Allotments 4 All

Allotment Stuff => The Basics => Topic started by: MattBristol on March 02, 2014, 17:52:18

Title: Rotovator/Cultivator advice
Post by: MattBristol on March 02, 2014, 17:52:18
Hi all,

I am thinking about getting a rotovator/digger. They are a bit pricey and wanted to save some cash.

Does anyone have any experience of using this machine? All the reviews are positive but I'm skeptical on the authenticity!

http://www.coopersofstortford.co.uk/coopers-of-stortford-the-micro-light-petrol-tiller-cultivator-prodst08957i/

thanks
Title: Re: Rotovator/Cultivator advice
Post by: goodlife on March 02, 2014, 18:28:52
I can only say it looks like any other light weight cultivator that works best in 'not so compacted' ground...it is definitely not one for turning grass land over.
It all depends what you want the machine for. It will be nifty enough for smaller beds but you will find it very hard work or it won't be able to cope if the land area is larger and/or you need it to go quite deep for proper turn over. It is more of 'surface' cultivator..ideal when all you need is few inches of soil being turned into finer 'mush'.
I don't know about the brand...there is lot of these not so well know brands..some of them being better than others...personally I would be bit sceptical of what they claim of its 'cutting power'. I have one similar..though with bit of more name to it..and its tines are much more robust than those, although I can go quite deep with it..it ain't light work nor I would take it to turn over heavy soil..it would just take forever...I have bigger machine for those situations.
Title: Re: Rotovator/Cultivator advice
Post by: steve76 on March 02, 2014, 19:11:24
I know its not every ones cup of tea but have you tried e-bay??
 I got a old tiller of their for £80, if you do a local search you tend to find they are a bit cheaper as its pick up only,
 i found mine only 10 miles from home had it 2-3 years now and it does my large plot very well.
Title: Re: Rotovator/Cultivator advice
Post by: gavinjconway on March 02, 2014, 19:46:12
Hi all,

I am thinking about getting a rotovator/digger. They are a bit pricey and wanted to save some cash.

Does anyone have any experience of using this machine? All the reviews are positive but I'm skeptical on the authenticity!

http://www.coopersofstortford.co.uk/coopers-of-stortford-the-micro-light-petrol-tiller-cultivator-prodst08957i/

thanks

How big is your plot and do you really need it? Is it an allotment or home garden. It would be a good idea to introduce yourself with some info so we know where you are and whet sort of gardening you do.

Digging is by far the best method. These are light tillers and are really to be used to fluff up pre-dug soil.. If you have bad perennial weeds do not rotavate!!
Title: Re: Rotovator/Cultivator advice
Post by: MattBristol on March 02, 2014, 19:55:19
Hi,

Thanks for the replies. The plot is around 150 sqm. Some of it is grassy and other bits not too bad. The main problem I'm having is with the soil as it seems like a clay grey sludge and when I dig it it's a nightmare trying to break it up into anything! Just comes up in clumps. I guess the recent weather hasn't helped. Also I wanted to save some time as I will end up spending a lot of time down there just digging this clay sludge.

I might need something more heavy duty than the one in the link I put up. I have been keeping my eye on eBay but there's not been anything really suitable yet. :(
Title: Re: Rotovator/Cultivator advice
Post by: ancellsfarmer on March 02, 2014, 20:20:00
This is a tool designed to sell ,not use!
A 230mm width means you will compress more soil as you follow than you disturb.
A entry -level cultivator would have at least a 3.5hp engine and ground braking machines are 6-8HP 4 stroke.
Two stroke means high revving (noisy!) and lack low-down "grunt" for grassland.
My advice,( apart from 150sq yds being only a few hours with a spade!) is
a)wait until the ground dries out (4weeks- no rain?) and if you really need it, hire a bigger machine for 1/2 day. (Locally £45 day)
b) Consider the needs of the plot.Is it compacted/poorly drained/covered in persistant or long vegetation. Remember that many problem weeds such as ground elder, bindweed,couch grass, tagel, all reproduce vegetatively and will love being thoroughly chopped and stirred into all of your soil.
c) Examine the options of spray/burn/mulch and hand digging a little at a time


With apologies to Coopers of Stortford who previously would have considered me a friend!
Title: Re: Rotovator/Cultivator advice
Post by: gavinjconway on March 02, 2014, 20:34:24
Sounds like you sludge needs loads of manure to break it up... so I'm afraid a spade is the only way to go.
Title: Re: Rotovator/Cultivator advice
Post by: goodlife on March 02, 2014, 21:04:06
Sounds like you sludge needs loads of manure to break it up... so I'm afraid a spade is the only way to go.

