Others will probably disagree, but I re-use compost mixed in with fresh stuff and/or composted farmyard manure, and my plants seem to do alright. You will probably need to add extra nutrients sooner than you would with totally fresh compost however. If I don't re-use it though, because I have too much or no need, it goes on the compost heap.
All our "home" grown potatos, in old compost sacks are in re-used compost with added composted farmyard manure, and they are growing really well. It remains to be seen what the yield will be like however.