Two schools of thought on this one...:
Stornoway black pudding from Charles MacLeod Mutchers from Stornoway. They use oatmeal in the mix so you need less black pudding to fil you up. The flavour is more nutty and rich; there's no great lumps of fat and the flavour is sublime. Used by top chefs and an international best seller. Comes in bloomin' large logs 2.5" or 3" diameter x 1 kilo or 2 kilos, plastic casing. Can be frozen (slice it first!)
www.charlesmacleod.co.uk. Their delivery is referidgerated and the ferry leaves the island on a Wednesday so get your order in before then. They make 10's of 1000's and they are still only a small butchers - it's amazing! Also do white pudding, white pudding with fruit, smoked salmon etc. I'd offer to sell you some but can't guarantee the refridgerated delivery! ;D
Bury black pudding. From somewhere up north. Award winning, secret recipe, small loops with 1" approx diameter. Lumps of fat visible and a natural pig's intestine casing.
www.buryblackpuddings.co.uk Last Christmas we converted a life-long, die-hard, raised-on-the-stuff Bury fan to Stornoway and when his parents came down for Christmas he bought some just for them.
Buy some of each and have a taste off - it's the best way to decide.
Try stuffing a pork loin with finely diced, peeled apple & the black pudding of choice, wrapping the closed loin on pancetta or air cured streaky bacon and roasting for 40 mins. Very nice indeed!