Yep..until it is drained from excess moisture..it will only clog up any machinery. I would do VERY rough spade work leaving the clumps to be..then get hold of 'good stuff' and spread it around..some of them will fall down into gaps between clumps..once the ground has dried out..then hire decent machine (if you still think it is necessary) and run the clumps over into smaller ones.
Unfortunately when your soil is as it is..there is no 'quick' remedies other than hard labour for year or two... :BangHead:..and copious amounts of 'good stuff'.
Title: Re: Rotovator/Cultivator advice
Post by: MattBristol on March 02, 2014, 23:13:20
so it looks like I might not be growing much this year then if I have to spread a load of muck :( wanted to get straight into it!
perhaps the soil will be better where it's grassy.
Title: Re: Rotovator/Cultivator advice
Post by: gavinjconway on March 03, 2014, 08:15:30
Matt there is still loads of time to get digging and manuring... as soon as the ground dries a bit get stuck in and it wont take long. Have you got manure available? We get horse bedding with poo and it works a treat - it's all fresh stuff and i add a 4" layer then dig it in..
Title: Re: Rotovator/Cultivator advice
Post by: goodlife on March 03, 2014, 08:19:42
Yes you can grow stuff...just don't try to make the soil all 'good' in one go. If the soil sticks to your boots..or on spade..then it just is too wet and it is better not to work with it yet.
Spuds don't mind if the soil is bit 'rough'..so you don't have to worry about getting it tilled fine for those. Runnerbeans..once the soil is workable prepare trench for them and get some old/new compost, manure, grass clippings etc..bit of anything and everything, and back fill the trench with the 'stuff' and the soil mix..if you grow the runner plants in pots and transplant when few inches tall, they will be able find their own way too.

Cabbages/cauli/broccoli etc. they don't mind , actually prefer more of compacted soil..so again..just rough dig for those..and 'heel' the plants in.

You 'only' need to be more thorough with less robust crops and roots..but roots don't want compost or manure around them neither.
If getting hold of 'good stuff' is not easy...get the 'big' crops in according the soil/weather conditions...and carry on working with rest of the area 'as and when..'
I would not bother trying to get 'blank canvas' the first year..unless you really want to..but get some crops in so you some rewards from the land and carry on working and preparing other areas..they will come ready then for later crops..not all are planted in spring.
NEXT YEAR..you soil is already worked over and will become much easier task to 'fine tune' ..and if you are still in mood for 'blank canvas' and rotavating , it will be much easier job.
'Good stuff'(with that I mean various dead plant matter and/or manures) can be added under crops through out the year as mulches where it will feed you crops as well as turn the soil better undernearth  :thumbsup:.
Title: Re: Rotovator/Cultivator advice
Post by: MattBristol on April 02, 2014, 14:05:10
Hi.

thanks for your advice last month (and sorry I didn't reply!).

I've not got a rotovator but I did put some weedkiller down. It's turned alll the grass yellow and killed it off which is great.

Was wondering what would happen if I did rotovate now, will weeds spread by chopping the roots eventhough they've had killer on them?

Was also wondering if I did get some manure how far a tonne would go in sqm (thats the minimum I can get delivered).

cheers!
Title: Re: Rotovator/Cultivator advice
Post by: gavinjconway on April 02, 2014, 14:52:28
Dig it - dont be lazy!!
Title: Re: Rotovator/Cultivator advice
Post by: goodlife on April 02, 2014, 15:01:18
Dig it - dont be lazy!!

 :laughing7:

Matt...if the ground is now 'clear' from live weeds after spraying it...turning it over without having to bend over for picking weeds up is going to be doddle. If the ground is gone 'solid' while its been unused..box standard rotavator is going to struggle turning it over anyway. Unless you get hold of good bit more 'heavy duty' machine, doing it with 'not so heavy one' you have to loosen the soil with fork before the machine is able to tackle the ground..by the time you've done that, fetched the machine, run the soil over few times (which in by no means light job), cleaned machine again and returned it (if borrowed/hired) you might as well get over and done with just a spade.
Only thing you need to 'fuel' the spade is few cups of tea and couple of biccies...they don't taste as nice amongst petrol fumes... :tongue3:
Title: Re: Rotovator/Cultivator advice
Post by: MattBristol on April 02, 2014, 15:05:26
ok you've convinced me, i'll just dig it up. it's hard work but you're right the  :coffee2: will help :)

I guess the dead weeds can now be 'dug in' to the ground and they'll just degrade over time? no need to pull them up?

thanks
Title: Re: Rotovator/Cultivator advice
Post by: MattBristol on April 02, 2014, 15:26:43
you guys ever used one of these before?

http://www.amazon.co.uk/product-reviews/B003KIY8WU/ref=dp_top_cm_cr_acr_txt?ie=UTF8&showViewpoints=1

trying my best to make this digging as pain-free as possible  :tongue3:
Title: Re: Rotovator/Cultivator advice
Post by: gavinjconway on April 02, 2014, 15:46:56
you guys ever used one of these before?

http://www.amazon.co.uk/product-reviews/B003KIY8WU/ref=dp_top_cm_cr_acr_txt?ie=UTF8&showViewpoints=1

trying my best to make this digging as pain-free as possible  :tongue3:

I have one hear at home but its only good for soft soil.. works well tho.
Title: Re: Rotovator/Cultivator advice
Post by: goodlife on April 02, 2014, 16:29:59
ok you've convinced me, i'll just dig it up. it's hard work but you're right the  :coffee2: will help :)

I guess the dead weeds can now be 'dug in' to the ground and they'll just degrade over time? no need to pull them up?

thanks

Yep..what is dead is dead and you can dig them in :icon_thumleft:
Title: Re: Rotovator/Cultivator advice
Post by: goodlife on April 02, 2014, 16:36:10
you guys ever used one of these before?

http://www.amazon.co.uk/product-reviews/B003KIY8WU/ref=dp_top_cm_cr_acr_txt?ie=UTF8&showViewpoints=1

trying my best to make this digging as pain-free as possible  :tongue3:

...that is only to 'fluff up' the surface..more of in ornamental borders...not a tool in for allotment when some serious cultivation is needed.
Digging will be almost pain free if you take care....do some warm ups before you start...don't do too much in one go and do little bit of stretching and other jobs after few rows or when you feel first little tightness coming on.. if you back is not used to digging..it will need to do some alternative movements every so often. And do some more 'warm ups' when you have finished for the day...it truly is good work out and you should treat it like gym session.
Title: Re: Rotovator/Cultivator advice
Post by: MattBristol on April 02, 2014, 17:28:11
Don't think i will bother with it then. I will treat it as a workout. Need some exercise anyway!

Thanks
Title: Re: Rotovator/Cultivator advice
Post by: Ian Pearson on April 02, 2014, 20:24:01
Quite apart from the exercise, digging it will let you get to know the exact characteristics of your soil, and how it varies across the plot.
Title: Re: Rotovator/Cultivator advice
Post by: cacran on April 02, 2014, 20:28:47
I have both a lightweight electric rotovator and a really heavy duty one. I used them both only once. I was told that it was not good to
 use them every year, spreads weeds and spoils the soil. After getting the allotment dugover I now cover each bed in the winter. It kills
most of the weeds. When I  uncover the beds, I use the garden claw. I works a treat. I pull out the few remaining weeds and bash out what few lumps are left with a hoe or back of the rake and roughly rake it over before planting. I am going to sell the big rotovator if anyone is interested.
Title: Re: Rotovator/Cultivator advice
Post by: Melbourne12 on April 10, 2014, 16:50:13
you guys ever used one of these before?

http://www.amazon.co.uk/product-reviews/B003KIY8WU/ref=dp_top_cm_cr_acr_txt?ie=UTF8&showViewpoints=1

trying my best to make this digging as pain-free as possible  :tongue3:

