deep if they get a bit leggy and that helps to strengthen them too. I love seeing tiny potatoes developing in the pot before planting out! You might find this thread helpful and interesting when I asked similar questions and got advice on early stages in 2020.
https://www.growingfoodsavingseeds.co.uk/forum/main-forum/potatoes/2039-growing-potatoes-from-true-potato-seeds-tps

But I hope you get lots of fun out of them and that Galina and I haven’t complicated matters too much with our enthusiasm! They’re good survivors with a will to grow, even though they look delicate in the early stages.
Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: juliev on April 18, 2024, 10:14:24
Thank you so much Galina and JanG for your advice!
Galina, I remembered reading about the toothpick trick somewhere... turns out it was in one of your posts from the link JanG shared. Haha! I love that forum and I must have read through it several times. It's such a shame it's not that active anymore (and I'm a few years late...).

I'll pot on the seedlings over the next few days, choosing a majority of the darkest stems and just a few greens because I'm curious! (The fact I don't have enough room for the hundreds of seedlings accumulating all over the place is a problem for another day...  :toothy10:)

Title: Re: Seed Saving Circle 2023
Post by: JanG on April 19, 2024, 06:38:54
Thank you so much Galina and JanG for your advice!
Galina, I remembered reading about the toothpick trick somewhere... turns out it was in one of your posts from the link JanG shared. Haha! I love that forum and I must have read through it several times. It's such a shame it's not that active anymore (and I'm a few years late...).

I'll pot on the seedlings over the next few days, choosing a majority of the darkest stems and just a few greens because I'm curious! (The fact I don't have enough room for the hundreds of seedlings accumulating all over the place is a problem for another day...  :toothy10:)

I very much identify with your feeling of flirting with impending chaos over the number of seedlings accumulating - a slightly reckless enjoyment mixed with a pushed away awareness that some culling will have to happen at some point. We can enjoy the profusion for the time being!

And I too regret that GFSS is no longer really active (although it’s possible still to post and you are almost certain to get a response) and that I came a little late, but, as you suggest, it is a mine of useful, interesting, and inspiring content.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal