I have only had experience with greengym. I have just looked at the thrive site, The good intentions are there, but as for the gaining qualifications and getting paid work. How can it happen in reality. I could not find a place for a disabled worker, as much as I would like to. The work is physically demanding and the rest of the team would have to carry him/her, which would eventually cause resentment. Also I am sure the less abled person would feel frustrated by being 'helped'.
Don't get me wrong I think Thrive are doing stirling work from what I have just read. But I dont think they should raise peoples expectations. There are quite a few people out there applying for jobs. Which do you think the employer will take on. They will pay lip service to the scheme, but the economics of employing less abled do not add up.
I give up some time now and again to help out the youth offenders team, Encouraging them to do something worthwhile, getting them used to the work ethic etc. At least 80 of them have worked on my 'chaingang' only one of them has managed to get a job through it. They are all decent kids at heart and most of them enjoyed the work, but the firms who 'promised' work never have a place availiable.