We have two!  As gavinjconway says, it's only good for soft soil, but it works well as a cultivator.  We refer to ours as "twizzlers".  Although they're easier on the lower back than using a fork, you'll feel it in your shoulders the next morning if you've done a hour or two of "twizzling"!
Title: Re: Rotovator/Cultivator advice
Post by: artichoke on April 10, 2014, 18:27:57
I have been admiring a new allotment neighbour who inherited a very neglected plot last week. He sliced off the surface weeds using what he called a mattock (did not see that stage: "Chillington hoe?) and has since been steadily doing heavy digging every day, dragging out bad weeds as he goes. Within a week he has completely dug half the plot (normal size plot, sorry cannot be exact) and put in impressive rows of potatoes. He is 67 and seems tireless. He says the soil is good, so it is better than your sludgy clay - but I bet he would have attacked that with similar vigour. Good luck with it.
Title: Re: Rotovator/Cultivator advice
Post by: BarriedaleNick on April 10, 2014, 19:53:21
I remember when I first had a plot in Tottenham and decided to rotavate it.  I scraped all the surface weeds to uncover a perfect slab of clay (it was an old brickworks) so I hired a heavy duty rotovator.  All it did was to spin round and propel itself forward without actually getting stuck into the clay.  It matter not what pressure I tried to put on it - the dammed  thing would not get stuck into the clay.

As I only had it for a long weekend I had at the soil with my digging hoe or mattock and then had another go.  After a back breaking weekend I did have something that looked like a clear dug plot..

It failed me in the long term though as in my innocence all I had done is spread bine-weed all over the plot!
Title: Re: Rotovator/Cultivator advice
Post by: Golach on April 14, 2014, 19:37:34
Not going to hijack the thread but was going to ask the very same question so save me posting a similar thread.

We've been digging our allotment but find the grass just keeps coming back.  I don't want to use weedkiller.  One of the other allotment holders suggested yesterday that we skim off the top layer of grass then dig over.

I take it Matt's in Bristol (by his nic).  I'm just 35 miles up the road and have the same type of soil.  I know brassicas love it so looking forward to my favourite veg later in the year (cauliflower & broccoli Mornay - yum).

Our council is getting a bit stroppy and in their newsletter (got it last week along with the rent bill - they haven't put the rent up for this year), they're saying they want all the new allotments to be 2/3rds cultivated and things growing in them within 3 months of signing for the allotment or get evicted.  Given the state of the allotments - I took over the first one in September last year, the grass was taller than me - over 5ft and it hadn't been cultivated for donkeys years.

My second allotment I only signed for Christmas week.  It's quite interesting as I've discovered the previous tenant had put down a lot of weed mat and old carpet, which, of course has now been covered by lots of grass.  Growing among the grass are some very nice strawberry plants and some raspberry canes.  Already partly unearthed an obviously very good quality net - just need to find where the rest of it goes as once it's dug up I can use it again.

Found a plastic type tarpaulin covering a mound.  Pulled the tarp away and discovered the biggest ants nest I've ever seen.  it was 2ft high by about 3ft in diameter.  The poor ants were desperately trying to save their eggs.  I did feel a bit sorry for them (black ants) but the nest seemed to be comprised of really good soil, very fine so the ants had done a good job of breaking down the clay soil there. 

I have contemplated rotovating Plot No.1 and my boss can get me a weekend deal at a very reasonable cost with the rotovator delivered and collected but I'm also worried about chopping up the weed roots and ending up with more weeds/grass than I have now.

Did buy an Azada from Get Digging.com and that really is a great digging tool.  Got the heavy duty one.  It's too heavy for me but my son works it.  One of our allotment neighbours showed him how to use it properly.
Title: Re: Rotovator/Cultivator advice
Post by: BarriedaleNick on April 14, 2014, 19:56:10
It is a tricky decision to make.  If you have couch grass (it has thick white roots and shoots up from the roots everywhere) then I'm afraid rotavating is going to cause you grief in the long term as it will grow from a tiny bit of root.  However if you have "normal" grass then it may well be worthwhile as it probably wont regrow if you dig it over properly after skimming over the surface as suggested by your fellow plotholder...


Title: Re: Rotovator/Cultivator advice
Post by: Golach on April 21, 2014, 14:30:24
Yep.  It's couch grass but there is something very satisfying about pulling out a massive root and thinking "That one won't grow again"  :toothy10:
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal